6 ms·
This is a strange title. Why did they use the word 'citizens' rather than just 'people'? Does it imply something important? As opposed to what else? Foreign mer
by chrisseaton 7y ago
This is a strange title. Why did they use the word 'citizens' rather than just 'people'? Does it imply something important? As opposed to what else? Foreign mercenaries of some kind? Or was it mistranslated and it's actually 'civilians' and the news is they're using non-military personnel for this?
And isn't this a really small appointment? Is the story actually that the MoD has created a cyber reserve force? It's a very small one if it's just a company's worth of people.
- tluyben2 7y agoYou cannot just be resident in the Netherlands; you need to be a citizen. The whole point here is that you get to work 'in the army' while you do not have to be physically fit to do so, so basically any citizen (but not residents) with relevant knowledge & experience can apply for some of these positions (the ones that are non combat and do not require physical training or fitness).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ddalex 7y agoWhat if I'm Romanian and move permanently to the Netherlands with my job, family, house, etc, as I can under UE law? I would be a resident, but not a citizen, correct?
- jascii 7y agoCorrect. for a quick run-down of Dutch immigration law see: https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/how-become-permanent-resident-or-citizen-netherlands https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/how-beco... I suspect op refers to a requirement to be a citizen to join the military, but can't be sure.
- tluyben2 7y agoThe terminology was specific mentioning 'citizen' which is because you cannot join any of the state security positions, including military, if you are not a citizen but 'only resident'. The letter written by the secretary of defence notes specifically that they are looking for people in the corporate world to join but that these people must be citizens.
- jascii 7y agoDank je wel voor de verklaaring! (gosh my dutch is rusty!)
- roel_v 7y agoYes.
- dogma1138 7y agoNo you need to be a Dutch national (as in having, or being able to claim a Dutch passport), it's the same with Romanian army, you have to be Romanian to join. EU Law doesn't prevent EU members from discriminating against EU Nationals unless it explicitly discriminates against them, for example you can't disallow specific employment under the freedom of movement if it's allowed under a non-EU work visa (there are few exemptions when it comes nationals of "EU" territories which have various ties to specific EU member states and may or maynot be EU nationals on their own right), if you look at national level government employment as a whole across the EU they either limit employment of EU nationals (sometimes with caveats such as unless they lived in the host nation for a certain period of time) or set quotas on how many EU nationals you can employ in any given agency or institution. This is because many government institutions and agencies while not being elected officials do affect and even set policy all the time. The EU "officially" isn't set to supercede national sovereignty of its member states so it's not really surprising why France might not want the majority of its foreign service employees to be German or why Germany might not want a bunch of Polish prosecutors and judges mucking with its legal system. Also don't forget that being an EU national while grants you the right to vote in another member state, you are only allowed to vote for the EU elections in that state. Whether member states allow EU nationals to vote in local, or general elections is up to the individual member state, most of them disallow it, the same thing goes for running for office in some places you can run for local elections but even in those nations many of the party bylaws disallow foreign membership so you have to run as an independant. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_militaries_that_recruit_foreigners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_militaries_that_recrui...
- Someone 7y agoThey’re loosening the physical fitness requirements for cyber-reservists who will never be sent out on a mission. Idea is that that will make it easier to find such reservists. That seems to be the case.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gallexme 7y agoNot every person in Netherlands is a citizen? Many only have allowances, I'm pretty sure they mean owners of citizenship
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I'm pretty sure they mean owners of citizenship I know what the word 'citizen' means. I was saying I think it's the wrong word because it's redundant. Of course they're hiring citizens - almost no military recruits anything else (except for commonwealth issues).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- realityking 7y agoThe US Armed Forces allow enlisting as a permanent resident: https://www.usa.gov/join-military https://www.usa.gov/join-military There are quite a few exceptions to "militaries don't recruit non-citizens": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_militaries_that_recruit_foreigners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_militaries_that_recrui... Most relevant to the case at hand, a number of EU countries allow EU citizens to serve in their militaries: Belgium, Denmark, Ireland and Luxembourg
- chrisseaton 7y agoBut I mean it’s not what the story is about - the story is about them being a new class of non-deployable soldiers - them being citizens or not is unchanged and orthogonal. So why’s it in the title as if it’s party of what’s newsworthy?
- jacquesm 7y agoDeplorable? Deployable maybe?
- jt0 7y agoIs that true? According to this, in the US at least, "Roughly 35,000 non-citizens are serving in active duty military and about 8,000 join each year."[1] The US government also deports some of its honorably discharged veterans.[2] [1] https://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/eligibility-requirements/the-us-military-helps-naturlize-non-citizens.html https://www.military.com/join-armed-forces/eligibility-requi... [2] https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2019/06/12/ice-is-supposed-to-consider-service-when-deporting-veterans-it-hasnt-been/ https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2019/06/12/...
