4 ms·
I get the concern, but Amazon is very aware that they can't do anything non-competitive with AWS to help its other business. Netflix (who undoubtedly has a long
by dehrmann 7y ago
I get the concern, but Amazon is very aware that they can't do anything non-competitive with AWS to help its other business. Netflix (who undoubtedly has a long-term contract) still hosts there.
The home field advantages companies have been getting away with lately tend to be tighter integrations (think Chromecast, Android, and Chrome). The only company that would pull something as bad as what's being feared is Oracle.
- noirbot 7y agoThe "non-competitive" thing they're doing with AWS is using it as a profit center so they can do anti-competitive things with all of their other businesses. If they weren't making so much money on AWS, they wouldn't be able to squeeze Netflix or other retailers as effectively. It's not to say it's entirely rational to boycott AWS like this, but I can understand the origin of it, and it's not like you can easily say no to a Walmart if you're some SaaS startup and they're offering you a massive contract if you can get off of AWS.
- benologist 7y agoAmazon has made it their business to clone 10,000s of items and software's just as easy to copy, they have already cloned multiple open source products and even commercial stuff they saw hosted on AWS. The only thing stopping them from routinely cloning stuff they see on AWS is nothing. They are accused of using vendor sales data to decide which products to clone, well that front-row seat watching you scale infers revenue too. Whenever Bezos wants Amazon will assign thousands of developers to cherry-picking SaaS and software to clone. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/03/08/amazon_copies_partner_products/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/03/08/amazon_copies_partn...
- StreamBright 7y agoDo you think they were able to clone it because it was hosted on AWS?
- benologist 7y agoThey were able to clone it because copying is easier than having the idea and building something for the first time and verifying that anyone wants it. Hosting is analogous to the sales data, it helps prioritize who you should clone first. Cloning is just practice for many developers. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=show%20hn%20clone&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- sfifs 7y agoActually it's much simpler. The Walmart's and Kroger's of the world know Amazon makes most of its profit in AWS. Amazon uses the profit to compete on prices with the retailers. So by insisting on working with vendors and partners who don't use AWS, they are trying to reduce the potential profit Amazon could make
- bilbo0s 7y agoActually the entire concern is irrelevant long term. No way places like Target and Walmart continue to outsource critical SaaS services to contractors. Retail is turning into a SaaS game, and Walmart and Target don't strike me as the kind of organizations that would be caught flat footed by that change. The reality is, in 2 years, there's a non-trivial likelihood that organizations like that may not be giving out those kinds of contracts at all. Too critical. Too much value add going forward. To own that infrastructure will confer too much competitive advantage for, say, Target to allow Walmart to build that out unchallenged. If you're in the business of serving large retailers services like this, you should probably be wargaming out some possible pivots before the market for those services begins to shrink. But there's a silver lining to those changes for everyone else, it's entirely possible that these retailers may go into providing those services that are going to start being on the critical path so to speak. Think Walmart and Target building out AWS competitors, or package delivery services, etc etc.
- fragmede 7y agoI disagree about Walmart possibly being caught flat footed. While it's valid to point out that Walmart Labs exists Wich means Walmart has a finger in the data science and ML pie, Walmart got caught off guard with online sales, to the point that they are credible competition to Amazon Prime - better in some areas, worse in others - this fact is barely known, with most of my friends (which is hardly the most scientific data set) happy customers of Amazon Prime. If Walmart was caught so flat-footed, and so unknown in this area, arguably central to the future of their business, it's hard to see them as a credible threat to Amazon.com or AWS, and not for lack of trying re: Amazon.com.
- jjeaff 7y agoI don't think Walmart was actually caught off guard with online retail. But because they had (and still have) such a massive retail market share, the powers that be inside Walmart undoubtedly stifled innovation in order to avoid cannibalizing their retail arm. (The Innovators Dillema). But wmt seems to have mostly woken up and correctly organized their power structure to empower the e-commerce arm. They even brought in an outsider (founder of jet.com).
- bytematic 7y agohttps://www.fiercevideo.com/tech/aws-mega-customer-netflix-using-google-cloud-more-report https://www.fiercevideo.com/tech/aws-mega-customer-netflix-u...