3 ms·
Passive discrimination is still discrimination. Changing the terminology doesn't change the reality. Which is why it's not a bad idea to stick close to the bas
by shadowgovt 7y ago
Passive discrimination is still discrimination. Changing the terminology doesn't change the reality.
Which is why it's not a bad idea to stick close to the base HTML spec unless you have a real good reason to deviate from it or use advanced features, JavaScript based animation, etc. Because HTML is a document format not a render format, staying close to home on the spec gives you a lot of accessibility for free. Not all of it, images of course are still just binary blobs without more metadata, but you cover a lot of ground.
A website in flash got approximately zero of that for free, and it was a known issue in that era. Accessibility suffered.
- AndrewUnmuted 7y agoChanging the reality should absolutely change the terminology, though. Almost nobody writes software where assistive accessibility is both legally required and discriminatory when it is not provided. That's an outrageous statement to make that you should back up with evidence, not just platitudes. The software developers who write the systems that stabilize airplanes in the sky, track radio emissions from space, monitor the nuclear reactor cores in power plants, and encode raw YUV video into tightly-compressed packets that can be transmitted over the web, all lack access assistance code. Why don't we go ahead and take these horrible people to task for discriminating against people who need to have their damned screens read to them aloud by software? Seriously, I and almost everyone else on Hacker News have never THOUGHT ONCE about assistive access in our code, and you are a shitty person if you want to call us all discriminators.
- shadowgovt 7y agoTwo things: a) the context of the entire conversation is Flash and the web. If you can point me to developers that are writing airplane autopilots, astronomy signal processors, reactor core monitors (oh God), or video compressors in Flash, you are welcome to bring those categories into the conversation. b) you're applying moral judgement to a statement of fact. I'm not. Everyone discriminates. There is no such thing as universally-accessible software (if nothing else, it fails the first test "Not everyone has hardware to run it"). The reasons we discriminate and the consequences of that discrimination are what matter. I'm personally against the casual, thoughtless discrimination that can result from declaring the HTML render model "too hard" and throwing up one's hands without considering how all relevant user agents that can consume the model do, but if one has considered those user agents (and the users behind them), it can be a valid decision a company can make. ... all of that having been said, for at least the set of developers whose primary target is "the web," not having thought once about assistive access is a mark of an amateur. You can cover a lot of ground in this industry as an amateur, but you'll be held to a higher standard by huge swaths of potential jobs (banks care, universities care, government websites care, consumer websites that do enough business to notice if they lose ~2% of users care). And the nice thing about HTML as a technology is that more often than not, if you do almost nothing, you'll cover 90% of use cases for assistive access.
- AndrewUnmuted 7y ago> for at least the set of developers whose primary target is "the web," Oh yes, one target of dozens! Perhaps the only one where this entire conversation of assisted-access technology even matters. Thinking that software development === HTML & javascript is a truer mark of an amateur.
- shadowgovt 7y agoSee (a). My opinions change if we aren't talking about websites intended for public consumption.
- watersb 7y agoOhhh, I came really close to finding that astronomy signal processor that I wrote in Flash in 1999, but nope. (No, of course it didn't go into production; Flash VM was way more complicated than the custom hardware we were using. I did a Flash one because I wanted to see if I understood some of the details, and wanted a little animation. I didn't. I learned a few things, though.) No points. Dang.