3 ms·
> I am always shocked, that instead of writing the authors of a website to change it, they write to authors of a browser to prevent it. If it's fixed once in t
by loeg 7y ago
> I am always shocked, that instead of writing the authors of a website to change it, they write to authors of a browser to prevent it.
If it's fixed once in the browser, the solution is universal.
Contacting every single website that does this (3+ orders of magnitude more than the number of browsers) is vastly higher effort and unlikely to be 100% successful (or even 50%).
And anyway, it's reasonable to fix this permissions issue in the user tool, rather than on the end of the publisher, because the user tool has incentives more in line with users. E.g., for some reason, browsers today block pop-up ads, although once they were extremely popular with publishers. Do you think asking publishers with pop-up ads to just stop that practice would have worked?
> I think each website provides you a content under a certain conditions, and the browser is not here to let you "steal" every content while absolutely ignoring the conditions.
Pulling single sentence quotes, such as "I think each website provides you a content under a certain conditions, and the browser is not here to let you 'steal' every content while absolutely ignoring the conditions," is very much fair use, not theft.
- IvanK_net 7y agoI used many programs, called "trials", which stopped working after 30 days. So it does not let me use it, while the program itself is on my hard drive, with all resources necessary to run that program. But the computer belongs to me, and the content of a hard drive too. And the OS should do what I want it to do. Should I report it as a bug to the creators of my OS? If it's fixed once in the OS, the solution is universal. So that since I downloaded a program to my computer, the OS should make it run every time.
- wtallis 7y agoStop and think about what specific techniques a program might be using to prevent the trial version to continue to run after 30 days. If it needs to phone home to the vendor's servers each time you launch the program, then there's not much the OS can or should be able to do to get in the way of that. You can redirect traffic to your own server that's impersonating the vendor's authentication server, but they can use cryptography to defend against that kind of attack. But if it's trying to place an undeletable file on your system or something like that (eg. in your boot sector, TurboTax style) to keep track of how many times you've launched the program, then your OS absolutely should protect you from such misbehaviors.