10 ms·
A 3D Metal Printer Is Churning Out Rockets
- roca 7y agoToo bad they don't mention the competition that is also using 3D printing, and is in fact quite far ahead of them. Rocket Lab has been flying 3D-printed engines for years. I understand why a regular PR piece wouldn't mention the competition, but this is IEEE Spectrum which is supposed to be better than that.
- jkilpatr 7y ago> is in fact quite far ahead of them This is like saying that AWS doesn't matter because people have been hosting servers for decades. It's technically correct but misses the entire point. SpaceX and RocketLab do print parts, but they still need assembly lines with hard to source machines and skilled labor. RocketLab is working on reusability not because of cost savings but because they are assembly line constrained. https://www.rocketlabusa.com/news/updates/rocket-lab-announces-reusability-plans-for-electron-rocket/ https://www.rocketlabusa.com/news/updates/rocket-lab-announc... > we’re now establishing the reusability program to further increase launch frequency,” says Mr. Beck. That's a jaw-dropping statement, it's easier and faster to develop reusability as a way to get more cores than to build a new assembly line. Relativity is printing out entire rockets, only stacking required. New assembly line is entirely contained in a new printer, constrained on upper stages? Just retask a printer no multi-year long lead time to build up a new set of traditional tools. Don't need any more rockets right now? Print planes instead. The list of advantages goes on. I'll suggest this interview with Relativity space. https://www.wemartians.com/episode062/ https://www.wemartians.com/episode062/ You may also be interested in this one about another company looking to print solar panel arrays on orbit. https://mainenginecutoff.com/podcast/131 https://mainenginecutoff.com/podcast/131
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- disordinary 7y agoRocket lab though uses less metal and has carbon fibre chassis, fuel tanks, etc. They 3d print their engines which is the main metal part of the ship. The constraint may be in autoclaves as carbon fibre is a more intensive product to make than just 3d printing or bending metal.
- roca 7y agoThose are good points. It's unfortunate that an article supposedly for a technical audience didn't make any of them. The "related work" section is a longstanding tradition.
- salimmadjd 7y agoI’m guessing that’s what you mean by “PR piece” ? About the Author Bryce Salmi is the lead avionics hardware engineer for the Los Angeles aerospace startup Relativity Space.
- roca 7y agoIt is possible to work for a company and still describe clearly and fairly the differences between that company's approach and their competitors --- i.e., do better than a purely self-aggrandizing press release. I assume Salmi probably could, and it's just that the IEEE Spectrum editors didn't ask him to, which is disappointing.
- cbanek 7y agoHe definitely could have - he worked at SpaceX as well. But saying things about what other companies are doing is a big no-no in the launch industry, and I doubt they would give permission. It's the kind of thing that can get you put in jail due to ITAR.
- Faark 7y agoIn contrast, here [0] is ULA doing it the more traditional way for their prototype. Don't think it can be compared 1to1, since small sat launcher play in a different league. But it certainly highlights the massive rooms involved. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eb8QkORA3HA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eb8QkORA3HA
- corodra 7y agoLooks like an aluminum welder on a robotic arm. Not discounting it, because I think the simplicity of doing it that way is brilliant for plenty of parts. Plus, I bet there was plenty of trial and error to get the timing and gas settings right for something like this. Got to give them credit there. Aluminum welding is a bitch (I suck at it). So, I'm not trying to rain on their parade... but a quick google search is showing they're not alone. To be fair, I think they might be doing it better though... especially when it comes to scale. A few minutes in, I don't see anything near to their scale, which is cool.
- choonway 7y ago3D printing is only one aspect of the solution. And that isn't the real problem yet (ha ha..)
- versteegen 7y agoIt's oft said that Relativity Space is a 3D-printing company; that's the hard problem they're solving. Launching satellites into space is a side-show.
- Robotbeat 7y agoIf the problem they're solving is harder than "just" launching satellites into space, then that doesn't bode well for their chances of success. Just launching stuff into orbit, or attempting that, has swallowed many companies in failure.
- Teever 7y agoNot necessarily. If they can solve the issues with 3d printing then they can potentially have a cheaper, faster, and more versatile production methodology which can result in faster iterations to solve the issues that they face with the actual launch process.
