3 ms·
I think the answer is kind of obvious if you understand the foundations of mathematics. Any alien that was smart enough to manipulate written symbols according
by whatshisface 7y ago
I think the answer is kind of obvious if you understand the foundations of mathematics. Any alien that was smart enough to manipulate written symbols according to rules would agree that our induction rules applied to our axioms would lead to our theorems, because proofs are a purely symbolic game that even a computer can do. Aliens might not agree on the axioms or induction rules except by pure coincidence, because even within our own species there is disagreement over which axioms (choice for example) or induction rules (the excluded middle in intuitive mathematics for example) are self-evident.
The law of the excluded middle might seem obvious to you, but not to these guys:
https://plus.maths.org/content/intuitionism https://plus.maths.org/content/intuitionism
- BadThink6655321 7y agoA lambda calculus of two variables requires the law of the excluded middle, or it won’t work. The alphabet of the calculus has to be distinguishable and unambiguous.
- voxl 7y agoThe law of the excluded middle is about the truth status of any proposition. The fact that the alphabet of the language has to have a decidable equality does not mean the law of the excluded middle is true for any theory built from the lambda calculus. (Or true in general)
- jammygit 7y agoI personally hold that math is a science of sorts that is grounded in physical reality. What then if their maths were experimental in nature with less logical abstraction?
- whatshisface 7y agoThey could disagree about the emotional significance of abstract symbol games, but they wouldn't disagree about their conclusions.