3 ms·
Search is not their core. Advertising is.
by scarface74 7y ago
Search is not their core. Advertising is.
- username90 7y agoThe search service generates more revenue than the rest of ads together. (if I recall correctly from their previous statement, it is at least very close)
- smiths1999 7y agoBut the search revenue comes from ads. Or are you merely pointing out that search ad revenue is the largest piece of total ad revenue? To be honest, I don't understand how everyone can remember the "quality" of their Google searches from 7 years ago. I can't even remember the quality from a year ago. The things I find most frustrating with search (such as maternity blogs being the first options when looking for medical information related to a newborn or tutorial sites being at the top of the results rather than the official language docs) rank highly because those are the things people are clicking on. As an example, I think the crown on HN is more likely to read the official documentation rather than go to a site such as TutorialsPoint or StackOverflow. On the other hand, the average programmer most likely just wants to go to TutorialsPoint or StackOverflow and copy-paste the solution they are looking for. And I think there are many more average programmers than there are visitors to HN. From Google's point of view, they are giving the user what they want. All that being said, it is easy to criticize Google, but dealing with search at the scale of the internet is non-trivial. It isn't clear to me that Google's algorithms from 7 years ago would do just as good of a job today as they did 7 years ago. There is a lot more junk and abuse online, people are figuring out ways to hack their search ranking or spamming useless articles.
- AJ007 7y agoI don’t recall Google’s search quality 7 years ago. I do recall it the first time I used Google. I also recall it when the Demand Media eHow/Livestrong content farm spam decimated their results. One thing that’s worth pointing out, that most technical users miss, are the ads. If you are blocking ads in the results, you have a totally different search experience.
- dredmorbius 7y agoMy read of the comment was that search-based-ads revenue >> all-other-ad-revenue -- banners, Android, etc. Actually, the fact of search >> Android would be something of a surprise, and raises the question of whether or not mobile nets increased ads exposure or if it's just a profiling data collection platform.
- m_fayer 7y agoOn the consumer side of things, their eyeball-holding core is "the platform". This includes search, news, youtube, docs, Play, etc. Search is just a component of that. It's not very different from FB: acquire eyeballs to look at ads, acquire usage data to target ads, with whatever accomplishes that goal. Search is a way for the user to, more or less, "pull" content from the platform - and everything else is a way for the platform to push content at the user. Nowhere in there is "being a good search engine" a core priority.
- tudorw 7y agoIndeed, I agree, depending on your age I guess you see Google as a search engine, if you are young enough to be in the AG generation, you may see them as a platform that happens to have a search engine attached to a device/car/media/photo/email/data platform.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIt's a symbiotic relationship. Search is the content, advertising is the product. Much as with traditional media -- newspapers, radio, television. The "content" (news, music or talk, programming) is the draw, the advertising is the revenue generator. Newspapers spent a century experimenting with the "news hole" (the blanks in the advertising template into which news items were placed, with news going from as much as 90% of the space to as little as 20%. Traditionally, a 40/60 split (40% news, 60% ads) was common from ~1950 - 1990 or so, at least. Economically, content is a public good, advertising is rents income. It seems to me that successful public-goods marketing requires such a pairing, though many problems can still remain due to incentives conflicts.