3 ms·
The level of political demagoguery surrounding this is really shocking. Gavin Newsom is blaming “dog eat dog capitalism” and “corporate greed” for the wildfires
by rayiner 7y ago
The level of political demagoguery surrounding this is really shocking. Gavin Newsom is blaming “dog eat dog capitalism” and “corporate greed” for the wildfires: https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/Newsom-PG-E-SoCal-utilities-undermined-14560015.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/california-wildfires/article/New...
Of course, PG&E is the kind of regulated entity people like Newsom wish all corporations were. Private investors put up the capital to build and maintain the electric grid. The government, through the California Public Utility Commission, tells them what to spend it on: https://www.pge.com/en_US/about-pge/company-information/regulation/general-rate-case/grc.page https://www.pge.com/en_US/about-pge/company-information/regu.... The CPUC reviews PG&E’s proposed expenditures and approves the resulting electric rates. The CPUC then allows PG&E to set rates high enough to recover a 10% profit on that expenditure.[1]
Under that regime, PG&E’s incentive is to spend more money gold plating the electric grid. The more it spends, the more profit it makes. The reason PG&E didn’t spend more money on wild fire safety is because the CPUC is run by political appointees and they have strong incentives to keep electric rates low in the short term. (This is a common problem with rate regulated utilities. They underinvest in infrastructure because voters demand low rates for electric, water, etc.)
Now of course, California doesn’t have the money to build its own electric grid. So Newsom is calling on Buffett to bail out PG&E. I.e. let different private investors take in the risk and expense of the CPUC’s years of short sighted behavior.
And, of course, this is the kind of thing that only happens in America, and maybe some third world countries. Not because Europe doesn’t have investor owned utilities. They are common. Some of the largest grid operators in Germany are private companies. Rather, it seems to be the result of the unique political dysfunction in the US. American politicians and their voters live in a fantasy land where they can literally say the grass is blue and the sky is green because that fits into their narratives about the world.
[1] That’s about what it works out to. It’s a more complicated rate return calculation: https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/uploadedFiles/CPUCWebsite/Content/About_Us/Organization/Divisions/Office_of_Governmental_Affairs/Legislation/2018/California%20Electric%20And%20Gas%20Utility%20Cost%20Report.pdf https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/uploadedFiles/CPUCWebsite/Content/Ab....
- taurath 7y agoAll this to say, it’s the governments fault for allowing PG&E to have the incentives it does. And I’d agree with you to an extent, but the solution being privatizing it and deregulating the power system is... maybe not the best. Corporations almost always have the same incentive structure as what you’re saying the CPUC has, short term profits over long term. The only difference is that rates would be higher along with PG&Es profits, since nobody would go in and build a second power grid and they’d have a de facto monopoly.
- rayiner 7y agoI’m not suggesting we deregulate the transmission grid. My point is that PG&E is heavily regulated, and the government should take responsibility for the consequences of its regulatory choices. For decades, PG&E submitted detailed rate cases to the CPUC saying; “here is what we plan to invest in, here is how much it will cost, and here is what rates will have to be to pay for it.” Given that PG&E would make more money by investing in safety upgrades, the only reason they wouldn’t have done it is because the CPUC pressured them to forgo such investments to keep rates low. (That’s a common concern for rate regulated monopolies: they have an incentive to “gold plate” the network because they make more money the more they spend.) The PG&E model works well in the rest of the world. It’s how the electric grid works in the UK, and most of Germany. In France and Spain the electric grid is operated by a for profit corporation, albeit one where the government is a shareholder (majority stake in France, minority stake in Spain). Indeed, many people espouse using the same model for broadband in the US. That proven model is not working in California because the politics is completely dysfunctional. There is zero accountability.
- hcurtiss 7y agoMan I wish more people understood this. Newsom hanging this on PG&E is so extraordinarily cynical. There's a need for some humility here. If we don't want power blackouts, we're going to need to spend a lot of money to create bigger breaks, put certain lines underground, etc. And that money is probably going to have to come from ratepayers (if you cut off the rate of return to the investors, you will have no more investors). Of course, ratepayers aren't going to like that very much, and the green energy advocates are going to have more difficulty pushing their agenda. No, better to just pray Warren Buffet bails you out. It's like an episode of Family Guy.