3 ms·
All of your use cases involve anonymity. Crypto currencies don’t provide anonymity. Sure it’s not directly tied to your name and address, but it’s quite possibl
by falcolas 7y ago
All of your use cases involve anonymity. Crypto currencies don’t provide anonymity. Sure it’s not directly tied to your name and address, but it’s quite possible to make that tie. Such cases are on the news fairly frequently.
- lawn 7y agoYou're right that Bitcoin is only pseudo-anonymous. But there are cryptocurrencies like Monero which provides much better anonymity. Also, anonymity isn't black and white. It would be very difficult for the Venezuelan government to prevent you from buying Bitcoin in-person and then walking out of the country, with your Bitcoin keys written on a small piece of paper or even memorized.
- jcranmer 7y agoAll Venezuela has to do is to make it illegal for anyone to sell you Bitcoin. Effectively, the current situation is rather close to that: the financial system is predicated on Know Your Customer and Anti-Money Laundering regulations that make moving large amounts of money for anonymous purposes dangerous for financial institutions. Given that cryptocurrency has struggled to provide any rationale for its existence other than the anonymous money flows that government regulation is trying to root out, dealing with it as a financial institution raises regulatory compliance red flags. As the article demonstrates, this means that your only real option is to rely on criminals and hope that money moves through the system fast enough that the government doesn't notice and the criminals handling your wealth don't skim too much off.
- lawn 7y agoAnd all the U.S. had to do is make drugs illegal, and it would disappear. (Or not.) > other than the anonymous money flows Are you saying that anonymous money is immoral and should be made illegal, and in the process dismissing all use cases that benefit from anonymity? And no, cryptocurrencies are perfectly legal in most of the world.
- jcranmer 7y agoI'm pointing out that anonymous money flows are already effectively illegal, given the KYC/AML laws. At some point, any Funny Money system you create has to interact with the fiat system so that people can actually do stuff like pay their utility bills, and if Funny Money is triggering compliance alarm bells, and at that point, well, read the article. Something else to point out is that just because a system is unsustainable doesn't mean it will collapse immediately.
- lawn 7y agoOh alright. I don't see how this invalidates the use cases? The businesses that have payment processor problems aren't illegal, and can easily prove their revenue. And I do agree that unsustainable systems don't collapse immediately. I've been waiting for Tether to collapse for years. But I don't think cryptocurrencies as a whole are unsustainable (the larger proper exchanges that don't use Tether as their "fiat option" should survive).
- CryptoPunk 7y agoAnonymous money flows aren't illegal. There are those that would like to make them illegal, but all they've managed to institute so far is KYC/AML laws relating to third party payment processors. These laws don't apply to cash or its electronic corollary, cryptocurrency. Until a law is created that makes unmonitored use of physical and electronic cash illegal, anonymous money flows aren't across-the-board illegal. One obstacle elitists have in instituting such laws is that enforcement would be costly, involving heavy-handed treatment of large numbers of end-users. Trusted third parties like banks are comparatively easy targets, being much less politically costly to repress.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 7y agoIn any case real estate is exempt from KYC/AML. That is supposed to be why Chinese people own so much American farmland and so many Canadian houses.
- rolltiide 7y agothe other open secret is that you just create a new identity in an isolated sub namespace you ring fence all the addresses in that space with Monero over VPN or TOR: Monero swapped to Bitcoin, Monero swapped to Ether, Monero swapped to Tether (ERC20/OMNI/TRC20), a general balance in Monero since merchants accept that too, and transact there. Swap back out to Monero if you need a withdrawal. Pencil pushers can track addresses on one transparent blockchain all fuckin day till your grandma gets tainted coins after Thanksgiving and all her accounts closed by some paranoid compliance officer and overzealous dumbass public servant, while the rest of us get every good and service we expected anonymously.
- vkou 7y agoSo, once you drive all the normies off the system, what makes you think that you're ever going to manage to turn your Monero into fiat?
- rolltiide 7y agoI don't. It also works.
- vosper 7y ago> Monero swapped to Bitcoin, Monero swapped to Ether, Monero swapped to Tether Is there a way to do this without going through some central exchange? I thought I'd read that (eg) Shapeshift was now doing KYC/AML checks, so would you still get identified there?
- rolltiide 7y agoMorphtoken Bisq XMR.to because your clearnet identity already owns Monero
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stale2002 7y agoNo, they don't have to involve anonymity. For example, lets take donating to WikiLeaks as an example. Anonymity is not needed for that, since they have never been charged with any crimes. The only thing needed was a way to get around the banking cartel, that blocked payments to them, even though WikiLeaks was not charged with any crimes. If it was 2011, being able to donate to WikiLeaks, was something that many people needed crypto for, regardless of anonymity.
- esotericn 7y agoIt doesn't matter whether most people's use cases are "truly" anonymous or not, because not everyone who makes an anonymous payment is the kingpin of a human trafficking ring who will actually have large amounts of resources brought to bear on them. People use burner phones to get drugs for nights out. Theoretically none of this is really anonymous, you're pinging cell towers, you're probably on CCTV, etc etc. But realistically that doesn't matter and it works as a system. Even something like Monero which might have claim to be truly untraceable really isn't because you're on like, an Intel ME machine and the NSA likely has backdoors in the Linux kernel and ... blah blah blah ... But it's good enough. Imagine if Hacker News required ID-verified real name front and center on every post. Throwaway accounts are impossible. They were never perfect anyway, but now they don't exist. The discourse would change. Perhaps an individual might see it as being better, or worse, but it'd definitely be different. The traditional banking system is that ID-verified world. Cryptocurrencies are the release valve. FWIW I think Tether is bollocks.
- RandomBacon 7y ago> Monero which might have claim to be truly untraceable They haven't. The developers are very upfront about its limitations.
- mcnichol 7y agoMixing coins or sending to a coldstore address freshly minted. Each address is a new account, the paranoid of the groups create new accounts quite regularly for their transactions. It is a low bar to learning this, I suggest reading the 101 level information first.
- alwillis 7y agoCrypto currencies don’t provide anonymity. It’s pretty easy to make bitcoin transactions anonymous. 1. Wasabi Wallet runs over Tor and has built-in support for CoinJoins: https://wasabiwallet.io https://wasabiwallet.io 2. Samourai Wallet has Whirlpool, another mixing technology, among other security features: https://www.samouraiwallet.com/features https://www.samouraiwallet.com/features 3. You can skip the usual exchanges and use Bisq for peer-to-peer trading over Tor, including selling BTC for fiat: https://bisq.network https://bisq.network 4. Lightning network (a layer 2 network on top of Bitcoin) has exploded in popularity; it’s also a major privacy win for transactions: https://medium.com/breez-technology/lightning-network-routing-privacy-and-efficiency-in-a-positive-sum-game-b8e443f50247 https://medium.com/breez-technology/lightning-network-routin... Most wallets nowadays don’t let you reuse addresses; even with plain vanilla Bitcoin transactions, this makes it much more difficult to link an identity with a Bitcoin transaction. And this is before Taproot and Schnorr signatures are added to the Bitcoin protocol in the not too distant future: https://blog.bitmex.com/the-schnorr-signature-taproot-softfork-proposal/ https://blog.bitmex.com/the-schnorr-signature-taproot-softfo... There's more but the point should be clear: it’s actually fairly easy to dramatically increase the anonymity of bitcoin transactions.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]