7 ms·
Related, they've figured it could generate 100% of present electricity needs https://edition.cnn.com/2019/10/25/business/offshore-wind-energy/index.html https:/
by tim333 7y ago
Related, they've figured it could generate 100% of present electricity needs https://edition.cnn.com/2019/10/25/business/offshore-wind-energy/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2019/10/25/business/offshore-wind-en...
- toomuchtodo 7y agoWith solar penetration increasing fast, and so much wind potential, it’s almost impossible not to transition off of fossil fuels rapidly. The economics are just too good to ignore. Storage isn't even an issue; we'll overbuild renewables and curtail as needed, which is cheap now (under 2 cents/kwh) and works until batteries come down in cost (which will happen).
- danans 7y agoWhat will stand in the way, at least for a bit, are interests that have tied their outlook to fossil fuels. In the case of transportation, its the oil industry down to the local gas stations. I think we should work from the bottom up to turn this case around. Incentivize gas stations to install rapid chargers, which will help to shift car buyers' mindsets. IIRC, gas stations make very little margin on gas anyways.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoI think about it the other way. Use land regulation to no longer permit zoning, permitting, or construction of gas new stations. If existing gas stations think they can compete as a place EVs will come charge, let them install vehicle charging hardware. More likely, gas stations lose out to places people will be at anyway to charge (grocery stores, work places, parking lots/structures, etc). I already Supercharge my Model S at the local grocery store if I've been driving more often than my 120V garage wall outlet can recover in range over a day or two (currently renting; when I buy, I'll pull 100amp service to the garage and never need to Supercharge locally again). Where do cars dwell for hours each day already (average vehicle isn't moving 90% of the time)? That's where you get chargers installed. The electricity and parking spots are usually already there, it's just a matter of getting the conduit, conductors, power conversion gear on site, installed, and painting and signing the parking spaces as EV only. In an EV future, gas stations are (mostly) a relic (IMHO). Think of the real estate cost savings, the reduction in truck traffic to deliver fuel, etc!
- saagarjha 7y ago> More likely, gas stations lose out to places people will be at anyway to charge (grocery stores, work places, parking lots/structures, etc). This isn’t economically practical unless you have subsidized charging. It’s significantly cheaper to charge my car at home than it is to use some random public charger.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoWe're not comparing home charging to fast charging though. We're comparing fast charging locations to other fast charging locations. Home charging is absolutely going to be cheaper due to no demand charges, but for where people elect to fast charge, you colocate where they will already be. At work places, you would want to provide charging current rates as high as possible without incurring demand charges. This is not to hand wave away street parking charging! This is definitely an issue, but there have been great strides in developing charging stations for street use (integrated into light poles, for example). Does you locale have Dig Once policies (call to action: get involved locally if they do not!)? Throw some fiber in there while you're upgrading street power! At home, I charge using power from Exelon's nuclear fleet at 1-6 cents/kwh (Time of Use plan). I want to stress: most people will plug in every time they arrive at home and charge at home. You will leave your house every day with a full charge by doing so. Supercharging costs me ~30 cents/kwh, so $10-15 for an 80% charge. Regardless, the costs are so low I don't care either way, I come out ahead versus gasoline (previously $40-60 per fill up) no matter how I charge. I literally don't even think about it when Tesla dings my credit card for Supercharging. It is annoying to use a J1772 public charger (install adapter, swipe Chargepoint card, troubleshoot why the station isn't providing current), so I avoid using those whenever possible. In the US, you are never more than 150 miles from a Tesla Supercharger, and of course the network will continue to grow over time: https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map
- danans 7y agoA motivating example for this is someone who drives the 80 miles from Austin TX to San Antonio to spend the day with friends. With only a 150mi range EV, a 15-20 min fast charge would be enough to comfortably do the return trip that same day without range anxiety. Existing gas stations (or parking lots) could serve that use case, which is fairly common in the US, where mid distance trips are almost completely car based. Today, they could charge the same or lower price/mile-of-range as gasoline and make a large margin, since electricity is less than half the price of gasoline per mile (at retail prices, there's an even bigger difference with wholesale prices).
- danans 7y agoHot off the press, looks like someone just did this: https://www.npr.org/2019/10/26/773446805/gas-station-converts-to-electric-charging-station-and-speeds-ahead-of-curve https://www.npr.org/2019/10/26/773446805/gas-station-convert...
