5 ms·
Self-driving got taken over by the "fake it til you make it" crowd. Uber, Cruise (go find Cruise's original demo video and marketing claims), Tesla, etc. Only G
by Animats 7y ago
Self-driving got taken over by the "fake it til you make it" crowd. Uber, Cruise (go find Cruise's original demo video and marketing claims), Tesla, etc. Only Google/Waymo approached it as a hard problem, and only Waymo has something that's deployed, even in a limited way, without a "safety driver".
Somebody will probably make it work, but it may come from some boring old company like Ford or Continental or Fujitsu.
A background in webcrap has negative value in this area, as it does in avionics.
- samuell 7y agoEinride got driverless trucks running on a public road: https://insideevs.com/news/350293/autonomous-einride-t-pod-public-road/ https://insideevs.com/news/350293/autonomous-einride-t-pod-p...
- reaperducer 7y agoAnd Las Vegas had driverless mini-buses running around downtown for about a year. Not anymore because funding ran out. https://lasvegassun.com/news/2018/apr/05/how-does-downtowns-autonomous-bus-work/ https://lasvegassun.com/news/2018/apr/05/how-does-downtowns-...
- Animats 7y ago"a short distance on a public road within an industrial area – between a warehouse and a terminal – where traffic speeds are typically low".
- ezzzzz 7y agoI honestly wouldn't be surprised if these 'Auto-Pilot' cars are actually being controlled remotely from some off-shore ops center.
- jandrese 7y agoIn fact at least one company is looking into this, having the car self-navigate as much as possible, but when confronted with a difficult situation like construction or debris in the road it would call back to a remote operator who would take over until you are past the difficult situation. They also saved the operators response so when the next car hits the same obstacle and calls back the next operator can just repeat the same solution. I thought it was a good idea, but somewhat more expensive since you have to keep a big call center running and it depends on having reliable and fast internet connectivity at all times. The alternative is what everybody else is doing where you have to have a full set of controls and a licensed driver behind the wheel ready to take over when the AI runs into a situation it can't handle.
- bllguo 7y agointeresting, but what a terrifying job that would be. dealing with life-or-death scenarios all day long. and the liability questions would become even more complex
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoI think it really becomes a question of what to do when the computer senses it is getting into a scenario that it can not handle with a reasonable confidence %. You wouldn't flash hand-off the car from auto-drive to the operator without some basic safety measures also occurring. One of those will be slowing (or stopping if possible) the car until the remote operator takes over. You won't hand the human "the bag" (responsibility) after the computer gets you totally up shit creek and you have no chance to effect a positive outcome. It will hand over "the bag" when the "we are getting up shit creek incrementally" value crosses some accepted safe threshold. (Didn't mean to ramble.)
- jandrese 7y agoYes, the AI did come to a stop before ringing up the support desk for assistance. The example video showed a construction site where the entire road was blocked off and the way through was to drive on the shoulder past the construction. However, in the demo the road was completely empty otherwise, which I didn't think was terribly realistic. The memory feature in particular was only useful as a convenience to the next operator, it didn't help the AI become any more self-sufficient.
- ezzzzz 7y agoI don't know enough about ML to comment with any authority, but I think this approach makes sense. Your call-center ops people would provide real-time QA (i.e. make sure the machines aren't killing people) as well as provide training data for your model. If this were in fact the approach, I'd be much more receptive to the promise of 'Autonomous Vehicles'. I for one, refuse to believe the hype that real-time distributed computer vision applications are 'nearly solved'. Consider the amount of variables (pedestrians, pot-holes, un-marked lanes, obstructed signage, other drivers etc etc) at play here...
- whenanother 7y agoI will take what is automation really is for 1000.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]