3 ms·
Much like the founding father's rational behind impeachment, if this was ever to come about, this type of thing should be strictly limited to "high crimes" and
by dmix 7y ago
Much like the founding father's rational behind impeachment, if this was ever to come about, this type of thing should be strictly limited to "high crimes" and only when it clearly benefits the individual.
Otherwise it opens up any executive to tons of personal risk by taking a leadership role in any major public company with any sort of consumer liability. Or worse getting punished for subordinates behaviour with some idealistic perspective on what the executives show be in control of.
That type of arrangement would likely result in worse executives who are more risk-friendly. While the ones who are careful and averse to risk would stay in a non-executive position with very low risk that kicks upstairs or only take the safe executive jobs (even if the cases are likely to fail in court).
This will create a booming workplace legal insurance industry that will cover downside risks of lawyer costs and loss of income going into prison. Which helps minimize the disincentives this sort of thing would need to create to be effective.
I'm open to these ideas but there really has to be some serious conditions thought out.
- ArtDev 7y agoNumerous industries go about "business as usual" with zero considerations for human life. The Opioid Pharma trials are the closest thing to justice I have seen in my lifetime. I do hope this is a positive step towards corporate accountability. God knows we severely need it in the US.
- blunte 7y agoThis might dissuade some bad actors: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_Xiaoyu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zheng_Xiaoyu http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-01/23/content_7422983.htm http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-01/23/content_742298...
- autoexec 7y agoThe effect of the death penalty as a deterrent has been studied and found lacking. It seems once you hit a certain threshold of "bad for me" worse punishments like capital punishment don't perform any better. Still, it's not often that I get to say that the Chinese government has the right idea even if in this case they take it too far which is more what I'd expect from them.
- blunte 7y agoDeath penalty as a deterrent may generally be true, but I do believe it would be more effective against white collar executives who often have an obsession with building their private legacies. The thought of an early death as consequence of cheating to reach the top would cause some to consider a slightly more legal/ethical path on their climb.
- myrion 7y agoBut isn't it regularly an argument for the absurd executive salaries that they have to shoulder so much responsibility and risk? Seems to me that they wouldn't have it both ways...
- dmix 7y agoThe risk of going to jail was never in those arguments so I’m not sure how that’s useful. This is a new conversation about adding risks never seen in the history of business outside of explicit fraud and criminal behaviour.
- autoexec 7y ago> Otherwise it opens up any executive to tons of personal risk by taking a leadership role in any major public company with any sort of consumer liability. I think executives should be at major personal risk when their companies do things that cause injury or death to many people. It will force them to make sure that the people under them are following the rules and that their products are safe. Mistakes will surely happen and I don't think we should ignore it when a company who makes every reasonable effort to protect their customers still fails and people are hurt. That shouldn't necessarily get them off the hook entirely but it should matter. In cases where it's more obvious like in the case of the tobacco industry intentionally misleading customers about the risks of their product, or the auto industry selling cars they know are dangerous, or this one where the company was well aware of the problem but did nothing in order to protect their bottom line they should very clearly be held responsible. I'm not sure that holding executives responsible for clear exploitation would make them more likely to take risks. It seems to me that as long they know they wont be held accountable for killing people they'll be more likely to do it. Companies would also be less likely to promote reckless people if they knew doing so could mean they might face a corporate death penalty. I do agree however that the specifics of who to hold accountable and to what extent they are punished are complicated issues. We've had decades of examples showing it's far past time we put in the work to come up with something however.
- petre 7y agoThat's why we need proper whistleblower protection laws.
- autoexec 7y ago100% agreed. The increasing attacks on whistleblowers from government down to private industries like agriculture show that there's a lot of sickness being covered up and allowed to grow in the dark. Keeping people from speaking out against the abuses they see certainly won't make anything better.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoHigh risk, high reward; low risk, low reward is supposed to be how it goes. So what are the multi million dollar pay packets for if there is no risk? We can't keep turning a blind eye to the hundreds of outrageous examples of ignoring health impacts and lying in public whilst the real facts are in a filing cabinet at head office. Frankly the law should have changed dramatically after discovery of Thomas Midgley and tetra-ethyl lead, "the science on smoking and health isn't settled", or Bhopal etc. We have centuries of proof there aren't adequate consequences. > getting punished for subordinates behaviour That's what leadership is. Responsibility for those under you on your watch. If you fired or prosecuted them on first discovery, that forms a decent proportion of mitigating circumstance. Perhaps you'll still be found negligent for not having adequate checks and balances to prevent it happening in the first place...
- SamReidHughes 7y agoBut there's also been plenty of bogosity running around, about dangers of butter vs. margarine, eggs and cholesterol, trans fats, high-fructose corn syrup, GMO's, acid rain, vaccines, whole milk, small screens, video games, pornography, and certain kinds of radioactivity. Tons of companies would love to outlaw their competitors.
- blunte 7y agoYou're just further illustrating how corrupt American capitalism is. It just happens to be directed at competitors instead of the general public.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoDo we want a chance of a working system, or just accept fraud all the way down? At least some of those examples are tied up with one industry spinning up misleading studies to make money by known false messages of margarine over butter or sugar vs fat etc. Chances are Nestle, Kraft and Coke or whoever have dozens of studies they didn't reveal sitting in the filing cabinet before they got the couple that gave the misleading results they needed to make a ton more money. It's nearly always the case that when we find out years or decades later, "they knew" and actually had extensive investigation on the topic - but chose not to care, or found a way to actively brief against the public interest, rather than it had simply never occurred to them to look or an innocent mistake was made. No, it generally turns out they have pretty extensive science and studies, just very very selective about what they let on about. Maybe there's a high profile spokes-PhD or two and everyone spends decades believing the problem is fat not sugars and apparently there are no consequences. If the company and execs, and past execs were held accountable, and had a duty of care to customers and public, perhaps their past bullshit, PR lies, and talking bollocks under Congressional Committee oath (I believe one was "We don't believe tobacco is addictive" from assorted CEOs under oath) can come back to haunt them. What would match with 2 years CEO jail time for the corporate-personhood? 2 years delisting and forfeit of dividends or profit? That might focus investors and execs on appropriate board integrity a little more... :) Is it really that old-fashioned to think there should be consequences for those who cheat even if they hide behind a corporation? Back when I was a director I actually gave a shit about us being honest, offering an honest service, and holding the staff to the same standard - especially when they were talking on the company's behalf.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoI guess you forgot the whole "and misdemeanors" part of their opinion on impeachment. They never intended for Presidents to be above the law. Quite the opposite, to the point that Presidents had an entirely additional set of restrictions, from citizenship status to emoluments. They'd be shocked and disgusted that so few Presidents in the years since have been impeached.