- ThomPete 7y agoThere are a number of misunderstandings when it comes to wind and solar I wish more people were aware of. Wind and solar is only electricity. Electricity is 15-20 percent of our energy needs. Wind and solar needs backup sources from either gas, coal, nuclear or oil because of the intermittency issue and low capacity factor. Regardless of whether solar cells become cheaper, it makes energy more expensive as a whole because it makes the energy system more complex and as many might have learned in physics, starting up something take more energy than when it's up and running. This is true for coal plants too and with wind and solar being highly fluctuating and with highly fluctuating demands on the backup sources. The use of fossil fuel is increasing not decreasing more than wind and solar. You can't make either windmills or solar cells without fossil fuel. Wind and solar is only 1% of the worlds energy not projected to be much more than 3-4% in 2040. https://www.iea.org/weo/?fbclid=IwAR2LwDYcozvpGCOa3bIi2ieMbjuykZb0HY-p3ZByxMXDEIfH36ydeYbVaxs https://www.iea.org/weo/?fbclid=IwAR2LwDYcozvpGCOa3bIi2ieMbj... In other words, fossil fuels aren't going anywhere anytime soon.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agoElectricity can replace most energy needs. Whatever is left should be minimal (~5% total oil consumption, air travel, chemical processing, steel coking, etc). Coal and nuclear are already not cost competitive, if natural gas can't compete with batteries, it too will be left as a stranded asset. Natural gas is a perfect fit now for renewables, it throttles very fast and ramps every night for the steep duck curve in California. Batteries are even faster. Hundreds of GWs of annual battery production coming online across the world.
- ThomPete 7y agoFossil fuels are used for thousands of products everything from medicine to concrete to asphalt to pesticides, to solar cells, to windmills and machinery and manufacturing, etc. We are not even close to having the battery technology that will work with most things we use fossil fuels for today let alone replace the other products that come from fossil fuels. Fuel Cells are not even on the drawing board let alone at scale. With regard to nuclear, it's expensive because it's being demonized which creates all sorts of extra requirements which is part of what make it more expensive. Furhtermore nuclear is calculated at actual cost neither wind or solar is.
- vkou 7y ago> With solar penetration increasing fast, and so much wind potential, it’s almost impossible not to transition off of fossil fuels rapidly. How rapidly is it, really? Solar, wind, and geothermal currently supply 6% of global on-grid electricity consumption. But on-grid electricity is only 20% of our energy consumption. Every year, the rate of growth in coal and oil energy is greater than that of all solar deployment world-wide. The rate of growth in natural gas energy consumption is greater than that of all wind deployment world-wide. Let this sink in. The increase in the amount of fossil fuels that we burn, year, over-year, is greater than that of all existing solar and wind energy deployment. Wind and solar deployment is growing fast. But you know what's growing an order of magnitude faster? Fossil fuel use.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoEmail in profile. I am happy to discuss at length the path forward, but this thread is not the forum. Boils down to market forces and public policy. We are awash in clean energy.
- ThomPete 7y agoWind and solar is less then 1% of worlds energy today and not projected to be more than 3-4% in 2040. My guess is that it won't even be 2% by 2040.
- throwaway5752 7y agoPlastics, other chemicals, and energy density are problematic. I am a huge proponent of renewables but density, distribution, and inability (as of yet) to economically replace chemical feedstocks are the biggest issues I see.
- SEJeff 7y agoOne approach for renewable energy not always being available is molten salt: https://insideclimatenews.org/news/16012018/csp-concentrated-solar-molten-salt-storage-24-hour-renewable-energy-crescent-dunes-nevada https://insideclimatenews.org/news/16012018/csp-concentrated... It heats the salt up to 1050 degrees where it is essentially a liquid and uses that to produce steam to turn a turbine.
- xbmcuser 7y agoWe can also use the excess energy to do carbon capture as I think world moving off carbon wont be fast enough so using excess renewable energy in the future to remove carbon from the atmosphere.
- riffraff 7y agoWhile I would love for that to happen,I still haven't seen an obvious plan on how we're going to manage millions of electric cars in high density cities. It seems it will take decades before we have a pervasive enough grid, or effective charging techniques.
- achow 7y agoActually more than that.. But the maximum potential for offshore wind production is more than 120,000 gigawatts, or 11 times projected global electricity demand in 2040..