3 ms·
Virtually eliminating pedestrian fatalities could be quite simple, but we don't do it because it would inconvenience people: Set a 30 km/h (18 mph) speed limi
by bryanlarsen 7y ago
Virtually eliminating pedestrian fatalities could be quite simple, but we don't do it because it would inconvenience people: Set a 30 km/h (18 mph) speed limit everywhere but controlled-access freeways, and enforce it strictly. At 30km/h a car-pedestrian collision is almost always non-fatal[1], and at that speed cars can stop almost instantaneously.
1: https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/relationship_between_speed_risk_fatal_injury_pedestrians_and_car_occupants_richards.pdf https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/relationship_between_speed_risk_...
- noobermin 7y agoThe good news is that cities are starting to finally do this. Slowly, but it is happening.
- dragontamer 7y agoThat means halving the bandwidth of all inner-city roads (that are traditionally at 35mph+) If a road used to carry 1000-cars per hour, it will only carry 500-cars per hour if you drop the speed limit from 35 -> 18. Effectively doubling the length of time for congestion. You can get around this by building twice as many roads I guess, but cities don't really have any more room.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIf there are 2 seconds of distance between cars at 36mph and 2 seconds of distance between cars at 18mph then the road has exactly the same capacity at both speeds. Also, the constraint on street capacity is intersections in the vast majority of cases. Until you remove intersections nothing else really else matters.
- tbihl 7y agoYou're also underselling the intersections part, because getting traffic to intermix at intersections is incredibly easy at 20mph. And, what you've conceptually stated (no loss in capacity) has been empirically demonstrated. Finally, you get vastly different places at 40 mph vs 20mph. At 20, roads are smaller, people can safely exist close to the roadway and even enjoy themselves, and you don't need huge buffer zones for the safety of drivers or people. All these things compound to put people (willingly) in closer proximity to one another, so that, while peak travel speed is lower, traffic throughput stays relatively consistent, and travel times decrease overall because many long trips get replaced with short ones.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoI'm betting that if pedestrians think they are safer, they will interrupt the flow of traffic much more often, which will impact throughput.
- dragontamer 7y agoI don't think people are "timing" their cars, and are instead driving at "car-lengths" worth of distance between the person in front of them If you instead assume 1-car lengths worth of distance at both 36mph and 18mph, the road capacity shrinks dramatically between the two speeds.
- carlmr 7y agoIf that is true, most congestion on my way to work is after an accident. Not having that accident at 30kph is much more likely than not having it at twice the speed, giving the same distance to react and brake.
- clairity 7y agoartificially setting limits like that is a poor solution, especially when you're depending on police enforcement to ensure compliance. a better solution is narrowing lanes (to 9-10 ft), and possibly installing bollards everywhere, because that internalizes the costs of collision (car gets wrecked and you get hurt in addition to pedestrians), so drivers naturally self-regulate driving behavior for safety (rather than the secondary measure, speed). you also don't need an external police force and it's attendant costs, both financially and societally, for enforcement.