4 ms·
It’s not really worrying. Disney owns the films. They don’t have to distribute them at all, and in this case, they’ve determined it that the money they’ll make
by dangus 7y ago
It’s not really worrying. Disney owns the films. They don’t have to distribute them at all, and in this case, they’ve determined it that the money they’ll make from an independent theater is smaller than the money they’ll make distributing another way, or perhaps not distributing at all for the time being.
I recently contacted a student artist to ask to buy a print of a work they posted on an art forum. I had no particular limit to my budget. The artist said no.
You know what I can do about it? Absolutely nothing. It doesn’t matter how badly I want that piece in my home.
- drtillberg 7y agoA business practice of refusing to make key cultural works available to the public-- this is on par with patent trolling. I don't debate their legal right to do it. It's still surprising and another reason to criticize both their business model and the current incarnation of copyright law, which this company had a significant role in creating.
- kiba 7y agoThere's almost nothing we can do about it, though. Nobody cares enough to force congress to reverse direction on copyright laws. However, individuals and companies can contribute to the public domain. That is something we can do regardless of what the current copyright law is.
- drtillberg 7y agoPatent trolling, for example, is less profitable due to reforms around the edges. We've seen an almost shocking level of legal innovation in many backwaters, from pot to legal opiod to climate change. The ground is shifting and a company that controls 40% of the nationwide market for anything is (or ought to be) subject to a higher standard.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoWe can change the laws. We just need enough people to make a fuss about it. This is a major misstep by Disney, because it the crosses over to the older generation. Best to spread the word.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- readams 7y agoYou seem to be confusing what is legal with what is reasonable. It's entirely justified to criticize a company for doing entirely legal things. Indeed it is impossible to make illegal everything for which a company might deserve such criticism.
- deogeo 7y ago> It's entirely justified to criticize a company for doing entirely legal things. Especially a company that had such a large role in writing those laws as Disney did.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dangus 7y agoSo then I’ll ask, what about this specific action is unreasonable?
- victoro0 7y agoIt is unreasonable to deny the entire public of works of art that are culturally relevant.
- dangus 7y agoWho determines what is culturally relevant? You’re saying that if I make my own movie with my own funding and time/effort, if enough people like it and the culturally relevant switch gets flipped on they get to take it from me while I’m still alive and I don’t have any say on whether my work is duplicated or screened? What if I run a SaaS product, people have been using it for 30 years, and they’ve determined it to be culturally relevant. Do they get to copy my source code and run it for themselves? These are 70s and 80s movies. Many of those who contributed to them are still alive. It’s entirely reasonable for those people to determine how/whether to distribute their own art. If you believe in that level of public ownership I can respect that you hold that opinion, but I don’t agree with it. At the same time, I do believe that copyrights expiring a lifetime after the creator dies are unreasonable. To me, the right balance of copyright law is somewhere in between the extremes of Mickey Mouse ownership in perpetuity and complete public ownership.
- zoul 7y agoIf they own the rights they can do whatever they want to, but that doesn’t mean we cannot consider it worrying. In fact, if we consider some of their actions too worrying, we can change the copyright law to better benefit the society.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kiba 7y agoIt's legal for them to do this, sure. It may even make business sense. But should a society lets them do this? That is more pertinent question.
- jimnotgym 7y agoIs it legal though? It could be market abuse?
- _ZeD_ 7y agohow everything you said "It’s not really worrying"?
- nobodyandproud 7y agoIt’s worrying because Disney lobbied over the years to increase the length of copyright. They perverted the intent of copyright, which is to encourage the arts by providing a temporary monopoly: After which artists are expected and encouraged to freely borrow any bits of the work and create their own. Now they’re outright restricting even viewing of famous works. Disney is terribly corrosive.
- gamblor956 7y agoWhile true, Disney has nothing compared to European authors, who lobbied the EU to create significantly stronger copyright protections than even Disney was able to lobby for in the US. So stop blaming Disney for the state of copyright, and start blaming all the European auteurs who tried (and nearly succeeded) in getting indefinite copyrights that passed down from the creator to his estate in perpetuity.
- chooseaname 7y agoAnd the reason they own some of them instead of the public, is that they are large and rich enough to have laws changed to allow them to continue to own them.