4 ms·
They offer one likely non-sinister explanation right in the article: “The software engineer market, it’s so saturated with H-1Bs that some of the people who ar
by triceratops 7y ago
They offer one likely non-sinister explanation right in the article:
“The software engineer market, it’s so saturated with H-1Bs that some of the people who are laid off are almost inevitably H-1Bs and some of the people that are being hired are inevitably H-1Bs,” Bier said. “I don’t read into it anything like this is obviously job displacement.”
- carapace 7y ago"What's the most important part of any message?" "The name of the messenger." The quote is from > Immigration policy analyst David Bier of the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, [who] didn’t see evidence of H-1B abuse by Uber in its increased visa approvals and efforts to obtain more.
- wheelerwj 7y agoCato is far from a libertarian think tank, its a Republican think tank, originally it was the Charles Koch Foundation.
- carapace 7y agoI'm quoting TFA.
- monoideism 7y agoSorry, but Cato is definitely a libertarian leaning think tank (one of their few redeeming qualities, in my mind): - Penn and Teller, the original small l libertarians, are in the board at Cato. That pair wouldn't be caught dead associating with some neocon or populist outfit. - Cato created and maintain libertarianism.org - first sentence in Wikipedia's description of Cato: "The Cato Institute is an American libertarian think tank headquartered in Washington, D.C."
- gyc 7y agoWe can quibble about the exact political slant of Cato, but it definitely takes policy positions that are more libertarian than mainstream Republican positions. See, for example, the drug war.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoThat whole "it doesn't look like job replacement" is completely ludicrous, because math. H-1B exists solely because industry says they can't find needed talent. If you've just had a huge number of layoffs of said talent, you should be getting 0 H-1Bs.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoWARN notices should trigger an H1B lockout/cool off period for at least a year.
- dmode 7y agoThere is no legal requirement like that. H1 has a simple rule - that you should have a degree and work on a field that USCIS considers specialized. Comp engineering is one of them
- mattnewton 7y agoThat's the law as written, but it is commonly sold to the public as the parent post's "filling competitive positions with talent that can't be found domestically."
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI'm not talking about any legal requirement. Two things: 1. I'm simply refuting the ludicrous-on-its-face idea that if you just laid off hundreds of highly paid technical employees, that then hiring double the amount of H-1B's the following year, claiming you are not "displacing any American workers" is total BS. 2. Regardless of the letter of the law, certainly the political justification of why the US should have the H-1B program at all, which is argued by all the SV lobbying groups, is that the US needs workers in specialized fields because there aren't enough US workers. Also, FWIW, I believe H-1B is a horrible program because it really only benefits the companies while basically allowing the visa holders to be treated like slaves. I'd be much more in favor of a simple "skilled occupations" global lottery that wasn't tied to any specific employer, with stronger protections to ensure visa holders aren't underpaid.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoThe thing that doesn't make sense to me here is that layoffs are supposed to be about having too many employees rather than about having low-quality employees. Why are they hiring at all? Shouldn't they have just laid off fewer people if they need more than they have now?
- triceratops 7y agoThat assumes employees are fungible. Which they are not, especially in tech roles. They may have too many employees in some departments and not enough in others. They may also need to replace people who quit of their own volition.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoA tech employee from another department should be able to get up to speed at least as quickly as an outside hire.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]