4 ms·
A quick thought experiment... If you wanted to transfer 2MW, you could do it at 200 amps and 10,000 volts. Two 200 amp conductors, 3 meters long, and 10 mm^2
by londons_explore 7y ago
A quick thought experiment...
If you wanted to transfer 2MW, you could do it at 200 amps and 10,000 volts.
Two 200 amp conductors, 3 meters long, and 10 mm^2 cross sectional area will come out at half a kilogram. 400 watts of heating will happen in the wire, which could be cooled by a 1mm^2 water/steam return cooling pipe in each conductor running at 1 ml/sec. That weighs another 12 grams.
Insulating a 10,000 volt supply sounds a lot, but if the wire was insulated with PTFE, with a 10x safety margin, you would only need a thickness of 1mm on each conductor. Total weight 140 grams.
So - the total weight of a 2 Megawatt human-safe cable could, with the right engineering, be under a kilogram (2 lbs) for 3 meters of cable, plenty to hook up your car or truck.
- mdorazio 7y agoYou're not wrong, but what is an EV going to do with 10,000 volts? You'd have to convert that into something useful to the battery system, so all you've done is shove the efficiency drop and heating issues into the vehicle's on-board transformer systems (which would add more weight) instead of the charger.
- timerol 7y ago> “If we increase the voltage on the car side then we can reduce the current we need to push through the cable….so we are looking at higher voltage drivetrains,” says Elshout. Presumably connect the batteries in series rather than parallel, so that the voltage is increased and the current is lessened
- londons_explore 7y agoIt isn't unreasonable to have a battery which can reconfigure itself. It could switch from parallel to series just by opening and closing a few relays.
- mdorazio 7y agoI'm thinking this would probably greatly increase the chance of arcing and catastrophic battery failures in the cell packs, but I'm not certain on that. Also, you still need to get that power into something useful for the rest of the car now - usually 12V for electronics and probably 350ish volts AC for the motor, so you're still going to need to deal with the conversions at some point. There's a reason high-voltage lines are nowhere near people and transformers are chunky as hell. Probably those reasons overlap with EV design constraints.
- AWildC182 7y agoIt's entirely doable. Tesla packs are already close to 400V and it's totally possible to go much higher. Keep in mind that every battery is a resistor so the voltage across each one is still tiny, even if the overall series voltage is massive. The reason power transmission equipment looks so weird is A) because it handles 345,000V and B) we have a lot of it and the chunky transformers and bare, massively spaced out conductors are way cheaper than wrapping everything in teflon. Also, pretty much all EVs have a 12v lead acid cell somewhere. It's kinda dumb but it's the cheapest solution to having 12v for relevant systems. The pack/charger voltage is stepped down to charge them.
- greglindahl 7y agoRemember that OP said 10k volts. 400 isn't close to that. For all the "move fast and break things" of Tesla, they haven't moved fast and electrocuted people with a 10k volt battery system.
- londons_explore 7y agoDownconverting voltages is surprisingly easy - a single bank of MOSFETS and an inductor is all you need. A 2MW convertor made of [1] comes out to less than 100 grams (excluding cooling, but that's fairly small at ~100 watts). There are also a lot of reasons to increase voltages in EV battery systems. The current ~400V systems need thick heavy internal wiring, and for all electric (ie. no mechanical) braking and ultra fast charging, they are insufficient. [1]: http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/csd19537q3.pdf http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/csd19537q3.pdf
- baybal2 7y agoHave you seen voltage rating on that thing? You can't reliably handle 1500V+ voltages in solid state electronics without purpose made IGBTs, or exotic semiconductor materials. Your EE knowledge doesn't seem to be more than cursory.
- londons_explore 7y agoIt has a maximum voltage rating of 100V, so you would need 100 in series, with leak resistors to prevent any one avalanching. This is how most modern high voltage switches work, because IGBT's are far less flexible. Take apart a tesla Model 3 motor controller and let me know what you find...
- baybal2 7y agoTo begin with, Tesla's "motor controller" is an inverter. The charger on board is AC-DC. DC-DC It's an old, but still not completely solved problem: imagine your stack open, but for a single FET, and your resistor is a little bit off. It instantly pops, and the "tuning" for the rest of it is now completely off, and it will cascade further In case of Tesla, they do use the exotic semiconductor materials I mentioned above. SiC goes to 1500V nominally You need to learn electronics engineering beyond wiring Arduinos There is old, but still quite good and relevant explanation why stacking FETs suck on edaboard https://www.edaboard.com/showthread.php?269261-Is-MOSFET-in-series-is-possible https://www.edaboard.com/showthread.php?269261-Is-MOSFET-in-... There is an even older, but still excellent paper published by Philips called "Power Semiconductor Applications" where they explored nearly all trick to make FET stacks to work reliably. Short: it's near impossible to do it reliably with off the shelf part, and it's better to not to risk if you deal with 600A+ currents. And if are determined to do all tricks necessary, IGBTs or III-V materials will still win on simplicity and cost
- avian 7y ago1 mm of PTFE on a 10 kV cable is not even remotely close to human safe. Nick the insulation on such a cable and you turn your user into a quickly expanding cloud of plasma. Cables for that sorts of voltages and currents come heavily armored for mechanical stability, not only dielectric strength.
- londons_explore 7y agoA 100um thick layer of foil mid-way through the PTFE, together with capacitance testing between the conductor and the foil will allow software to detect any knicks before they get deep enough to do damage. Adds <5 grams to the weight. Also, any high voltage system would use a balanced +- non-ground-bonded (ie. floating) supply, so a human could touch one or other bare copper conductor without risk anyway. Far more user and environmentally friendly than todays engineering approach of "just make the insulation really thick and weigh a ton while the electronics are dumb and wouldn't even notice if you hammered a nail through the conductor".
- Kirby64 7y agoFeel free to develop a system that can provide high voltage cabling at a fraction of the cost of traditional methods if you think it's so easy. You'll have a boatload of money waiting for you. Also, there's already plenty of electronics in most cabling setups for EVs that definitely WOULD notice if you ran a nail through the conductors. What you're proposing just isn't safe.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoOthers have commented on technical feasibility already, but I want to point out, this is not sitting in an office powering a smoothie machine. It will be in contact with dust, dirt, debris and tools, and angry people. Your 1 mm of insulation will not last a week.
- loufe 7y agoNot to take away from your point, I know you weren't talking about mining, but it should be pointed out that in an active mine there would surely be at least 10mm of insulation to protect the cable from damage.
- tigershark 7y agoYes, probably with all the problems that are highlighted in the comments below that I’m not going to repeat. This seems to me a serious over-engineering problem. Why they didn’t think to use the battery swap in probably one of the few use cases where it makes sense?