6 ms·
Skylon’s SABRE Engine Passes a Big Test
- jcims 7y agoSkyon's SABRE Engine Component Passes a Big Test. Still very cool progress and quite the test setup.
- joshmn 7y agoHow do you pronounce it? Sah-brey or say-ber?
- amerine 7y agoSay-Ber
- shakna 7y agoSay-ber, like the sword. [0] [0] https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/pronunciation/english/sabre https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/pronunciation/english/sa...
- cryptozeus 7y agoHaha if this was office reference
- joshmn 7y agoIt is.
- nickpinkston 7y agoIn case anyone was confused by the article's description, here's the Wikipedia: "SABRE (Synergetic Air Breathing Rocket Engine) is a concept under development by Reaction Engines Limited for a hypersonic precooled hybrid air-breathing rocket engine. The engine is being designed to achieve single-stage-to-orbit capability, propelling the proposed Skylon spaceplane to low Earth orbit. SABRE is an evolution of Alan Bond's series of liquid air cycle engine (LACE) and LACE-like designs that started in the early/mid-1980s for the HOTOL project. The design comprises a single combined cycle rocket engine with two modes of operation. The air-breathing mode combines a turbo-compressor with a lightweight air precooler positioned just behind the inlet cone. At high speeds this precooler cools the hot, ram-compressed air, which would otherwise reach a temperature that the engine could not withstand, leading to a very high pressure ratio within the engine. The compressed air is subsequently fed into the rocket combustion chamber where it is ignited along with stored liquid hydrogen. The high pressure ratio allows the engine to provide high thrust at very high speeds and altitudes. The low temperature of the air permits light alloy construction to be employed and allow a very lightweight engine—essential for reaching orbit. In addition, unlike the LACE concept, SABRE's precooler does not liquefy the air, letting it run more efficiently. After shutting the inlet cone off at Mach 5.14, and at an altitude of 28.5 km, the system continues as a closed-cycle high-performance rocket engine burning liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen from on-board fuel tanks, potentially allowing a hybrid spaceplane concept like Skylon to reach orbital velocity after leaving the atmosphere on a steep climb." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine)
- trhway 7y ago>After shutting the inlet cone off at Mach 5.14, and at an altitude of 28.5 km, the system continues as a closed-cycle high-performance rocket engine burning liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen from on-board fuel tanks the benchmark of today - SpaceX - separates the first stage at Mach6-8 at 65-80km height. Thus, the SpaceX second stage has less delta-v to add and don't have to carry all that weight - the SABRE would naturally be bigger than the 2nd stage for the same payload. The economical space related case of HOTOL/SABRE single-stage-to-orbit pretty much disappeared for a foreseeable future when SpaceX started to recover the 1st stage. That not to say about suborbital flights SF-Shanghai though. Or even "just" hypersonic as SABRE tech seems to successfully deal with one of the major/key obstacles for it (and that is huge, i'm in no way trying to dismiss their work). And one can see how SABRE can be used in some cases as a convenient 1st stage, i.e. by being able to launch from any big airport instead of only specially designed spaceports (such a 1st stage would probably be better than that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket)#Carrier_aircraft https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket)#Carrier_aircr...).
- SECProto 7y agoImagine putting SABRE on the first stage though - the engines would be heavier, but using air instead of carrying oxygen, for the full burn of the first stage. The payload mass fraction would be dramatically higher without carrying the oxidizer mass on board.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- trhway 7y agoIt is possible though cost&complexity seems high - we theoretically can even today bundle a bunch of SR-71 engines and probably stretch them beyond designed Mach 3.3 for the short time. Having low thrust-to-weight (SABRE promises up to 14, SR-71 had 6) we'd need either a lot of them for VTOL which leads to high cost, or we're limited by the size of maximum realistically possible hypersonic capable plane, plus the plane body being the additional weight. For example VTOL calculation - say engine weights 1 ton, we can lift off 13 ton of fuel and payload. It will use 40 ton of O2 from the air. For rocket engine - 1 ton engine can lift off 100+ ton, and if we just take the 13 ton fuel plus 40 ton O2 we'd have 45 ton budget for the rest (body plus payload). In reality you'd need higher fuel ratio, and this is why VTOL for atmospheric breathing engine pretty much isn't an option . Going beyond pure rocket engine for the 1st stage i think air-augmented rocket (http://astronautix.com/g/gnom.html http://astronautix.com/g/gnom.html) being simpler (thus cheaper) would be the next step that would get us closer (specific impulse wise) to what SABRE is targeting.
