3 ms·
> ...and in some cases even trying to blame the observatory for "transmitting" But doesn't it transmit? Most radio receivers use the superheterodyne principle
by GuB-42 7y ago
> ...and in some cases even trying to blame the observatory for "transmitting"
But doesn't it transmit?
Most radio receivers use the superheterodyne principle, where the idea is to combine the signal from the antenna with another one that is generated by the receiver. As a result radio receivers tend to emit signals close to the frequency they are tuned for.
Note that I don't believe that electrosensitivity is anything but psychological. I am just curious to know if there is at least some truth in that statement.
- ajford 7y agoGreen Bank Observatory does not intentionally transmit, and any leakage would hardly exist for long, since the whole point is to listen to extremely weak signals. However, a radio telescope differs from your usual radio receiver in that the stages are often separated by vast distances. I'm unfamiliar with the exact signal chain used in GBT, but I do have plenty of experience with a similar scale telescope, the Arecibo Radio Observatory. A radio telescope will go to huge lengths to reduce the system noise of the receiving elements, including cryogenically cooling the receiver and first few stages of amplification. These signals will then often be brought down within a shielded enclosure (often within a shielded receiver room) and shifted into their intermediate frequency (IF) stage with a highly pure local oscillator (LO) signal and brought back down to the control/electronics building. In the case of both GBT and Arecibo, that IF is brought down as modulated light over fiber optics, meaning that there is no RFI leakage possible on the transport. And at both, the conversion back to IF is done within a shielded room. At GBT, if I remember correctly, that room is within the Jansky Lab, which was designed as a shielded building. All of this is to say that it's very unlikely that there is any signal at all transmitting out of the telescope system in any way.
- Doxin 7y agoJust noting that a superheterodyne receiver doesn't transmit on purpose, it's just mostly that it generates an internal frequency reference some multiple of the target frequency that has a tendency to leak out. For a normal radio this isn't too relevant as the signal isn't particularly strong or in a frequency range where it'll mess with anything. As a bit of an aside: The intermediate frequency leaking is how the police can detect if you're using a radar detector (for avoiding tickets from speed cameras for instance). Of course listening to a faint signal like that is best done with a superheterodyne receiver, so there are radar detectors that detect if the police are using a radar detector detector nearby, which is then in turn of course called a radar detector detector detector. wikipedia has some more info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar_detector#Counter_technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar_detector#Counter_technol...