5 ms·
This is not something that can be decided by edict. Prices are driven by supply and demand. Highly desirable locations with limited scope to increase supply ha
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
This is not something that can be decided by edict.
Prices are driven by supply and demand. Highly desirable locations with limited scope to increase supply have always been expensive, and will always be expensive.
Oulu is a small place almost literally in the middle of nowhere and extremely North, hardly a property hotspot.
- freeone3000 7y agoOkay but what if we just let people build condos until people stopped buying them?
- tasuki 7y ago> Okay but what if we just let people build condos until people stopped buying them? I guess the question is "let people build condos" ... where? What if there's a natural park? Or what if something is private property and the owner doesn't want you to build there?
- zamfi 7y agoUmm...many cities (SF, NYC, most of California, ...) have plenty of prohibitions on building condos that go far beyond “there’s a natural park there” and “the owner doesn’t want random people building condos on his property”. Zoning laws basically prevent construction of condos even by the owners of the property in like 90% of the Bay Area, if not more...
- cyborgx7 7y ago>Prices are driven by supply and demand. Highly desirable locations with limited scope to increase supply will always be expensive. You know it's possible to regulate prices with laws, do you? The thing you said is not a law of nature, just something we agreed on. And we can change our mind.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoSupply and demand is as close as a 'law of nature' as can be. It is natural human behaviour. Price controls do not work and are actually damaging because instead of trying to balance supply and demand they make the imbalance even worse. They do not remove the pressure of supply and demand, which continues to be at play.
- cyborgx7 7y agoThere are other ways of deciding who gets a valuable resource, like housing in an area that a lot of people want to be in, than giving it to the person with the most money. This defeatism always can drive me nuts.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhat are the other ways?
- pengstrom 7y agoWaiting lists and lotteries are simple solutions which have their own problems sure, but are significantly more fair than by wealth.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoHow does a waiting list or lottery work in practice for housing though? Would people not be able to sell housing? Would they have to sell to the next person on the waiting list? Are children able to inherit it? I'm not trying to be coy, I simply haven't seen a viable alternative with details. And since most of the world converged on using money to decide allocation of resources, I'm wondering if the alternatives have significant drawbacks. I understand that wealth begetting wealth, especially for generations seems unfair. But the solution to that doesn't have to be lottery or waiting list of housing. If the goal is to spread the wealth around more evenly, then that can be accomplished with higher taxes.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoHome prices are driven in large part by the ease of obtaining loans. Interest rates and mortgage policies have a huge effect on housing prices. Bizarre tax policies like the ability for Americans to write off interest on mortgages also certainly don't help. There are governments that intervene directly to keep their housing market cool in order to maintain affordable housing stock for their workers. My understanding is the German state tries to do this, for example, in order to maintain its ability to be a relevant industrial exporter. https://qz.com/167887/germany-has-one-of-the-worlds-lowest-homeownership-rates/ https://qz.com/167887/germany-has-one-of-the-worlds-lowest-h...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoObviously rates and mortgages amplify price increases but they are not the root cause, which is... supply and demand. Prices are driven up because people compete to buy a limited stock. Restrictions on mortgages and higher rates to not necessarily make desirable areas more affordable. The absolute prices might be lower, indeed, but fewer people will also be able to afford the mortgages. For effective and sustainable affordability there is no alternative to balancing supply and demand.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI don't get the disconnect here. I _am_ talking about the demand curve. The demand for private ownership of housing is driven in many respects by the ability to take out a mortgage loan. This kind of low interest easy to get loan exists for no other type of asset, and is unique to housing, and is in large part a product of macroeconomic state policy. These types of loans are backed in many countries by government insurance. So they are in effect a kind of macroeconomic planning by the state. So it should be no surprise that in countries where the state effectively encourages private home ownership through favourable loans that the demand for private homes is high enough to drive prices high. Obviously there is the supply side to this. I think in some regions, especially the badly planned sprawl that is Silicon Valley, restrictions on density and supply are really a big part of the problem. But it doesn't explain it everywhere. There are regions where construction and density are not similarly restricted that still have high, unaffordable home prices, because demand for single family homes is effectively stimulated by economic policy.
- yxhuvud 7y agoSupply of houses and infrastructure is however something that governments can do a lot about, even if they can't impact the demand too much.