4 ms·
It’s a little sad that so many people only get interested in these problems for the drug angle: https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/human_rights/2019/05/revisitin
by rayiner 7y ago
It’s a little sad that so many people only get interested in these problems for the drug angle: https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/human_rights/2019/05/revisiting-life-without-parole-in-alabama-one-prisoner-at-a-time.html https://lawprofessors.typepad.com/human_rights/2019/05/revis...
Geneva Cooley was sentenced to mandatory life without parole based on the drug conviction. However, even if that hadn’t been the case, she could’ve gotten a life sentence based on two prior felony convictions for forgery, and a felony conviction for failing to get tax stamps for the drugs she sold. The drug laws in Alabama have been amended, but the habitual offender laws have been much harder to change.
There is a ton of focus on the injustice of drug convictions, maybe because it’s something middle class people can identify with. But that’s just scratching the surface of what’s wrong.
- curryst 7y agoI do think you're right that it's something that middle class people can identify with. Largely because the opioid crisis has started to impact a lot of middle class households, which has helped to humanize the problems with drug addiction. It's also to some degree perceived as less severe because selling drugs is generally something addicts do to other addicts; it's not victimless, but it's not something that victimizes those that aren't drug addicts (beyond helping to continue the cycle of addiction, and stopping that by prosecuting drug dealers hasn't proved effective). Forgery, on the other hand, is much harder to humanize for the middle class because it's generally a crime that victimizes the middle class. Many people are less likely to reduce the sentencing for things like that or burglary because it's a crime that might be inflicted on them, and they want their pound of flesh if it is.
- wgerard 7y ago> Largely because the opioid crisis has started to impact a lot of middle class households, which has helped to humanize the problems with drug addiction. Interesting take! I've always thought it's because of the change in viewpoints towards marijuana (and to a lesser extent, psychedelics). Attitudes towards recreational marijuana use are far more liberal than they used to be. As it became more socially acceptable it caused much of America to re-examine attitudes towards penalizing drug usage in general, if only because it felt draconian to imprison someone from their milieu for smoking their illegal drug of choice (marijuana).
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> Largely because the opioid crisis has started to impact a lot of middle class households, which has helped to humanize the problems with drug addiction. Perhaps off topic, and apologies for discussing political issues, but this is the angle I always bring up when folks wonder where "Black Lives Matter" comes from. Reason being in the 80s we also had a horrible drug epidemic that destroyed lives and families, but the response was 180 degree opposite of what you see today with the opioid epidemic: drug users were derided as "crack whores" and "junkies", oppressive minimum sentences were enacted (with cheaper crack punished much more harshly than more expensive powder cocaine), and essentially 0 empathy shown towards drug users. Compare that today with even hardcore Republicans advocating empathy and treatment. "Black Lives Matter" is needed as a slogan because, quite honestly, black lives didn't matter, at least in the eyes of America at large.
- GhostVII 7y agoI think black lives matter has more to do with what is happening now than with what was happening in the 80s. Protesting because we are treating opioid users better than drug users 30 years ago doesn't make much sense.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> I think black lives matter has more to do with what is happening now than with what was happening in the 80s. I absolutely agree, and I wasn't arguing against that. I just think when you hear things like the "All Lives Matter" retort, the juxtaposition between the crack epidemic and the opioid epidemic is such a crystal clear difference where (a) the crack epidemic really wasn't that long ago at all and (b) the race of the main affected communities is the only real difference that brought about all the huge differences in the societal response.
- tropo 7y agoIt's not race. It's how the addiction started. There is sympathy for people who started because a highly-educated and trusted professional made a prescription of an FDA-approved medicine to treat a severe injury. There is much less sympathy for somebody who started because they illegally got a substance for recreational purposes from a criminal. That is a world of difference, and race doesn't even come into the picture. TL;DR is that "my bone is sticking out of my leg" is different from "let's get fucked up".
