3 ms·
I suppose "smurfing" means, you create a new account, to pretend that you are a new player and therefore get into matches with only newbs? So the motivation is
by hutzlibu 7y ago
I suppose "smurfing" means, you create a new account, to pretend that you are a new player and therefore get into matches with only newbs?
So the motivation is to feel good at winning against not experienced players?
- jtms 7y agoYes, that’s exactly right. They just want to feel like gods as they stomp the new players.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> So the motivation is to feel good at winning against not experienced players? Contrast online matchmaking systems that take your assessed skill level into account. These are certainly... widespread. I don't understand why. The design goal of such a system is that, no matter what your skill level is, you win or lose at a rate indistinguishable from chance. Are you getting better at the game? Doesn't matter; your win rate is constant. Are you getting worse under lack of pressure, since nothing you do affects your performance? Doesn't matter. Nothing you do can affect your performance. Your win rate is constant; the system will seamlessly swap in weaker players to play against you. If I'm improving at something, I want to see better results than I was getting before. If I'm getting worse, I want to see worse results.
- Double_a_92 7y agoThe problem is that the more skill you have, the more effort you need to put in while playing. So if you get too good you can't have a fun relaxed game anymore (without getting wrecked and losing rank). Smurfing (playing on lower rank) or cheating (playing effortlessly at your real rank) would be a solution for that... but they are obviously bad and unfair for others. The new scrimmage mode seems to be a promising solution for that though.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoYou appear to be describing a completely different problem than I am.
- hoseja 7y agoWhat else would you do in an MMO? The flip side is that with matchmaking, higher level matches are higher quality and more enjoyable too.
- rebuilder 7y agoDo grandmasters play chess against beginners? I think most people want to be challenged, and playing with others of similar skill seems to be the norm in most games.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Do grandmasters play chess against beginners? All the time. They teach people to play; they do stunts like playing against 5 people at once; they sit in the park and take all comers. If you want to prove you're good, go and fight someone who's known to be good. But that generates information for other people, not for you. If you want to determine how good you are, you need to fight a lot of different people.
- rebuilder 7y agoVery good, I chose a poor example. You can see the point I'm making, though?
- thaumasiotes 7y agoNo, I can't. All three examples I gave correspond to arguments advanced in this thread as to why you might want to smurf. They teach people to play -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21393157 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21393157 > If you play with a friend who has a low rank, it is much easier to create a free now account (that will start in a low skill group) than it is to obtain one for them which is already in a higher skill group. They do stunts like playing against 5 people at once -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21394927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21394927 > you can essentially carry your entire team to victory because your skill level is so much higher than the enemy. You get to fuck up a bunch of newbs and win the game, while your team mates are drooling at spawn. They sit in the park and take all comers -- I've been pushing this angle myself: > If you want to determine how good you are, you need to fight a lot of different people. I'm arguing that the idea of matchmaking according to assessed skill level is inherently flawed, and smurfing is a natural workaround to this self-inflicted problem.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The design goal of such a system is that, no matter what your skill level is, you win or lose at a rate indistinguishable from chance. Actually, if you are improving you will do better than even, if you are getting worse you will do worse—those are the signals for upward or downward movement. When you plateau it should be a coin flip. > If I'm improving at something, I want to see better results than I was getting before. While you are improving, you will. Roughly, your win rate reflects the derivative of skill.
- IMTDb 7y ago> If I'm improving at something, I want to see better results than I was getting before. If I'm getting worse, I want to see worse results. This is why games using those matchmaking system will give you either MMR (Match Making Rank) points based on you performance. When you win, you "earn" points, and will face stronger opponents (to keep you around 50% victory). And when you loose you will "spend" points to go back to 50% victory on average. The process is very similar to ELO in chess. So you have a visual indication that you are on the right or wrong path and where you are in terms of skill level compared to other players. Most game also offer some vanity system, where your character is displayed differently according to the skill level you have reached (Eg: bottom 20% is bronze, 20%-40% is silver, 40-60% is gold, 60-80% is platinum, 80-95% diamond, top 5% is master, and top 1000 players overall are grand master). Players then fight to reach the next level, still with around 50% win-lose rate until they reach the very top or the very bottom).
- chmod775 7y ago> If I'm improving at something, I want to see better results than I was getting before. If I'm getting worse, I want to see worse results. If you win you get a higher ranking.