3 ms·
Obviously rates and mortgages amplify price increases but they are not the root cause, which is... supply and demand. Prices are driven up because people compe
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
Obviously rates and mortgages amplify price increases but they are not the root cause, which is... supply and demand.
Prices are driven up because people compete to buy a limited stock.
Restrictions on mortgages and higher rates to not necessarily make desirable areas more affordable. The absolute prices might be lower, indeed, but fewer people will also be able to afford the mortgages.
For effective and sustainable affordability there is no alternative to balancing supply and demand.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI don't get the disconnect here. I _am_ talking about the demand curve. The demand for private ownership of housing is driven in many respects by the ability to take out a mortgage loan. This kind of low interest easy to get loan exists for no other type of asset, and is unique to housing, and is in large part a product of macroeconomic state policy. These types of loans are backed in many countries by government insurance. So they are in effect a kind of macroeconomic planning by the state. So it should be no surprise that in countries where the state effectively encourages private home ownership through favourable loans that the demand for private homes is high enough to drive prices high. Obviously there is the supply side to this. I think in some regions, especially the badly planned sprawl that is Silicon Valley, restrictions on density and supply are really a big part of the problem. But it doesn't explain it everywhere. There are regions where construction and density are not similarly restricted that still have high, unaffordable home prices, because demand for single family homes is effectively stimulated by economic policy.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoPrivate ownership vs. renting is quite irrelevant. In the end, affordability whether in terms of property price or rent level will be set by supply and demand. The demand for private homes is driven by people wanting to live in a specific location. Prices are then set according to how that aligns with supply. It is unrealistic to expect every locations to be affordable to everyone. Apart from increasing supply, a remedy is to spread demand. Prices in e.g. London or Silicon Valley are high in part because these are very attractive locations and there are so in part because jobs are concentrated there.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoIn North America, there are few state level macroeconomic policies that encourage demand for rents, apart from the few places where rent control is still in place. There are macroeconomic policies that underwrite and encourage private ownership of single family homes. The two are not equivalent in the real world.
- zamfi 7y ago> This kind of low interest easy to get loan exists for no other type of asset, and is unique to housing, and is in large part a product of macroeconomic state policy. These types of loans are backed in many countries by government insurance. So they are in effect a kind of macroeconomic planning by the state. Not quite unique: this kind of loan is available for college tuition too! Perhaps unsurprisingly, that’s another disaster zone...
- lotsofpulp 7y agoAn even worse kind of loan I'd say. No collateral, no underwriting, only requirements are a business willing to sell a product and a customer willing to buy it.