3 ms·
Economist here! Austrian economics hasn't been totally ignored. However, the school of thought's aversion to econometrics makes their policy advice self-limiti
by tomrod 7y ago
Economist here!
Austrian economics hasn't been totally ignored. However, the school of thought's aversion to econometrics makes their policy advice self-limiting compared to mainstream/mainline economic theory. This means Austrian methods can occasionally diagnose a potential cause to a given economic malaise, but the methods can't quantify impact nor fully assess hypotheses regarding causal factors.
The second issue with the Austrian school is in the quest for ideological purity, extreme workarounds substitute for what the mainline has already worked through in the decades or centuries prior (e.g. Rothbard vs. utility). I recommend reading over Bryan Caplan's piece on why he is not an Austrian despite working in the famous US Austrian-supporting school, George Mason University.[0]
As for your specific points, that the large central financial institutions are, according to Austrian theory, causing recessions, even Austrian RBC doesn't completely agree.[1] Economic busts will happen with or without central banks -- being able to bail out key financial platforms is a good thing if it prevents the unnecessary misery of millions or billions. As every economics student should learn in the second half of economics 101, the free market does not always perfectly allocate resources, either immediately or over time (see discussions on externalities).
[0] https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm https://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/whyaust.htm
[1] https://mises.org/wire/economic-busts-can-happen-free-market-central-banks-make-things-much-worse https://mises.org/wire/economic-busts-can-happen-free-market...
- QuesnayJr 7y agoThis is way too kind. Once upon a time there was a school of important, economists who were literally Austrian -- Menger, Bohm-Bawerk, Hayek -- who had certain commonalities. Mises and Rothbard turned it into an ideological movement that deliberately did not engage with anyone else's ideas. A healthy intellectual movement doesn't need to be convinced to pay attention to empirical evidence.
- tomrod 7y agoFair point. Although in my defense I don't come to HN looking for or to start ideological fights :)
- Qasaur 7y ago>A healthy intellectual movement doesn't need to be convinced to pay attention to empirical evidence. You misunderstand the reasoning behind the "rejection" of empiricism by Mises and those that followed him. Austrian theory as formulated by Mises is based on a priori truths about human nature and cannot be falsifiable by evidence. This may sound outlandish when you first hear it especially when one comes from an engineering or natural science background, but there is a very well developed epistemological reasoning for this position that is often overlooked by critics. The economy is composed of humans who act towards their own personal goals, whether that is to provide for their family, or become a billionare tech founder. This is a highly complex system with an incredible amount of variables (in the case of individual humans, the ordinal scale of preferences is quite literally infinite!). As such, there are no constants that can be inferred with the same level of reliability that we may have in physics like the rate of gravity on planet Earth. Thus, empirical economic models have a much, much greater margin of error than what we have in the natural sciences, and it is therefore untenable to formulate economic theory based on inherently unreliable foundations. Instead, as the economy is composed of humans acting and not objects acting, the Austrians look inwards and through a Kantian-esque process of introspection formulate the a priori action axiom ("Human action is purposeful behaviour.") and build their theory using logic based on that axiom - thereby creating a system of knowledge that is unfalsifiable through evidence and is always true.
- duxut_staglatz 7y agoHow do we know whether this system of knowledge actually describe our world?
- tomrod 7y agoIf I understand the grandparent's point, we have to accept it as an axiom.
- duxut_staglatz 7y agoWhich leads to the question: if "because I assume so" is evidence enough for making statements, how do you sort of the conflicting predictions of one theory based on "I assume so" and another based on as much evidence? To give an example, let's assume that central bankers can make everyone better off by picking the right inflation rate. Therefore it is good to centrally plan the price and quantity of money. The grandparent's comment "let's assume"-based theory concluded that it is bad to centrally plan the price and quantity of money. Which advice should we follow?
- 0x445442 7y agoIf you're so inclined, can you comment on what you think Ron Paul was getting at when he used the phrase "Honest Money"? I'd like to hear what an Economist has to say about this.
- tomrod 7y agoI've actually not heard his use of the term. Can you provide a reference to see the context?
- 0x445442 7y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Pillars-Prosperity-Markets-Private-Property/dp/1933550244 https://www.amazon.com/Pillars-Prosperity-Markets-Private-Pr... https://www.lewrockwell.com/1970/01/ron-paul/bring-back-honest-money/ https://www.lewrockwell.com/1970/01/ron-paul/bring-back-hone... https://youtu.be/IF5pwDCpz4s?t=450 https://youtu.be/IF5pwDCpz4s?t=450
- gumby 7y agoHe uses the term to describe using gold and silver as currency instead of notes issued by a central bank. The ideological point is that people are fallible (or in his view manipulate) and some seemingly independent metric is superior. This ignores the empirical, historical evidence of the inflationary/deflationary boom/bust whipsaw of the gold standard eras (19th century in particular) which were hugely destructive and ruinous. More distressingly it also ignores the fact that money is a signaling mechanism and when the amount in circulation is out of relation to economic activity the economy breaks down. Yes, humans have a hard time figuring out what the level of economic activity is, but I am quite sure that gold strikes are not correlated with the production costs of iPhones and t shirts.