- tmikaeld 7y agoRockets are really neat, but to me this says a lot more about how far robot manufacturing has come and where we're going.
- Accujack 7y agoThe robotic technology involved here is decades old. What they're doing that's new is designing for manufacture using modern materials. That robot arm is probably an off the shelf part.
- rtkwe 7y agoIt's off the shelf, it's a Kuka arm but the arm itself isn't the interesting bit. It's integrating the 3 arms, the print head, and the rotary table. I've programmed an older one of those arms and it was no cake walk and my program was to just do the Towers of Hanoi as a demo. [0] [0] It's a pretty simple demo because it can just be done as a simple set of calculated linear motions. The only real trick was that the version of the language it was using didn't support recursion.
- phaedrus 7y agoI'm eagerly anticipating the day when hobbyists can 3-D print engine blocks and cylinder heads. Imagine the engine swaps enthusiasts will come up with when they can make their own designs from scratch and share high-performance designs as open source hardware. It will also be a boon to people restoring antique cars, the ability to print a new period-correct engine block.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoWouldn't milling be a much better way of creating bespoke engine blocks than printing?
- rpmisms 7y agoPrinting engine blocks will never work without sintering. Metallurgy has limits.
- magoon 7y agoWhen this technology can exist in space, earth will have orbiting shipyards building space craft.
- imglorp 7y agoIs this assuming some of the materials are available there? This would make sense if you're getting fuel or metal from asteroids, moon's surface, etc and building ships near those. But in Earth orbit, you'll need to lift the shipyard, then the fuel, then the metal powder etc for sintering, so what would be the gain?
- mkl 7y agoYes, you'd probably want to go get some asteroids. Even small ones can contain huge amounts of metals, and icy ones could be turned into fuel. There's a lot of potential, but it's all a bit out of reach for the moment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asteroid_mining
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIsn't moon dust mostly bauxite? (oxidized aluminum)
- mkl 7y agoNot exactly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geology_of_the_Moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geology_of_the_Moon. I think the problem with moon resources is the moon's gravity while forming was strong enough to pull metals like iron and nickel down into the centre where we can't get at them (they're on the surface a bit too, but not conveniently concentrated). Asteroids, on the other hand, can contain lots of accessible nickel, iron, cobalt, etc. I'm no expert though!
- ben_w 7y agoWikipedia looks like it says [0], by elemental concentration, roughly 42% oxygen, 21% silicon, 12% iron, 8% calcium, 7% aluminium, 6% magnesium, 4% other. [0] Bar graph with insufficient labels: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Composition_of_lunar_soil.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Composition_of_lunar_so...
- not_a_cop75 7y agoHow's the 3d printing landscape for metal overall? I hear there have been made great strides in 3d printers that rely on sintering. Very affordable relatively speaking. Any other methods that have gained traction?
- bumby 7y ago> Relativity has in-house metallurgists who are honing the process, ensuring that our components meet the strict quality standards for aerospace hardware. My understanding is that much of the cost of flight materials is ensuring/maintaining the quality pedigree. I would have liked to see more detail into the ways quality changes with a new manufacturing process. E.g., are certain non-destructive evaluation techniques necessary? Are inspections capable of being automated?
- russdill 7y agoGreat Real Engineering video with a lot of discussion of the issues with material properties, crystalline structure, and fatigue cracks related to metalized 3d printing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzBRYsiyxjI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzBRYsiyxjI
- Gravityloss 7y agoCurrently, one would expect to filament wind all the tanks, intertank and nose out of carbon fiber. You can buy off the shelf machines for that. It's used widely for solid rockets, where the internal pressure is very high. I don't know why not for pump fed liquid rockets, maybe the design being buckling limited makes the approach worse.
- swagasaurus-rex 7y agoI am unfamiliar with material sciences. Are 3d printed metals as structurally sound as other techniques for metallurgy?
- deepnotderp 7y agoDMLS is generally within 80% iirc. This appears to be a bit different in terms of technology, but I don't see why it should be significantly off. Both Rocket Lab and SpaceX have been flying 3D printed rocket parts for a while now.
- synaesthesisx 7y agoRelativity Space is one of the aerospace companies I'm most excited about (especially in regards to whatever they pull off in the 3D printed launch vehicle space)!