4 ms·
The drug convictions draw the most attention because they're the most absurd - an entire sector of criminality created by moral crusaders pushing sadistic funda
by mindslight 7y ago
The drug convictions draw the most attention because they're the most absurd - an entire sector of criminality created by moral crusaders pushing sadistic fundamentalism for what amounts to a public health problem.
The forgeries presumably wronged someone, and so it's easy to see it deserves some kind of punishment. Even if the magnitude of the sentence is draconian, subjectivity means this isn't as clear-cut of an argument.
- Gibbon1 7y agoBrings up my observation, how much brutality are you willing to inflect on people for esthetic reasons? Or being problematic. Lot of people are problematic. The worst of the worst usually have power. Say what one might but a middle aged junkie lady with a sock full of smack isn't going to bring the roof down over our heads.
- rayiner 7y agoI disagree that they’re the most absurd. The majority of people incarcerated for drug offenses are traffickers. Peddling a deadly substance is morally wrong, whether or not society chooses to make it illegal.
- comicjk 7y agoAlcohol is more deadly than most drugs (smaller ratio between the effective dose and the lethal dose). Yet a little alcohol each week is safe and a part of life for many people. I think we can blame a seller for selling too much to an individual - note that it is illegal to sell a drink to an intoxicated person. But I don't think we can blame them for selling reasonably safe amounts.
- simonh 7y agoIn a very large number, if not most cases, these are junkies trading small amounts with other junkies. If someone goes and buys some weed, brings it back and splits it and the cost with a few friends, they are now a 'drug dealer' and get treated as such under the law if they're busted. Functionally, that means almost all users at one time or another are 'dealers' and it's just a matter of getting the evidence.
- endymi0n 7y agoAbout the forgeries, I‘m not so sure. Judging by the other secondary conviction of failing to get a tax stamp to sell her drugs (!), the forgery conviction could just as well have been something much more mundane, like her passing off the drugs as something else while traveling.
- candiodari 7y agoThis. A million times over. Crimes often sound bad. Then take what most people who get convicted DID. Take juvenile "justice". Crimes vs what child potentially really did: Kidnapping: running away from parents that hit you. Helping someone else run away from their parents, or running away and taking your brother/sister (because you don't have the right to take yourself or anyone else away from parents). Can also be "removing from parental control", which is also a crime (if you manage to get help, those people can also get convicted) (same for running away from an "open" child protection institution if you don't agree with their treatment of you (which is quite likely the case I might add), even running back to your parents. Stealing: taking anything. Even your own stuff of course, as children don't technically own anything. Drugs: much the same. But standing in the street while kids inside a house are doing drugs, even if you're clean, is drug use too (or at least conspiracy to ...). Child protection services have been known to ask to convict children for drugs because their parents or friends did drugs, EVEN if those parents were not convicted/were innocent (they can, because there is no burden of proof for them. After all, they’re “protecting” children, “not punishing them”) (usually because the parents didn't agree with doing whatever CPS wanted them to do, and this is a way to force parents into compliance, usually to "place" (lock up) the children (which results in a LOT of extra subsidies for CPS, which I’m sure is just a coincidence). And let's be real here, there's closed and "open" CPS institutions. And there's "juvie". All are prisons, it's really just the regimen that's different, and "open" should be understood to be something like minimum security prison) Breaking and entering: same problem as with drugs. Being nearby, accidentally, will get you convicted. Grand theft: being in a stolen car, knowingly ... or not, is grand theft. And of course, there’s the fundamental criticism of the juvenile justice system and CPS: recidivism rates are higher for the system ... compared with just letting criminals go unpunished. It’s that bad. (Incidentally: the same is true for psychological problems: odds of improvement are better without treatment). Given the above “crimes” this makers more sense, I hope. “Criminal” (or “abused”) children often haven’t DONE anything they (or we) would consider a crime, then commit real crimes afterwards to take revenge against society for their treatment, because that treatment is so bad (violence, drugs, sex, forced and/or threatened is everywhere in CPS, schooling yourself is near impossible due to constant moving and instability). Understandable, to Some extent. Sadly both CPS and courts have financial incentives to get more children into the system, so this is getting worse.