3 ms·
I read the article. But I don't get the point. What are they proposing? That people with means be prohibited from hiring people to perform services for them?
by fortran77 7y ago
I read the article. But I don't get the point.
What are they proposing? That people with means be prohibited from hiring people to perform services for them?
- leoh 7y agoTwo thoughts: * fires are becoming an increasing problem and there isn't a sound, coordinated, public effort to deal with them right now; if the wealthy, who generally have a lot of political power, are shielded from the fire issue through their personal wealth, then there could be a diminished incentive to solve the problem generally for the public * it's hard to fight fires and the wealthy could marshal firefighters that are needed for public usage and the public might not offer enough compensation/resources to protect the public
- valley-green 7y ago> there isn’t a sound, coordinated, public effort to deal with them. Please, open your eyes. This statement is an insult to the many fire agencies involved in preventing and attacking the fires. We are doing everything we can to prevent and stop these wildfires. A majority of the fire response is from public agencies with public funds. Get your head out of your ass.
- leoh 7y agoCan't reply to `valley-green` since their post was reported. But I genuinely am sorry if this came off as an affront to firefighters as they do work incredibly hard. What I mean to say is that there is a more general public, government-led effort required to cut back fire risk; in no particular order: * more controlled burns * continue to upgrade firefighting capabilities * continue to hire more firefighters * enhance preventative maintenance of power lines by cutting back brush * enhance power infrastructure by insulating or burying lines
- clarry 7y agoI sense fear. Is it not ok to tell the world that you're scared even if you have no solution to offer? The fear is that a public service that should, within their capability, protect everyone without discrimination is over time going to be replaced by private services that only protect those who can pay. I believe that is the point. Now we can contemplate whether that fear is justified, whether it should be dismissed, or if something should be done to resolve it. Of course security and safety is already a privilege of the rich (to an extent), but you could go further in that direction. Or try to swing back.
- fortran77 7y agoSomeone who has a very large house with very large grounds paying for additional private services for fire protection seems _fair_ to me. Should the public pay for the increased cost to cover someone with a house and property much larger than what the median home and property is? The wealthy are stepping up to the plate and paying for the additional services they need without public help. And keeping the fires from spreading though their own property will no doubt have a beneficial effect on those around them, too.
- david-gpu 7y ago> Should the public pay for the increased cost to cover someone with a house and property much larger than what the median home and property is? A large real estate property pays large property taxes every year, so I don't understand your argument.
- clarry 7y agoI'm somewhat inclined to agree that there's nothing wrong per se with paying for additional services that you desire. The problem is manyfold. > Someone who has a very large house with very large grounds paying for additional private services for fire protection seems _fair_ to me. The need to pay for additional services at all is indicative that the public service is insufficient to keep us and our property safe. Fire does not discriminate between rich and poor; that should be a concern for everyone, but only the rich can do something about it (by throwing money at it). > Should the public pay for the increased cost to cover someone with a house and property much larger than what the median home and property is? If the rich have more land and property to risk, then they should be paying more taxes too. The public service should not discriminate against them. Why is the service insufficient to keep their property safe, and how can we trust them to keep the poor safe? Of course you can have more land than the average citizen without being FU rich. In that case, the land is probably your job, and someone else's food or job down the chain. Shouldn't the public service protect those too? > And keeping the fires from spreading though their own property will no doubt have a beneficial effect on those around them, too. Yep, helps all the rich in their rich enclave where the poor cannot afford to live. > The wealthy are stepping up to the plate and paying for the additional services they need without public help. One of the fears I perceive here is that it's a slippery slope. If public service is insufficient and privatization becomes more prominent, one day it's going to be the one and same fire service everyone needs, but only the rich can afford. See health care, etc.