4 ms·
>From my personal experience in nyc, and from talking to neighbors who own restaurants, small and family owned businesses are absolutely hurting. They’ve reduce
by coldtea 7y ago
>From my personal experience in nyc, and from talking to neighbors who own restaurants, small and family owned businesses are absolutely hurting. They’ve reduced staff, and owners are making up lost hours themselves
Well, if they were hurt with such a raise, perhaps they were not viable businesses and are better closed.
The employees might lose a crappy near-subsistence job, but both the employees and owners can then concentrate their efforts into something better...
Somehow Europe manages to have viable restaurants despite decent minimum wage and not tips-oriented compensation...
- dwild 7y ago> The employees might lose a crappy near-subsistence job, but both the employees and owners can then concentrate their efforts into something better... Before the hike, both the employee and owners could do that... yet they didn't. Is the existence of a lower paid job make it harder to create something better? That seems really backward, because there will always be lower paying job. > Somehow Europe manages to have viable restaurants despite decent minimum wage and not tips-oriented compensation... Where does Europe has an higher minimum wage than $15 USD? That's excluding tipping which can bring that wage MUCH higher. You can't really compare viability when the wage is actually lower....
- scient 7y agoImpossible, go away with your socialist ideas! /s
- alfromspace 7y agoWhat if the alternative is unemployment?
- Freak_NL 7y agoWhat makes the US unique that it needs to forego minimum wage? Unemployment isn't much different from most countries in Europe or other comparable economies.
- eej2ya1K 7y agoReally? Really? Take a look at the unemployment in Spain or France and get back to me. Also, not all countries in Europe have a minimum wage - there's no official minimum wage in Norway (although the de facto minimum wage is a lot higher than in the US).
- coldtea 7y ago>Really? Really? Take a look at the unemployment in Spain or France and get back to me. Really? Really? You think the unemployment in Spain and France is because of the minimum wage? They had the minimum wage decades before they had high unemployment (and inversely for the US). Not to mention unemployment rate doesn't say much, since in the US it includes all kinds of subsistence semi-jobs that would qualify more like colonial deals in other countries -- among other manipulations: "The answer lies in the measurement of unemployment. If you have not looked for a job in the last four weeks, you are not counted as being unemployed, because you are not counted as being part of the work force. When there are no jobs to be found, job seekers become discouraged and cease looking for jobs. In other words, the 4.1 percent unemployment rate does not count discouraged workers who cannot find jobs. (...) The US Bureau of Labor Statistics has a second measure of unemployment that includes workers who have been discouraged and out of the labor force for less than one year. This rate of unemployment is 8.2 percent, double the 4.1 percent reported rate. (...) The US government no longer tracks unemployment among discouraged workers who have been out of the work force for more than one year. However, John Williams of shadowstats.com continues to estimate this rate and places it at 22 or 23 percent, a far cry from 4.1 percent. In other words, the 4.1 percent unemployment rate does not count the unemployed who do show up in the declining labor force participation rate." [1] In any case, even with the given "unemployment rate" as the metric, the US is well below Cambodia, Laos, Thailand, Vietnam, Guatemala, and other places, the same way it is, itself, ahead of France. Does that tell you much? [1] https://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2018/03/08/make-believe-america-why-the-us-unemployment-rate-doesnt-indicate-economic-recovery/ https://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2018/03/08/make-believe...
- baud147258 7y ago
- coldtea 7y agoWell, then you don't have a society and economy that can support both employment and decent wages. In which case you should take a long hard look at what's wrong with it instead of using semi-employment under horrible wages as a band aid...
- admax88q 7y agoThere are such efficiencies to be have in restaurants. In Japan I went to a curry restauraunt that was run by 2 staff. Two people did the cooking, taking orders, collecting bills, serving food. The whole operation was two staff. Back home I went to an equivalent size burger joint that had 6 people on staff that I could see. With good design and prep a curry restaurant was able to serve the same amount of food with 1/3 the staff. They could double the wage of the staff and still have money left over with better prep and design.
- jedberg 7y ago> Somehow Europe manages to have viable restaurants despite decent minimum wage and not tips-oriented compensation... They have a social safety net for all the people who aren't employable at that high wage. That's the difference. You can't massively increase minimum wage without a social safety net to go with it. And if your goal is both you need to start with the safety net, not the minimum wage increase.
- whenanother 7y agoactually the social safety net puts a downward pressure on wages. americans need to earn more money to make up for the lack of social services. europeans and most of the free world, the middle class work like they are earning spending money vs americans who work like they are earning money for their health insurance, transportation, etc. this is why americans can't compete with h1b workers as they undercut their american counterpart for wages as they can go home in the end. minimum wage in the US is on the low end of the first world countries when it comes to minimum wages. they should be at the top end. a proper minimum wage would be well above $20 an hour to make up for the lack of social safety nets. it really should be $25 per hour. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_count...
- eej2ya1K 7y agoI'd rather work for my own business at $10 an hour than for a franchise or corporate chain at $20 an hour.
- xibalba 7y ago> viable restaurants My experience in both the UK and Germany was the service is utterly terrible. Some people believe this is a worthy trade-off. I disagree ,and I reject the notion that the only acceptable answer is higher guaranteed wages.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoAnd my experience has a French person is that service in the US is terrible because waiters are ultra invasive (they interrupt me while I talk to say stupid stuff like « how is everything ? »). It’s called « cultural differences »
- joker99 7y agoI agree. Not once in both France or Germany did the waiter come to me and rushed me. I can sit for hours and no one bats an eye. In the US things are always rushed. They come to your table and annoy me _and_ expect a tip of min. 15%. Once, a waiter in NYC actually yelled at us because we didn't tip enough.
- Mirioron 7y agoThe only country in Europe with a minimum wage above $15 an hour is Switzerland.[0][1] Also consider that the tax burden for poor people in Europe is higher, but this does get offset by the better social support structures. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_European_countries_by_minimum_wage#Minimum_wages_by_country_(European_countries)_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_European_countries_by_... [1] https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=RMW https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=RMW