5 ms·
I don't understand your theory of how the internet has "lifted so many people out of poverty". I'm not saying I disagree with it necessarily, I don't even unde
by jrochkind1 7y ago
I don't understand your theory of how the internet has "lifted so many people out of poverty".
I'm not saying I disagree with it necessarily, I don't even understand what you're suggesting enough to disagree or agree with it. It's definitely not _obvious_ to me that the internet has somehow lifted so many people out of poverty, I just don't understand what you mean.
- ThomPete 7y agoCreated jobs, increased global trade, allowed for people to teach themselves, new types of products available, higher awareness about what is going on around you, technology share, open source, free products etc.
- jrochkind1 7y agoOK. Except for possibly "created jobs", it's not obvious to me most of those things lead to "lifting so many people out of poverty." (For instance, I suspect very strongly that "new types of products available" has nothing to do with lifting people out of poverty). I am gonna want some analysis based on actual numbers of some kind that shows the internet did those things, and it lifted so many people out of poverty. (For starters, I don't even know if fewer people are "in poverty" now than pre-internet or not!)
- _jgdh 7y agoIncreasing global trade leads to better outcomes for those producing those goods. The greatest alleviation of poverty and creation of the largest middle class in the history of humanity happened in China starting the early 90s and that was fuelled by increased global trade made possible partly by the Internet.
- airstrike 7y ago> I suspect very strongly that "new types of products available" has nothing to do with lifting people out of poverty Your suspicion is wrong. GDP per capita has increased significantly in emerging markets where cheap labor creates these "new types of products", with China being the prominent example > I don't even know if fewer people are "in poverty" now than pre-internet or not! That is a well known fact, you'll just have to google it. > I am gonna want some analysis based on actual numbers of some kind that shows the internet did those things There are countless analyses on the benefits of globalization which was enabled in part by the advance of near-instantaneous telecommunication
- ThomPete 7y agoThe invention of how to create fire or the wheel also created a bunch of jobs but also allow warmongers and thieves and murdering pyros to do their evil deeds. Every innovation has consequences short and long term.
- winternett 7y agoThese jobs are shrinking as low level apps get dumbed down... The process of creating a simple web site has gotten much much more complex as scripting languages have changed. I still can't believe we're compiling code for simple phone and web sites and apps. Corporations have lobbied to take away Net Neutrality, and to institute throttling and make running a personal web site much more expensive. Social media sites de-prioritize regular users under corporate (paid) marketing posts... These days you have to pay to be seen, the Internet was originally based on having everyone on an equal playing field, and now everything is being based around the new rules to prevent us from going back. The Internet is becoming less effective because it's no longer an equal playing field. Its becoming much more expensive and complex over time to run an independent web presence, when in the past it was simple and inexpensive, I think that's the major issue.
- cle 7y agoThe Internet is changing because people who use it are changing it. This is what happens with tools. The Internet’s current state is a reflection of our societal values, which I think is what you’re really decrying.
- criddell 7y ago> The Internet’s current state is a reflection of our societal values, which I think is what you’re really decrying. I wish that were true. It feels more like the internet is a reflection of a very small number of greedy, amoral people from the bay area.
- JohnFen 7y ago> The process of creating a simple web site has gotten much much more complex as scripting languages have changed. If your site requires any scripting at all, it's not a "simple web site".
- smolder 7y agoIt's actually very easy to make websites and apps now IMO, never worrying about hosting and network intrusion and things like that, but you sell out to the centralized, pervasively monitored model of the web in doing so.
- smolder 7y agoCreating jobs isn't good by itself if the work being done is to a bad end. Despite how much promise the internet has for free information, lots of people have been paid to pollute it with garbage that is the opposite of helpful. Or to spy on people so that knowledge can be used against them. The internet is a great thing technology wise, but it has enabled bad actors as much as enabling humble and well intentioned people.
- andrepd 7y ago>Creating jobs isn't good by itself if the work being done is to a bad end. Lots of people have been paid to pollute it with garbage that is the opposite of helpful. Or to spy on people so that knowledge can be used against them. I wish more people internalised this fact.
- ThomPete 7y agoI answered a specific question which was about pulling people out of poverty. Everything has consequences. I am pretty sure you would prefer the life you live now than what even kings live 300 years ago.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mrlala 7y agoWell, a homeless person with a smartphone has a hell of a lot better chance of getting a job than they did pre-smartphone, right? Maybe this can count as more of a smartphone thing an internet thing.. but it's still largely an internet thing that would allow someone in a rough spot to still be able to connect with people online and look/apply for jobs.
