4 ms·
I think the 'scam' implication comes up because the RIAA's lawyers try as hard as they can to just get people to settle out of court, and once they are brought
by pyre 16y ago
I think the 'scam' implication comes up because the RIAA's lawyers try as hard as they can to just get people to settle out of court, and once they are brought into court, usually try to back-peddle as fast as they can to get out of there while still leaving open the possibility of bringing suit again in the future. The impression this leaves with people is that it's meant to be a 'shake-down' since the RIAA is less interested in court cases and more interested in settlements.
- _delirium 16y agoI don't like the cases he was involved in either, but I don't think Verrilli was part of those settlement-demand letters, or in litigation against individuals. He's an appellate and Supreme-Court practice attorney, and the cases he's been involved with have been appeals of the RIAA's suits against content-hosting companies and P2P companies. For example, he argued their side in the Viacom v. Google case and in MGM v. Grokster. I don't like the positions he argued in those cases, either, but I don't think representing MGM versus Grokster, for example, was a breach of professional ethics or scammy. In fact it seems the position he argued was correct as a matter of law, according to a unanimous Supreme Court (the main problem is that Congress shouldn't have passed the law in question).
- chopsueyar 16y agoI wonder if a similar argument could have been made about slave ownership prior to the 13th amendment? Morality be damned, it is the law.
- pyre 16y agoThe RIAA was involved in the Viacom v. Google case?
- tzs 16y agoWhen did they back peddle? All the cases I heard of where someone decided not to settle and went to court, the RIAA went along and crushed them. Most cases settled because most people the RIAA went after were guilty, and knew it, and realized the the minimum damages they would owe if they lost in court were quite a bit higher than the RIAA's settlement offer.
- nikster 16y ago>When did they back peddle? All the cases I heard of where >someone decided not to settle and went to court, the RIAA >went along and crushed them.' proof? >Most cases settled because most people the RIAA went after >were guilty, and knew it, and realized the the minimum >damages they would owe if they lost in court were quite a >bit higher than the RIAA's settlement offer. That's exactly what they want you to believe. That's why they pursue these lawsuits. It's good old FUD. They can't sue everyone, but they are hoping to sue a handful and scare millions into obedience. It's pretty damn successful at that, too. I know many people who won't download anything for fear of a million Dollar lawsuit. In a just system, the RIAA would be able to sue for me for damages amounting to revenue lost - $20 per film they catch me downloading. But somehow, somewhere, things went awry and people are getting sued for absurd amounts of money. That alone should be a tell tale sign that this is nothing but a big scam. Dressing it in fine legal language doesn't change that. The RIAA is the enemy of the people, plain and simple. It's a corrupt organization which mainly benefits itself, and marginally benefits the artists it's claiming to represent. Because there is very little legitimacy to anything they do, they need to make lots of loud noise - that's the only way they can survive, after all. Nothing good can come from electing what we must assume is a puppet for this organization into an important office in the US government.
- AlexandrB 16y ago>In a just system, the RIAA would be able to sue for me for damages amounting to revenue lost - $20 per film they catch me downloading. I would like to preface this by saying that I don't like the RIAA. The damages they can sue for ARE disproportionate and copyright law is currently massively unbalanced (e.g. never-ending copyright since the 1920s). BUT, have you actually thought about what suing for $20/film would mean? To recover any meaningful losses hundreds of thousands of people would have to be sued at once - unless civil law is radically changed this would not be economical, effectively making copyrights non-enforceable. Not to mention that "downloading" isn't actually covered by copyright law AFAIK and it's the uploading (distributing) part they are suing for. Also, note that enforcement in cases of property theft isn't proportional either - it's not "pay for the thing you stole and you're free to go". There are often other consequences (community service/fines/light jailtime) attached.