3 ms·
This gets silly, though. If you are going for full isolation where applications can't just let the user have data, then you have to coordinate every app talkin
by taeric 7y ago
This gets silly, though. If you are going for full isolation where applications can't just let the user have data, then you have to coordinate every app talking to every other app.
This is why the share button on a phone is ridiculous. Instead of just copy to clip board, you get a ton of options.
Is it safer? Hard to say. I can do less and have less capabilities without more active work from the developers.
There is something to be said for this, of course. But it seems a losing game. I contend there is no technical panacea to security versus convenience.
- GauntletWizard 7y agoThere is no technical panacea, but containers are a useful abstraction. Containers bring back the original intent of the unix process/user security model, allowing you to scope each process to have it's own 'private' filesystem to get around the broken way executables are built, packaged, and linked. This doesn't save you if you do dumb things, like have open ports that allow administrative access that are exposed to the rest of your (potentially malicious) system. They do force you to think about some of the questions, though, like "Where is my data stored and how do other tools interact with it?" Most of the problems that people complain containers don't solve are ones that are open ended, and have no definite solution.
- taeric 7y agocontainers are a great tool for corporate servers. For end user machines, it is a tougher sell.
- GauntletWizard 7y agoWhat do you think of the permissions associated with Android apps? Each developer gets a separate and cordoned user account on your phone. They only have access to private storage unless they request it through special APIs. Android apps are run in containers, for some broad sense of the word. That's how it should be. Every app I run should be run with a simply configured set of permissions, and "per app" or "as user" makes sense, even in the desktop space. That's what snap originally tried to do (but failed at, and have now broken)
- taeric 7y agoIsn't that where I said it can get silly? I don't want developers having an account on my phone. I just want to process some data on my phone. Consider that on my phone, I am limited to accessing my data for most apps through the apps. On my computer, I typically know where the data is stored.
- robocat 7y ago> This is why the share button on a phone is ridiculous. Instead of just copy to clip board, you get a ton of options. Off topic, but I don't understand your objection... On Android Chrome the share button shows you a context sensitive choice of apps that will accept the object (a link, some text, etc), followed by a second choice of what the app can do with the object. The flow for copy-then-paste is more convoluted and is waaay less discoverable. Copy then paste is still available for the situations where it has an advantage.
- taeric 7y agocopy-then-paste is only more convoluted if you haven't learned how computers have worked for a long time. And things have gotten some better for the phone option. But I don't have or want all apps installed. So, my sharing is dominated by copy/paste, still.