- qz_ 7y agoI think the OP meant civilians
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- modernerd 7y agoCivilians is a closer translation. Civilians can't normally participate in Dutch military and defense programs. This pilot seeks to change that and set up a reserve force to enhance existing security expertise from the Dutch military and police forces. Here's the full translated text from the docx: ~~~ During the General Personnel Consultation on 11 September this year, I undertook to inform your House of Representatives about the cyber reservists pilot in which the selection process deviates from the physical requirements that apply regularly for appointment as a soldier. I will discuss the principles that apply, the appointment process and the first results. Starting points for different requirements The Ministry of Defense is increasingly in need of cyber professionals: civilian employees, professional soldiers and reservists. Under the humanitarian law of war (HOR) only soldiers are allowed to participate in the fight. In or from the Netherlands only soldiers and the police have powers of violence. The use of civilian employees for performing acts of violence is not permitted; professional soldiers or reservists are required for this. A number of cyber activities also fall under the practice of acts of violence. To be able to recruit more cyber reserves, the cyber reserves pilot was launched on 6 November 2018. The Defense organization organizes so-called Matching Days (M-Days) several times a year with the aim of identifying suitable cyber reservists. In addition, candidates are approached who must be (partially) exempted from certain physical and medical requirements as included in the CDS instruction "Preparation of individual soldiers". These are the candidates who are ultimately classified in the category "not broadcastable, but employable." Appointment process The Ministry of Defense organizes the above-mentioned M-days about nine times a year. Candidates for these days are largely recruited via the cyber professionals' own network. The Defense organization is also actively seeking contact with the business community for potential candidates. When a candidate shows an interest, a short matching procedure is started based on his or her Curriculum Vitae (CV). As soon as there is interest in the candidate from the Ministry of Defense, he is asked to fill in an (online) personality questionnaire and to take a cyber substantive test prior to the M-day. The candidate is then invited for an M-day. During this day, applicants are selected for a position as a cyber reservist based on various tests, (group) assignments and interviews. A maximum of fifteen candidates are present per M-day, of which ten were able to continue the appointment process last year. Applicants who, after an M-day, do not appear to have the required competencies and therefore do not qualify for a position as a cyber reservist, can, if they wish, follow the regular appointment, selection and testing process for other (reserve) positions. Applicants for whom it has been established on M-day that they have sufficient potential for a cyber reserve position, are offered the choice between the regular appointment process or the deviating process. If they opt for the latter, they will be appointed as a non-transferable reservist without a further medical or sporting examination, after issuing a Declaration of No Objection (VGB). Applicants who opt for the regular procedure go through the inspection process at the Personnel Logistics Service Center (DCPL) in two days. In the event of a positive result of these tests, these applicants are appointed, after issuing a VGB, as a reservist without restrictions on deployment. Applicants who drop out during this follow-up process can still be appointed as a non-broadcast cyber reservist. First results The pilot has been running for almost a year and the first results are positive. At the start of the pilot, the Ministry of Defense had thirty cyber reserves. In the meantime, 72 have actually been appointed (of which nine with the special form of appointment can be deployed but cannot be deployed). In addition, there are 48 aspiring cyber reservists (nine of whom have completed the adjusted procedure) that have already been selected and are still awaiting appointment. Due to their specific knowledge and experience, the eighteen non-broadcastable (aspiring) cyber reserves are important for the cyber capacity of the Ministry of Defense. At the moment 22 candidates have applied for the next M-days. This pilot runs until the end of 2020. At that time, a final evaluation will be drawn up with conclusions and recommendations for a follow-up process. I will inform your Chamber about this.
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoIt might be because for highly sensitive security roles, each government usually only allows citizens to participate, as opposed to resident immigrants that where not born in that country.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mothsonasloth 7y agoService guarantees citizenship. Would you like to know more?
- RosanaAnaDana 7y agoThere are no dangerous weapons; there are only dangerous men.
- jacquesm 7y agoMen with weapons are more dangerous than men without therefore weapons are dangerous.
- ctrlc-root 7y agoIt's a quote by Robert Heinlein from Starship Troopers (https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/141333-there-are-no-dangerous-weapons-there-are-only-dangerous-men https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/141333-there-are-no-dangero...). I don't agree with your reasoning either by the way. Men with pencils are more dangerous than men without therefore pencils are dangerous.
- jacquesm 7y agoWhen wielded properly pencils are indeed dangerous, even more dangerous than swords in some cases. But less dangerous - in the general case - than say a gun or a knife which is why we call those weapons in the first place. Note that according to the definition of a weapon ("a thing designed or used for inflicting bodily harm or physical damage") a pencil can be classed as a weapon due to its use. Which is a perfect illustration of why men with pencils (used as weapons) are more dangerous than men without. So thank you for making my point.
- ctrlc-root 7y agoI think you actually made mine which was that anything can be classed as a weapon therefore the object in question isn't as relevant as the person wielding it. Yes, you can put them on a continuum, but I'd still rather not be in an elevator with a person intent on doing me harm regardless of the object they are holding. "There are no dangerous weapons; there are only dangerous men."
- C1sc0cat 7y agoSecurity Clearances
- peterwwillis 7y agoBecause if it just said 'people', someone else would ask, "are they allowing _anyone_ from _any country_ to join, or residents, or citizens?" You're assuming that the wording of 'people' should be obvious, and other people will find it non-obvious. They just picked one.
- velox_io 7y agoYeah, the correct term is civilian or more commonly known as civvy. Error, in translation? Or they may need to be a Dutch citizen for security clearance, which would make sense. It does sound similar to the UK's version, and I'm sure most countries have some sort of cyber division by now. Plus there's suppliers and consultants, like traditional forensics and computer forensics/ data retrieval e.g.
- jascii 7y agoI think a clearer title would be "Dutch pilot project waves military physical requirements for cyber-military roles in reserve force" Whether the aspirant reservists are citizens is not relevant to the article and the moment they join the reserve force they would not be civilians anymore.
- usrusr 7y agoThank you. The title alone made me wonder if they perhaps drafted a bunch of appropriately qualified civilians into that role, perhaps on basis of some ancient law that has never been enacted so far but it's technically still on the books. Because who knows how exactly "reservist" is defined in the Netherlands. (and if it meant, in the context of "cyber-military", that they might occasionally come for you at weird hours with requests for consulting, it might not even be all that terrible)