5 ms·
Whatsapp still processes complex data from any stranger in the world entirely without a sandbox. It's E2E encryption is like sending and receiving messages w
by londons_explore 7y ago
Whatsapp still processes complex data from any stranger in the world entirely without a sandbox. It's E2E encryption is like sending and receiving messages with a top security truck, but then on arrival, storing them in a tent.
The fault here really relies on the design of whatsapp. Not the thieves who saw an open door.
- tptacek 7y agoThat's... not how culpability works.
- darawk 7y agoThe fact that you leave your door unlocked doesn't excuse someone burglarizing your house. Facebook and Whatsapp totally deserve blame for lax security here, but that does absolutely nothing to absolve NSO of exploiting that weak security.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- olliej 7y agoLet's look at a house analogy: * If I leave the door unlocked is someone entering it and taking my property my fault? According to insurance companies it often is, but not the law. Who's side are you on? * If I've locked the door, but there's a window that doesn't latch properly, is it my fault? * If my door doesn't have a kick plate, is it my fault for not providing adequate security? * if they break the windows, is it my fault for not having bars on my windows? Making software secure is hard, but saying that the existence of any bug instantly means that the software manufacturer is culpable for how someone [ab?]uses those flaws is clearly nonsense. No one wants to deliver software with bugs in it, but NSO is clearly ok using those flaws to attack and kill reporters and HRAs.
- saagarjha 7y agoWhat kind of sandbox should WhatsApp have used?
- olliej 7y agoA magic one that fixes all security holes of course :) More seriously: I thought they popped WhatsApp on iOS as well? That would imply sandbox escape there as well - although the default iOS sandbox is more a quarry :)
- tedunangst 7y agoRooting an iphone is certainly useful, but just having access to all of a target's WhatsApp messages would also be very interesting to NSO's customers. Further, WhatsApp likely has permission to access photos, etc.
- kd3 7y agoI tend to agree with op. Surely the NSO has blame but the real problem is the hole in WhatsApp and the fact that their security could use serious improvement. They even allow making backups of the unencrypted database to the cloud defeating the whole e2e encryption.
- Buge 7y ago>Whatsapp still processes complex data from any stranger in the world entirely without a sandbox. Isn't that also the case with every phone and desktop email client?