4 ms·
I always thought one of the biggest plusses of the early web was that you didn’t have to hire a graphic artist and designers in order to publish. In fact best p
by ryandrake 7y ago
I always thought one of the biggest plusses of the early web was that you didn’t have to hire a graphic artist and designers in order to publish. In fact best practice was just don’t worry about whether it’s pixel perfect.. just publish your data and organize it into headers and paragraphs. The browser will display it however the user wants it displayed. If that means turning your links orange, that’s fine. If it means displaying it as fixed width green text in a 40x25 terminal, that’s fine too. If the user wanted a textured brick wall background, fine, let them. If it would be read through a screen reader, great!
Later, the designers showed up and started abusing <table> and <img> and body background, thinking the web was a word processor or Photoshop, and everything started going to hell. Now we have JavaScript and <canvas> and I as a user have pretty much lost all control over my browser. It’s just been handed over to the web site publisher, who tries to get rid of my scroll bars and worries whether some element is rendered 3 or 6 pixels wide on different browsers.
In my view, we sacrificed a lot at the altar of “predictable layout”.
- dleslie 7y agoIn the very early days, before Flash, making a website was a difficult proposition. HTML was an esoteric structural markup language, and much of the effort of early browsers was focused on "correcting" mistakes made by individuals attempting to build websites. <map> was the true monstrosity, <table> and <img> were improvements upon it, but were burdened by padding and margins added by early browsers that were difficult to modify and retain consistency. The situation hasn't really improved much; creating a website nowadays is a matter of dedicating yourself to a custom content platform, like Blogger/Squarespace/Wordpress, or learning the arcane language of HTML+CSS+JS. That's a far cry from the drag, drop, click, publish or share of Flash. Just how does an individual create a .EXE of their animation/game/document and send it via email, nowadays?
- mattmcknight 7y agoHave you forgotten Dreamweaver and Front Page? You didn't need to write HTML directly.
- dleslie 7y agoThose were almost contemporary, almost, with Flash. There was also plenty of websites made by exporting HTML from Word. They also weren't nearly as good as Flash at creating layout and appearance that would be consistent on all browsers.
- grawprog 7y agoI had forgotten about it. That takes me back though. My mom made a website using Dreamweaver way way back to post stories she'd written. She was so excited about it and the fact that she'd been able to do it all herself. It was fairly tasteful as far as sites from that era went, There were only one or two animated gifs at the top and the background was pretty easy on the eyes.
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> I as a user have pretty much lost all control over my browser. > It’s just been handed over to the web site publisher This is an illusion. It is a fact that the evolution of the web as a medium empowered publishers with more control. However, the browser is running on our computers. The truth is we let them have control. We trusted the publishers and allowed execution of foreign code on our machines. We gave them that power. We can take it away. It began with popup blockers. Then people created ad and script blockers. Now we have general content blockers. I bet one day people are going to make GPL'd custom clients for popular websites.
- jerf 7y ago"I bet one day people are going to make GPL'd custom clients for popular websites." People do, it's just hard to do so against any website that has an incentive to prevent you from creating a third-party custom clients, which is every site that serves advertising, which is... uhh... basically the internet. But, see Hacker News: https://play.google.com/store/apps/collection/cluster?clp=ggENCgtoYWNrZXIgbmV3cw%3D%3D:S:ANO1ljLdfVU&gsr=ChCCAQ0KC2hhY2tlciBuZXdz:S:ANO1ljK0-98 https://play.google.com/store/apps/collection/cluster?clp=gg... (At least, I hope that link sends you to a search on "Hacker News" on the Google Play Store. If not, well... search for "Hacker News".)
- matheusmoreira 7y agoIf people can build and maintain huge ad blocking databases, I don't see why custom clients and APIs for sites would be out of reach. For example, youtube-dl has handlers for specific sites, gets constantly updated to deal with changes and has a generic video scraper it falls back on. I posted about this idea on reddit and someone showed me this: https://weboob.org/ https://weboob.org/ Something like this could change the web.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoExcept this time around, browsers are on the side of the publishers[0]. They keep removing useful functionality that gave users control, while adding more and more ways for publishers to impose their will on people. And every now and then you get blatant attempts at neutering the users' decisions, like e.g. Chrome's recent extension API changes. [0] - Except maybe Firefox, but it has to follow Chrome on most things to stay relevant.
- tracker1 7y agoI've been building web applications since 1996, I don't really recall what you are describing ever really being the case in my own experience. Yeah, I could push back on some variance of "pixel perfect" as a meme, but in the end it really needed to be very close to as-designed. Before CSS became the norm (early 00's), it wasn't much fun at all on that side of the fence.