3 ms·
I have come to the conclusion that buying to occupy is no longer a rational decision. Consider a grid. On one axis, housing purchases are cheap or expensive. O
by jacques_chester 16y ago
I have come to the conclusion that buying to occupy is no longer a rational decision.
Consider a grid. On one axis, housing purchases are cheap or expensive. On the other axis, the local economy is vibrant or moribund.
Hence:
* Cheap + Vibrant: Basically doesn't exist.
* Cheap + Moribund: Bad place to buy, you're tied to a high-risk location.
* Expensive + Vibrant: Purchase cost will eat up the advantage of the local economy.
* Expensive + Moribund: Get out ASAP.
Why buy anywhere?
Similar logic applies to buying to rent. Why not diversify? Long term rates of return on share indices are competitive with property and do not have mortgage risk. They also don't have local property market risks. Vanguard will set you up with an international share fund, hedged or unhedged, very cheaply and easily.
- kscaldef 16y ago> On one axis, housing purchases are cheap or expensive. On the other axis, the local economy is vibrant or moribund. Neither of these things is binary.
- jacques_chester 16y agoIf it wasn't clear, I'm using "axis" in the sense of continuous values.
- whatusername 16y agoSo then look for Cheap + Improving.
- jacques_chester 16y agoNot a bad idea, but it assumes that you can forecast local markets. And you're still left with mortgage risk.
- teyc 16y agoahh I've heard of that before. It is the idea that markets are perfect. But in reality, you only need to find one house that is improperly priced. Given banks are pretty tight on lending now, a borrower who can convince the bank to lend is better placed to offer a lower price.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoEh, what are the odds that you're actually good at finding such a house? I mean, everyone thinks that they're an above-average driver; people naturally overestimate their own skills. And most people have absolutely zero training or practical experience in assessing either real estate markets or houses. And buying a house is not an emotionally neutral task that most people can remain clinically detached from: most people can't help looking at a house to buy and seeing their future there, visualizing their kids growing up there, etc. So they're likely to be emotionally attached to any house they like well enough to buy, which further reduces their ability to make a rational decision. My claim is that for every person who is actually skilled at this, there are many more who think they're skilled but really are not skilled at all.
- teyc 16y agonot that hard. It's only got only to be good enough. You are not an investor who has to invest $20M. For a 200K non-repeatable investment for someone willing to do the legwork, yes. It's like finding a GF. Most people eventually settle on someone. If you start by saying "all the good ones are taken" then you are unlikely to get any where.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoYou are not an investor who has to invest $20M. Most home buyers are looking for a home into which they'll be dumping the majority of their wealth. They have an incredible amount on the line. For a 200K non-repeatable investment for someone willing to do the legwork, yes. Why should we assume that many people know how to correctly do "the legwork"? Is real estate market assessment and pricing covered in school now? I mean, most people lack the mathematical sophistication needed to understand their mortgages -- let alone whether buying is a good decision.
- lwat 16y agoYea I kind of agree. From my perspective it only makes sense to buy if you really plan on living in the place for many years. And I'm too young for that kind of commitment so renting makes the most sense for me.
- elai 16y agoWhen you get to cheap+nice to retire, it's a good idea!
- jongraehl 16y agoFurther, the 'security' of a long term fixed mortgage at present low rates (as in: who cares if home prices drop because interest rates go up), is only useful if the economy remains locally vibrant, i.e. rents don't plummet. If you don't mind the stress and time, and are capable of selling quickly in a falling market, perhaps you should decide to buy when you're more than willing to bear the huge round-trip within 3 years transaction costs (scaled by your estimated probability of this happening).