- kohanz 7y ago> Well, a homeless person with a smartphone has a hell of a lot better chance of getting a job than they did pre-smartphone, right? Not that I know the answer, but I would have to see a source on this. Why would a device that may increase access to job postings, but a non-homeless job candidate is much more likely to have than a homeless person, increase the chances of said homeless person in getting a job? I'm not even sure that the ability to access job postings is the main problem there.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoI’ve worked with and volunteered with an org who among other things got smart phones to our local homeless. Yes, it does help quite a bit. It’s a $50-100 setup and even without data they can go to any million places with free WiFi and get emails, call job listings, keep in touch with family members. It’s a pretty big deal to them.
- lucideer 7y agoI think you're comparing different things here. 1. Comparing the chances of a homeless person in the modern world with a smartphone, to a homeless person in the modern world without a smartphone. 2. Comparing the chances of a homeless person in the modern world with a smartphone, to a homeless person in a hypothetical internetless world (where noone can have a smartphone). The org you volunteered with dealt with comparison #1 above. We're discussing comparison #2.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y ago
- tim333 7y agoThe number of people in extreme poverty globally have dropped roughly 650m since 1990. Some part of that is probably due to the internet though I'm not sure you could say how much exactly. (Our World in Data graph https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2019/04/Extreme-Poverty-projection-by-the-World-Bank-to-2030-786x550.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2019/04/Extreme-Poverty-p...)
- andrepd 7y agoThe often-repeated trope, touted as an achievement of capitalism, relies on defining "not poor" as earning 2$ PPP per day, or 60 bucks a month, or 700$ = 0.7k per year. Not to mention, ignoring any other measures of quality of life or progress besides raw dollars. It's judging capitalism via a metric internal to capitalism. Pure circular reasoning. E.g. subsistence farmers in rural areas made 0$ and were "poor" by that metric, now they work 14h a day at factories for 2$ a day and are "not in poverty" anymore. Congratulatory handshakes all around!
- slapshot 7y agoThat's not how subsistence farming is counted in GDP and poverty statistics. The value of home production is still counted. If you are eating only $2 worth of rice per day, you are counted as poor whether you buy it or grow it.
- Aunche 7y agoThe international poverty line does take into account of subsidence farmers [1]. Dollars is just used as a standard, so that there can be a tangible value. 1. https://ourworldindata.org/poverty-home-production-and-consumption https://ourworldindata.org/poverty-home-production-and-consu...
- gugagore 7y agoEven though the facts appear wrong, I think this comment does raise the interesting question of whether money is a metric that is internal to capitalism, or if capitalism is the natural consequence of using only money as a metric.
- jimmies 7y agoI am one of those people. I was a poor boy in a remote village in a third world country. The Internet brought me opportunities to know and connect to people far far away. The Internet has shaped my thought process, education, job opportunities. Just about everything I have today was due to the advance of computers and the Internet.
- minblaster 7y agoI agree. On a tech forum the bias is to consider the internet a panacea. Look at the US. We went from ~0% internet penetration in 1990 to 75% in 2017. How much have real wages changed since then? We fantasize about an impoverished person learning a new skill, but it's not the reality.
- codegeek 7y agoIt is a fair question. I assumed based on my own experience that this is very clear but let me clarify. I am privileged to be living in the United States (richest country in the world) but I am originally an immigrant even though that was 20+ years ago. I hire people from all over the world as freelancers from time to time. Internet allows me to hire some random person from a random part of the world and in many cases from a very poor country. I am more than sure that if they didn't have internet, they wouldn't be able to get those freelance jobs and make a living since their home country does not provide a whole lot of options. So I don't have exact data and technically I am guessing the impact but considering how many people live in countries like India, China, African countries, I would assume internet has helped millions out of poverty because without internet, they would not be able to do things to make a living that they do today. Go to upwork.com for example and see ppl from all over the world making a decent living for themselves even if it is low wages for rich countries.
- Faark 7y agoSeems like you only look at one side. I thought by now we have mostly understood that unlimited globalization also has dark sides, especially for the broader local population in richer countries. To me the sentiment of GPs post felt like "internet makes it better on average for all of us". You're "now I very easy can find even cheaper workers" doesn't support that, even though it certainly is an improvement to a select few at the very bottom.
- codegeek 7y agoI focussed mostly on the jobs thing. But Internet has brought many other great things to the world so I think it is a bit myopic to just focus on the "hire cheaper workers" thing. Just the fact that you can communicate your opinions to me while we both are sitting somewhere totally different is the power of internet. It brings plenty of good. Some bad, sure. If not for internet, I would probably never talk to you and not exchange our different perspectives.
- oblio 7y ago> even though it certainly is an improvement to a select few at the very bottom 1. "a select few" is disingenuous. A lot of people have benefited from it. 2. One could say that morally, the people "at the very bottom" deserve more help than "the broader local population in richer countries".