3 ms·
> How is it not obvious that FSD most likely requires artificial general intelligence Because it doesn't. The issue is that all the self-driving car companies
by bsder 7y ago
> How is it not obvious that FSD most likely requires artificial general intelligence
Because it doesn't. The issue is that all the self-driving car companies ignore how people actually drive.
People memorize their local driving area--it's why teenagers are so incredibly dangerous and why if you put a new stop sign into an area you cause chaos for several months. A self-driving car needs to do the same--the advantage is that a self-driving car can download that "memorization" for any new area it goes into.
Between memorized zones, people mostly "keep station"--they get onto a freeway and keep a relative position with respect to the lanes and the other cars on the road until they get back off.
When something goes very wrong, people panic and random chance takes over the fate of the vast majority of people.
None of this represents general or artificial intelligence. However, solving these tasks requires a lot of very grubby, non-scalable work over a lot of grubby data.
- ghaff 7y agoExcept that when people travel away from their local area and even rent a car they're not familiar with, they don't go randomly crashing into things. They probably have to pay more conscious attention than on a daily commute. But they don't go around crashing into things.
- bsder 7y ago> Except that when people travel away from their local area and even rent a car they're not familiar with, they don't go randomly crashing into things. Collision Damage Waivers and the fact that they are relatively expensive suggests the opposite. Accidents near an airport are more than 50% of auto accidents I have had totally in my life. All of the airport accidents I was literally not moving when someone drove into me. We vastly overestimate the competence of the average driver.
- icebraining 7y ago> The issue is that all the self-driving car companies ignore how people actually drive. People memorize their local driving area (...) A self-driving car needs to do the same Self-driving car companies have been memorizing ("mapping") areas for years.