3 ms·
>In a just system, the RIAA would be able to sue for me for damages amounting to revenue lost - $20 per film they catch me downloading. I would like to preface
by AlexandrB 16y ago
>In a just system, the RIAA would be able to sue for me for damages amounting to revenue lost - $20 per film they catch me downloading.
I would like to preface this by saying that I don't like the RIAA. The damages they can sue for ARE disproportionate and copyright law is currently massively unbalanced (e.g. never-ending copyright since the 1920s).
BUT, have you actually thought about what suing for $20/film would mean? To recover any meaningful losses hundreds of thousands of people would have to be sued at once - unless civil law is radically changed this would not be economical, effectively making copyrights non-enforceable. Not to mention that "downloading" isn't actually covered by copyright law AFAIK and it's the uploading (distributing) part they are suing for.
Also, note that enforcement in cases of property theft isn't proportional either - it's not "pay for the thing you stole and you're free to go". There are often other consequences (community service/fines/light jailtime) attached.