5 ms·
I love the analogy between early command-line computer interfaces and the telegraph, versus graphical computer interfaces and the telephone. It's also funny to
by simonh 7y ago
I love the analogy between early command-line computer interfaces and the telegraph, versus graphical computer interfaces and the telephone.
It's also funny to that when he elaborates on this by saying we prefer not to describe where something is but just point to it, he did so with his finger. Of course in context he meant on a computer it's better to point with a mouse than enter commands, but it so nicely foreshadows his intuitive embrace of touch interfaces decades later.
- acqq 7y agoYes, his vision was permanently very clear. In this 1985 interview he already had: "The most compelling reason for most people to buy a computer for the home will be to link it into a nationwide communications network. We’re just in the beginning stages of what will be a truly remarkable breakthrough for most people—as remarkable as the telephone."
- globular-toast 7y agoI don't agree with the analogy. Telephones derive their power from the use of language just like command-line interfaces. Point and click interfaces will never surpass the power of language because it is language that makes us human.
- simonh 7y agoYou're completely missing the point. Language is about an awful lot more than words, it's about expressiveness and emotional content as well as just textual information. He talked about telephones letting people sing - express themselves though voice beyond mere words. A command line interface isn't a great medium for singing, but graphical interfaces enabled sophisticated music production software, desktop publishing using beautiful fonts and images (examples he used). It enables expressiveness beyond what can be captured in mere text. But it can do plain text just fine too. But the main point he made was not that these things can't be done using a command line, it's that a graphical interface democratises access by removing the need to learn special incantations to interact creatively with content.
- swiley 7y agoThere’s an awful lot of folk music notated in ABC (the musical equivalent of markdown.) IMO unless you’re actually drawing or looking at an image GUIs really kind of suck but are very sexy and help people sell a lot of software.
- ekianjo 7y agoYour examples are not very convincing. Desktop publishing powers tabloids while a great book remains a great book even in pure text format. Expressiveness is not limited to a medium, and if you ever used a command line interface you would understand the concept it pipes and arguments is way more expressive than a round of 100 clicks to do the same thing thru a GUI. GUI do democratise access to capabilities, but unless you work only with pixels GUIs are inferior in every single way.
- simonh 7y ago"If you ever used a command lien interface". That's a good one, I've been using Unix/Linux systems daily since the early 90s and test people on their Bash skills in job interviews.
- IggleSniggle 7y ago"Command lien interface" - a modality of interaction in which the empowered party (lienor) exerts control over someone with valuable property (lienee) via commands backed by a ephemeral interface that does not need to exist at compile time (lien), but is practical for eliminating bugs that arise from causality in economic systems.
- ekianjo 7y agoVery strange that bash has still not disappeared in 2019 if GUIs are so superior to every thing a command line interface can do.
- coldtea 7y ago>GUI do democratise access to capabilities, but unless you work only with pixels GUIs are inferior in every single way. Except in the way that matters: symbolic representation and manipulation (and discoverability). >Expressiveness is not limited to a medium, and if you ever used a command line interface you would understand the concept it pipes and arguments is way more expressive than a round of 100 clicks to do the same thing thru a GUI. Actually, a GUI can trivially include a pipe system (tons of VFX and Color gradings apps for example offer one, MAX/MSP and others). A GUI can also trivially include a text console, and have all the capabilities of the command line. The command line, on the other hand, can't have all the capabilities of the GUI. Even auto-completion is implemented crudely with curses interfaces (which, in any case, are GUIs too). (Oh, and I've been using the command line since the pre-Solaris days of Sun OS).
- jt2190 7y agoSome of us remember running applications from the command line. These were not the “does one thing well”, POSIX compliant, programmer/admin facing tools you still find in *nix these days. These were typically very limited, weird REPL sort of things where you might have eight or ten or fifty very domain specific commands that didn’t approach a Turing complete language. There was no other way to use the program other than the weird REPL that was provided.
- zozbot234 7y ago> It's also funny to that when he elaborates on this by saying we prefer not to describe where something is but just point to it, he did so with his finger "One evening, Master Foo and Nubi attended a gathering of programmers who had met to learn from each other. One of the programmers asked Nubi to what school he and his master belonged. Upon being told they were followers of the Great Way of Unix, the programmer grew scornful. 'The command-line tools of Unix are crude and backward,' he scoffed. 'Modern, properly designed operating systems do everything through a graphical user interface.' Master Foo said nothing, but pointed at the moon. A nearby dog began to bark at the master's hand. 'I don't understand you!' said the programmer. Master Foo remained silent, and pointed at an image of the Buddha. Then he pointed at a window. 'What are you trying to tell me?' asked the programmer. Master Foo pointed at the programmer's head. Then he pointed at a rock. 'Why can't you make yourself clear?' demanded the programmer. Master Foo frowned thoughtfully, tapped the programmer twice on the nose, and dropped him in a nearby trashcan. As the programmer was attempting to extricate himself from the garbage, the dog wandered over and piddled on him. At that moment, the programmer achieved enlightenment."