4 ms·
> If you think it’ll cost a lot but end up ineffective [...] then it’s completely rational to vote against it. That is true, and I easily agree with everything
by dahart 7y ago
> If you think it’ll cost a lot but end up ineffective [...] then it’s completely rational to vote against it.
That is true, and I easily agree with everything you said, but FWIW there have been studies on whether cost-benefit analysis actually works by examining the outcomes after the fact. For example this set of case studies demonstrating that cost-benefit decision making would have historically made the wrong choice, and that sometimes our estimates for costs in the future are wrong by orders of magnitude.
https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1326&context=facpub https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...
Point being that the completely rational vote isn’t always the right vote. Focusing on costs rather than goals sometimes leads us to miss the big picture.
- rayiner 7y agoOn the flip sides, focusing on goals rather than costs leads to programs that cost stratospheric amounts without producing the desired results. At the end of the day, we must attempt to rationally analyze our world and make decisions accordingly. If we abandon that, we might as well resort to religion. ("Climate change is God punishing us for the sins of capitalism!" "No! God wouldn't let climate change happen to God's people!").
- dahart 7y agoCost-benefit is not the only way to rationally analyze the world. There are more than two options here, it’s not either cost-benefit or religion. The suggestion is not to ignore all costs, the suggestion is to be more thoughtful about using speculative estimates when deciding whether to do something big that will have a positive outcome, and not to prematurely limit our willingness to do it because the estimated benefits don’t total more that the known financial costs. The evidence here is that cost-benefit analysis has produced incorrect results, especially the larger the stakes, and further in the future the outcomes are. The big mistake in calculations is the estimated benefits, which are intrinsically difficult to put a monetary value number on, and highly prone to wildly incorrect predictions. Over-reliance on cost-benefit analysis in this sense might be just as bad as religion; it is not well suited to all scenarios, prone to failure when costs aren’t actually known, prone to failure when applied incorrectly, and it’s not the only way to rationally analyze decisions. > focusing on goals rather than costs lead to programs that cost stratospheric amounts without producing the desired results. Just curious, I don’t doubt there are some, I just don’t know what they are. What would count as some examples of that having happened in the past, akin to the examples I linked of leaded gasoline, damming the Grand Canyon, or removing vinyl chloride from workplaces?
- rayiner 7y ago> Cost-benefit is not the only way to rationally analyze the world. First, the article paints a strawman of cost-benefit analysis. Cost-benefit analysis can consider different scenarios, probabilistic measures, and even qualitative components. Second, what's the alternative? If you don't at least quantify the things that are quantifiable, all you're doing is going by gut feelings and emotion. And that's the province of savages. > Just curious, I don’t doubt there are some, I just don’t know what they are. What would count as some examples of that having happened in the past, akin to the examples I linked of leaded gasoline, damming the Grand Canyon, or removing vinyl chloride from workplaces? There are many areas where over-emphasis on desired outcomes and goals, while ignoring costs, led to poor results. The war on poverty: https://www.heritage.org/poverty-and-inequality/report/the-war-poverty-after-50-years https://www.heritage.org/poverty-and-inequality/report/the-w... The war on drugs: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/31/opinion/failed-war-on-drugs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/31/opinion/failed-war-on-dru... Doubling education spending per student since 1970 (in constant dollars): http://www.foundry.org/wp-content/uploads/ed-spend-fam-facts.jpg http://www.foundry.org/wp-content/uploads/ed-spend-fam-facts... The Iraq War, most of our Middle East policy, and the TSA. Socialism: https://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/socialism-marking-century-death-destruction https://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/socialism-markin.... (Huge disaster from an environmental standpoint.) Many environmental disasters are the result of focusing on goals or outcomes without thinking about costs. Irrigating the southwest, damming the Colorado, hydroelectric power, opposition to nuclear power in the 1960s and 1970s, etc.