3 ms·
I think we were at cross-purposes because you want to know whether your assumptions were reasonable, not whether they were false. Sorry about that, I wasn't hea
by skybrian 7y ago
I think we were at cross-purposes because you want to know whether your assumptions were reasonable, not whether they were false. Sorry about that, I wasn't hearing you.
It's true, Hacker News can be harsh sometimes, and I'm sorry you got downvoted so much. I don't think your assumptions were absurd.
But maybe there are better assumptions to make? Can we talk about that instead?
I'm not saying abstractions don't exist, but I would suggest taking some of them less seriously. In particular, I take the idea that companies are singular much less seriously. It's a show they put on for the convenience of the outside world and it takes effort to maintain. Internal politics is often hidden away. It's a leaky abstraction and often breaks down. (Sometimes literally through people leaking.)
Also, some things they don't try to standardize. Diversity of opinion can be fine.
Research, in particular, works that way. It would be weird to try to squelch diversity of opinion in research, where the whole point is to explore new ideas. Giving researchers the ability to publish their ideas, even those the company ends up not supporting, is a good way to recruit researchers.