I don't think those figures are really meaningful. What about the mushroom cloud of new and different bands who are all unsigned, all selling CDs and shirts, an

I don't think those figures are really meaningful. What about the mushroom cloud of new and different bands who are all unsigned, all selling CDs and shirts, and booking shows, etc, while the giants fall? Those are the growth areas, not the giants. It's easier to measure the downfall of the giant and say that's what's happening to "music," but really what we're looking at is corporate revenue. We need a better way to measure the actual music industry, instead of just the dying players who used to dominate it.