- grawprog 7y ago>selling drugs is generally something addicts do to other addicts; When it comes to hard drugs, that's really not the case most of the time. Kind of hard to run a successful drug dealing operation when your consuming your own products. Especially gang dealers. A lot of gangs have no tolerance for their dealers doing drugs while selling. In a lot of cases these really are non addicts taking as much advantage of people as they can. >but it's not something that victimizes those that aren't drug addicts Ran into a junkie once, he asked to buy a smoke, then just started telling me his life story. He'd been engaged, ran his own company, owned a house. He ended up getting into a car accident, doctor prescribed him opiates, when his prescription was finished he started getting dopesick, he ended up finding someone who could sell him, oxy's(pretty sure that's what it was), anyway appparently his buddy or whatever.didn't have any one day offered him some heroin, helped him shoot up and pretty much started the dude's downward spiral into losing his entire life, not speaking to his family for years and had placed him in the position where he was asking me for a smoke on the street while trailing all his wordly possessions in a shopping cart. He was not happy with his life, he'd been too ashamed to talk to his parents for 6 years or something, there really isn't much help available for people like that. If they don't get into some kind of program, which, is not easy for people like that who have nobody, they're just stuck in that cycle.
- WalterBright 7y agoIt's terrible that non-violent crimes should get you a life sentence.
- Balgair 7y agoDepends on the case! Coincidently, this is why judges typically dislike mandatory minimum sentences and whatnot. Sometimes the punishment should be different than what the lawmakers said it must be. Every single case is as unique as the people that caused it happen, and thus, the sentences should be as unique too. There are a LOT of arguments against this, but that there is an argument at all is not as widely comprehended.
- WalterBright 7y agoMandatory minimums are wrong, I agree with your reasons.
- jopsen 7y agoIt's terrible that minor violent crimes can get you a life sentence too. Just saying, don't limit your empathy, limit your sentences -- sure, there is a few extreme cases.
- peignoir 7y agoYes, remind me of Weber s law. It is observed that the same law applies to justice sentences as a bias on how our brain works (following a logarithmic function) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hHG8io5qIU8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hHG8io5qIU8
- macspoofing 7y agoI don't know how true that is. I strongly suspect it isn't true at all. Politicians keep talking as if there are thousands of innocent people in prison, but then any reform tends to stall or backfire (i.e. releasing violent offenders to the public) or not result in much change. In almost every case there are usually a plethora of prior convictions, or there was a violent crime (or a pattern of violent crime) underlying the conviction but the drug/non-violent conviction is what 'stuck'. In the same way, Al Capone's conviction wasn't really about non-violent/white-collar crime of tax evasion. The cases that are cited where there are no associated factors are, I suspect, few and far between and are largely outliers. And it makes sense. The justice system is already overburdened. Just as a matter of practicality, neither judges nor prosecutors wish to send non-violent offenders to prison. The last season of Serial, which followed a bunch cases in the Cleveland court system over a few months, showed this. People who deserved to go to prison, went prison. People who didn't (even if they were guilty), didn't. From a big-picture perspective, the vast majority of people in prison deserve to be in prison.
- mindslight 7y agoThe drug convictions draw the most attention because they're the most absurd - an entire sector of criminality created by moral crusaders pushing sadistic fundamentalism for what amounts to a public health problem. The forgeries presumably wronged someone, and so it's easy to see it deserves some kind of punishment. Even if the magnitude of the sentence is draconian, subjectivity means this isn't as clear-cut of an argument.
- Gibbon1 7y agoBrings up my observation, how much brutality are you willing to inflect on people for esthetic reasons? Or being problematic. Lot of people are problematic. The worst of the worst usually have power. Say what one might but a middle aged junkie lady with a sock full of smack isn't going to bring the roof down over our heads.
- rayiner 7y agoI disagree that they’re the most absurd. The majority of people incarcerated for drug offenses are traffickers. Peddling a deadly substance is morally wrong, whether or not society chooses to make it illegal.
- comicjk 7y agoAlcohol is more deadly than most drugs (smaller ratio between the effective dose and the lethal dose). Yet a little alcohol each week is safe and a part of life for many people. I think we can blame a seller for selling too much to an individual - note that it is illegal to sell a drink to an intoxicated person. But I don't think we can blame them for selling reasonably safe amounts.
- simonh 7y agoIn a very large number, if not most cases, these are junkies trading small amounts with other junkies. If someone goes and buys some weed, brings it back and splits it and the cost with a few friends, they are now a 'drug dealer' and get treated as such under the law if they're busted. Functionally, that means almost all users at one time or another are 'dealers' and it's just a matter of getting the evidence.