- Qasaur 7y ago>However, the school of thought's aversion to econometrics makes their policy advice self-limiting compared to mainstream/mainline economic theory. This I agree with, I do think there is tremendous value in using statistics as a way of analysing trends and reinforcing theoretical arguments with empirical data. I'd disagree strongly on the point that Austrian theory is not ignored by mainstream economists though as it seems like many of the underlying assumptions that justifies the Federal Reserve are rather flimsy when examined critically from an a priori Austrian perspective. >As for your specific points, that the large central financial institutions are, according to Austrian theory, causing recessions, even Austrian RBC doesn't completely agree.[1] Economic busts will happen with or without central banks -- being able to bail out key financial platforms is a good thing if it prevents the unnecessary misery of millions or billions. As every economics student should learn in the second half of economics 101, the free market does not always perfectly allocate resources, either immediately or over time (see discussions on externalities). Thanks for pointing this out, maybe I wasn't too clear in my post. I elaborate a bit more on this in a comment below, but didn't touch on the neccessity of having an institution able to bail out financial platforms during economic downturns. I do think that this boils down to the question if we can ethically and legally justify fractional-reserve banking, as bailouts would not be necessary if banks were mandated to keep a 100% reserve on demand deposits. I'm personally a bit split on this issue and so are many other Austrians, with purists adhereing to the Rothbardian view that only full-reserve banking is ethically defensible while others prefer leaving it to the free market to decide. I believe that in the latter case private insurance companies would be more than suitable to provide services to bail out banks who overextend credit, and would also serve as a natural check on said overextension as an insurance company would not be willing to take the risk to insure an irresponsible bank with a tendency to not make careful judgements. If anything, having a central institution that will bail out banks regardless of what happens is far more dangerous as it introduces a significant moral hazard whereby banks can take significant amount of risk (within applicable regulations, Basel III made it a bit more difficult after 2008) and know that they will be bailed out regardless of what happens. I can't say that this leads to a more stable economy than it would were we to have a full-reserve banking regime, or even a free market where banks choose their own reserve ratios.
- tomrod 7y ago
- Dumblydorr 7y agoWhy is econometrics important? I went to UChicago during 2007 and econometrics was a major bane of all Econ majors. There was something so anti-pragmatic about reducing irrational economic actors into mere equations. Meanwhile, did all of that sophisticated math improve the economy or predict the recession or help us out during recovery? It's nice to have hidden mathematical knowledge but is it actually providing benefits or is it just arcana?
- duxut_staglatz 7y agoEconometrics (aka stats for economists) is how we test models on real data. It seems to often be confused with the idea of using math in econ however ("reducing irrational economic actors into mere equations" seems to me to be economic theory, not something specific about econometrics). This has two purposes: - we would like to know which of our models are true, or at least good enough, and which ones are not. - we would like to know the actual magnitude of things. For instance, if we increase tax rate by 1%, how large will the taxable income reaction be? Decrease by 0%? .25%? 1%? 10%? That's useful information for policy making.
- Mikeb85 7y agoIs this a joke? Econometrics is literally how you test models, quantify changes in the economy, etc... Versus just hand-waving and hoping your assumptions work. And the reason economics doesn't always help the economy is because politicians almost never listen or shills are paid to advance policy that's detrimental to the economy.
- tomrod 7y ago> It's nice to have hidden mathematical knowledge but is it actually providing benefits or is it just arcana? It depends on the context. Plenty of areas of econometrics have substantial mathurbation, as do all quantitative fields. But the toolkit is not without use. (1) One common critique (which you leverage here) says that econometrics isn't useful because it doesn't predict business cycles. Macroeconomics divorced from microeconomic foundations[0] is a difficult domain to apply reasonable econometrics -- insufficient data to describe the system completely. (2) Individuals often present as irrational but populations tend to behave rationally -- meaning that descriptive information or predictive information can be ascertained.[1] This is the central point of ML/predictive analytics applied to human systems (e.g. marketing), which is where the value-add of ML can come from. (3) Remember the utility of econometrics is to measure economics -- that might be something like a value impact assessment, describing the output of a randomized control trial (for which the Nobel prize[2] was just awarded[3]), and similar. Economics is much bigger than only the macroeconomy. Notes: [0] The Lucas critique: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique, Theory before business-cycle measurement: http://faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/papers/qr1042.pdf http://faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~lchrist/papers/qr1042.... [1] To describe or predict: https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~aldous/157/Papers/shmueli.pdf https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~aldous/157/Papers/shmueli.pdf [2] I am aware the prize is not a real Nobel, the name is The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel [3] List of Economics Nobel Prize winners: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nobel_Memorial_Prize_laureates_in_Economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Nobel_Memorial_Prize_l...