3 ms·
You're completely missing the point. Language is about an awful lot more than words, it's about expressiveness and emotional content as well as just textual inf
by simonh 7y ago
You're completely missing the point. Language is about an awful lot more than words, it's about expressiveness and emotional content as well as just textual information. He talked about telephones letting people sing - express themselves though voice beyond mere words.
A command line interface isn't a great medium for singing, but graphical interfaces enabled sophisticated music production software, desktop publishing using beautiful fonts and images (examples he used). It enables expressiveness beyond what can be captured in mere text. But it can do plain text just fine too.
But the main point he made was not that these things can't be done using a command line, it's that a graphical interface democratises access by removing the need to learn special incantations to interact creatively with content.
- swiley 7y agoThere’s an awful lot of folk music notated in ABC (the musical equivalent of markdown.) IMO unless you’re actually drawing or looking at an image GUIs really kind of suck but are very sexy and help people sell a lot of software.
- ekianjo 7y agoYour examples are not very convincing. Desktop publishing powers tabloids while a great book remains a great book even in pure text format. Expressiveness is not limited to a medium, and if you ever used a command line interface you would understand the concept it pipes and arguments is way more expressive than a round of 100 clicks to do the same thing thru a GUI. GUI do democratise access to capabilities, but unless you work only with pixels GUIs are inferior in every single way.
- simonh 7y ago"If you ever used a command lien interface". That's a good one, I've been using Unix/Linux systems daily since the early 90s and test people on their Bash skills in job interviews.
- IggleSniggle 7y ago"Command lien interface" - a modality of interaction in which the empowered party (lienor) exerts control over someone with valuable property (lienee) via commands backed by a ephemeral interface that does not need to exist at compile time (lien), but is practical for eliminating bugs that arise from causality in economic systems.
- ekianjo 7y agoVery strange that bash has still not disappeared in 2019 if GUIs are so superior to every thing a command line interface can do.
- coldtea 7y ago>GUI do democratise access to capabilities, but unless you work only with pixels GUIs are inferior in every single way. Except in the way that matters: symbolic representation and manipulation (and discoverability). >Expressiveness is not limited to a medium, and if you ever used a command line interface you would understand the concept it pipes and arguments is way more expressive than a round of 100 clicks to do the same thing thru a GUI. Actually, a GUI can trivially include a pipe system (tons of VFX and Color gradings apps for example offer one, MAX/MSP and others). A GUI can also trivially include a text console, and have all the capabilities of the command line. The command line, on the other hand, can't have all the capabilities of the GUI. Even auto-completion is implemented crudely with curses interfaces (which, in any case, are GUIs too). (Oh, and I've been using the command line since the pre-Solaris days of Sun OS).
- palerdot 7y agoYou can think of Jobs argument as this way. What `ncurses` is to you, computers are for normal people. You are essentially arguing the same point Jobs is emphasising. If Jobs have to do it your way, basically you are leaving behind 95% of normal people who are not tech savvy like writers, artists, accountants etc who could benefit from a computer without knowing the complicated inner workings of a computer. Exactly the same way you are benefiting from `ncurses` and not writing all the obsure logic of text rendering from scratch everytime just so you can work in command line ... You misinterpreted this whole discussion as an argument between GUI vs terminals which is not the point at all.
- tyingq 7y agoI agree with you, though I did know some non-tech people that were amazingly good with software like Wordstar, Visicalc, etc. Jobs makes fun of Wordstar in the interview, but it was a really productive tool, since your hands stayed on the keyboard.
- throwaway87378 7y ago> What `ncurses` is to you, computers are for normal people. That is a really dumb analogy, that makes a really good point. Try piping a program that uses ncurses. Ncurses is a shitty way to do a GUI on serial video terminals. It is a GUI and not a Unix command-line interface.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoYou're comparing a 18-wheeler to a compact car and saying the 18-wheeler is superior in every way. Most people need ease of use more than they need raw power. Both of them have their place.
- globular-toast 7y agoI am fully aware of what he's trying to say, but it's wrong. We're talking about communication of ideas between humans and computers. The claim that GUIs have enabled music production is nonsense given the vast amount of music produced without it. Same for desktop publishing. I can use beautiful fonts and images using TeX, for example. A command-line interface is no more a "magic incantation" than pointing and clicking in the right places is. In fact, I would argue that language is less magic than pointing and clicking because the rules of language are available for anyone to learn, while the rules of pointing and clicking are designed and only understood by the application developer. Damn me for having a different opinion, though.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoNo analogy is perfect, and I agree that this one falls apart in one important way: if you know what you're doing (!), a good CLI can be legitimately faster than even the best GUIs for certain tasks. But that's a big caveat. I've been volunteering at Girls Who Code. My club is doing a project that involves SSH'ing into a Raspberry Pi, and I've spent a significant amount of time getting the kids used to just moving through folders within the command line. Using cd and ls to navigate a file system is actually really tricky to wrap your head around if you're not used to it!
- chopin 7y agoI can relate. One of the things I miss most on the command line is the poor visualization especially of hierarchical stuff (file system, git history,...).
- ses1984 7y ago> fact, I would argue that language is less magic than pointing and clicking because the rules of language are available for anyone to learn, while the rules of pointing and clicking are designed and only understood by the application developer. I guess your command line uses natural language processing and is accessible to anyone who never read a man page or heard of a shell? The command line interface is no less opaque than "the rules of pointing and clicking".
- bch 7y ago> A command line interface isn't a great medium for singing, but graphical interfaces enabled sophisticated music production software, desktop publishing using beautiful fonts and images (examples he used). It enables expressiveness beyond what can be captured in mere text. Mere text[0][1]. CLI vs GUI in the context of this thread is a false dichotomy, because we’re imagining (I.e, inventing) scenarios where GUIs are better. “Look at this virtual rack of equipment in Reason and see how democratic that is.”[2] Sure, or a mess that begs to be put into a table in a text processor. Where it’s more truly democratic because a screen reader can be employed if necessary. Jobs was selling sparkles, successfully, not “computing”. “Do you want to sell sugar water for the rest of your life, or do you want to come with me and change the world?”, indeed. Why pick only one? Text isn’t dead or outmoded. [0] https://drive.google.com/file/d/1D6ZzTeUlk6mwqyZ0GIrhYIFeRkKa_Hnc/view?usp=drivesdk https://drive.google.com/file/d/1D6ZzTeUlk6mwqyZ0GIrhYIFeRkK... - my own, developed in console with vi, tmux, CSound, ffmpeg, custom software for compositing, Makefiles [1] https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/1319/showcase-of-beautiful-typography-done-in-tex-friends#24719 https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/1319/showcase-of-bea... [2] https://youtu.be/PjeFRLcioqk https://youtu.be/PjeFRLcioqk