5 ms·
Any article that congratulates hyoo-mons on their uniquely superior capacities instantly disqualifies itself from representing anything fundamentally correct.
by ncmncm 7y ago
Any article that congratulates hyoo-mons on their uniquely superior capacities instantly disqualifies itself from representing anything fundamentally correct.
Either (1) fundamental mathematical principles are universal, and every society that incrementally improves will converge on them, or (2) our mathematical principles are socially constructed, and other societies will evolve their own structures that may be closed to us. There is no middle ground.
There is, however, a third possibility: some of the universal fundamentals may be inaccessible to humans because of innate limitations in our savanna-evolved monkey brains, where aliens need not be so restricted. In other words, we (and everybody else) have access to the basics, but not everybody gets beyond the basics.
We can reasonably conclude that we have thus far only touched on the basics, because we have only just started looking. Whether we will progress beyond those basics has yet to be demonstrated. If civilization collapses as the natural world breaks under the strain put on it by industrial society, we might stop at this level. Or, if the number of people with mental capacity to comprehend increasing levels of sophistication declines, eventually it will reach one, and then zero.
Our only hope might be inventing machines that can progress beyond us, but they would then supplant us. The aliens might see no value in talking with us, but only with our machines, and we would never understand what they were saying to one another.
All of the above is the natural progression of the Copernican revolution: any assumption of specialness is flawed in exactly the degree by which it flatters us.