- jacquesm 7y agoLooking forward to the integration test, if they get this to work it will be quite the engine.
- zer0sugar 7y agoIsn't it inevitable the SpaceX will (and already does) dominate the entire space industry? Won't it be cheaper to launch on starship than anythign else even for very small payloads? Yes, I know about RocketLab but I wonder if they will be able to survive once starship is up and running.
- ggm 7y agoEuropean governments will continue to back Ariane because strategically it makes sense. Russia will bankroll energyia likewise. Dominance is not static and private capital will not entirely replace state actions.
- avmich 7y agoA nitpick, Energiya doesn't make rockets this days, rather Soyuzes, Progresses, satellites, upper stages (Block D)... Launchers are made mostly by Khrunichev (Proton) and Progress (Soyuz-2). Russia tries to develop new rockets, but so far it's really slow and quite expensive. It's possible that when NASA will stop paying for Soyuz transport to ISS, it will become even slower. It's not a particularly good time in Russia for new rockets paid by the state.
- ggm 7y agoAll true, but do you seriously think Putin will renounce a domestic space industry? They might pick jv partnerships like ariane to stay afloat. Or sell engines or something but i dont see them giving up. To your side of this, the cash flow to a russian space sector will end when a man rated launcher from the U.S. starts making regular trips to the ISS, I guess.
- avmich 7y ago> do you seriously think Putin will renounce a domestic space industry? Probably not. It's possible to bring the space industry to the state of aviation industry, but 1) some resources are still available to maintain some level (as you mentioned) 2) to keep the same level, one needn't spend too much effort and 3) there are some interested parties in Russia which wouldn't want too deep degradation of space industry (e.g. periodically some hints to that come from Samara). So a likely outcome could be maintenance of some expertise, at least for military purposes, and possibly attempts to cooperation with foreign partners - China, Europe etc. No total destruction; "just" - potentially - another deep crisis.
- travisporter 7y agoHere’s to a single stage to orbit craft a la Kerbal space program’s RAPIER engine (although it’s probably still not realistic to expect better than two stage due to the rocket equation)
- btbuilder 7y agoPretty sure KSP RAPIER is a fictional copy of the described SABRE engine.
- riffraff 7y agoThe names seem to indicate that, both being similar kind of weapons.
- travisporter 7y agoAbsolutely. https://wiki.kerbalspaceprogram.com/wiki/CR-7_R.A.P.I.E.R._Engine https://wiki.kerbalspaceprogram.com/wiki/CR-7_R.A.P.I.E.R._E...
- privateSFacct 7y agoThese guys don't disappear - they have been around forever with their Skylon plane. Just a heads up, it's a long way from testing one component of an engine on the ground to getting a full engine demo going to then testing it in the air to then build the plane then integrating engine - then getting orbital trips working with reentry! I am curious how much private capital they have been able to attract (outside of govt contract players). Obviously if this is really revolutionary then they will but this always felt like a long term / govt kinda of cool - tech forward but pork barrel project for the UK. More of their background from a somewhat more balanced source - at least the headline put revolutionary in quotes. https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-36773074 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-36773074 They do claim to have the "best engineers" in the industry - so beating out big players like rolls royce, PW, CFM, spacex, blue origin, ariane aerospace - so that is a positive they have.
- walkingolof 7y agoThese things take time, but it's not the complete story, Virgin Galactic has been around since 2004, so the same year GMail launched, without producing a single passenger flight. Blue Origin has been around for almost 20 years, and they have a few suborbital flights to their credit, and an engine that has yet to fly. SpaceX, on the other hand, has been around since 2002 and achieved orbit in 2008, and have completed a lot of milestones since then. I suspect the biggest difference between these companies is not talent or vision, but sens of urgency
- heisenbit 7y agoSense of urgency lets one leverage the best current technologies and take the best compromises within the time and monetary budget. But this is incremental innovation. It fails at tackling novel concepts where the paths forward are not so clear. You can't incrementally tunnel through a wall. At one point maybe SABRE is ready and the next SpaceX comes along and will build a spaceship with it. The spoils of innovation seldom accrue with the inventors.
- growlist 7y ago
- credit_guy 7y agoEveryone over here on HN seems to be quite negative about the SABRE engine. While there's very little evidence for this engine being useful for orbital applications, it is instead a very compelling idea for a Concorde and/or SR-71 replacement. Scramjet engines don't seem to be happening anytime soon (I just listened to a Queensland University researcher saying that their research may yield an actual engine in 4-5 decades). This idea of pre-cooling the incoming air seems closer to reality.