3 ms·
Yea, and the rule of law means that if you do something that’s legal, you shouldn’t be punished for it. Even if society later discovers that it made a mistake
by konschubert 7y ago
Yea, and the rule of law means that if you do something that’s legal, you shouldn’t be punished for it.
Even if society later discovers that it made a mistake when making it legal.
- stevesimmons 7y agoNotions of legality are rarely that black and white. It often depends on timing, context and intent. For instance, it is legal to sell a drug that is FDA-approved. But suppose: - It transpires years later that the FDA approval was based in part on the pharma company suppressing unfavourable clinical trial results. - The pharma company claims the FDA was aware (in some sense) of those suppressed studies, and still approved the drug. - A patient dies from adverse reactions observed in one of the suppressed studies. The patient's family is advised to litigate. Who is liable for what here?
- konschubert 7y agoYou are right, it's always more complex than it seems on first glance.
- 23throwaway23 7y agoBut not when you know your product causes harm and spend BILLIONS to suppress and sow confusion around the science. We have an excellent precedence in terms of big tobacco and the lies and disinformation they fed the public about the link between lung cancer and smoking.