4 ms·
I am fully aware of what he's trying to say, but it's wrong. We're talking about communication of ideas between humans and computers. The claim that GUIs have e
by globular-toast 7y ago
I am fully aware of what he's trying to say, but it's wrong. We're talking about communication of ideas between humans and computers. The claim that GUIs have enabled music production is nonsense given the vast amount of music produced without it. Same for desktop publishing. I can use beautiful fonts and images using TeX, for example.
A command-line interface is no more a "magic incantation" than pointing and clicking in the right places is. In fact, I would argue that language is less magic than pointing and clicking because the rules of language are available for anyone to learn, while the rules of pointing and clicking are designed and only understood by the application developer.
Damn me for having a different opinion, though.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoNo analogy is perfect, and I agree that this one falls apart in one important way: if you know what you're doing (!), a good CLI can be legitimately faster than even the best GUIs for certain tasks. But that's a big caveat. I've been volunteering at Girls Who Code. My club is doing a project that involves SSH'ing into a Raspberry Pi, and I've spent a significant amount of time getting the kids used to just moving through folders within the command line. Using cd and ls to navigate a file system is actually really tricky to wrap your head around if you're not used to it!
- chopin 7y agoI can relate. One of the things I miss most on the command line is the poor visualization especially of hierarchical stuff (file system, git history,...).
- ses1984 7y ago> fact, I would argue that language is less magic than pointing and clicking because the rules of language are available for anyone to learn, while the rules of pointing and clicking are designed and only understood by the application developer. I guess your command line uses natural language processing and is accessible to anyone who never read a man page or heard of a shell? The command line interface is no less opaque than "the rules of pointing and clicking".
- wtetzner 7y agoI think you're still missing the point. It's not that talking on the phone or using a GUI is more efficient, it's that it allows people to use technology in a way that feels more natural to them, and requires much less training to be able to utilize it. To your point about clicking vs knowing commands, a GUI is more discoverable for someone, because they can try things and see what happens. Trying to guess commands is much harder, because there are no clues to guide you.