8 ms·
Zen and the Art of Software Maintenance
- ssbsvvv 7y agoI feel every chapter from this book can be pulled out and can be converted into a blogpost in its own right. This blogpost touches only on a chapter of the book. Nevertheless, nice, short read.
- charlieflowers 7y agoAre you talking about “zen and the art...”, or are you talking about a book by the author of the blog post?
- emmelaich 7y agoThe Pirsig book, I'm sure.
- Insanity 7y agoI'll add to this that I recommend just reading the book as well instead of waiting for blog posts! :D It's a good book - well worth your time, in my opinion.
- jamil7 7y agoIt's my favourite part of the book and really resonated with me at the time.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoIn Pirsig's second book, Lila, he returns to examine what the romantic-classical synthesis looks like from another perspective: the moral perspective. He imagines the moral qualities of the world. What are the moral qualities of a motorcycle? How ought a motorcycle to behave? Pirsig proposes a thought experiement, the "chemistry teacher" experiment, where a chemistry teacher is left on a beach to rot. Through this experiment, he concludes that the morality of chemical objects, of atoms and molecules, is precisely the rules of chemistry. Indeed, Pirsig supposes that most of the natural world is like this, where things do as they ought already. (I would close the door by suggesting that, in the Discordian tradition, the morality of people, and indeed any sapient creature, is to do as we like. This not only neatly lines up with Pirsig's philosophy, but also gives that the Free Will Theorem still holds and is useful!) So, what is the morality of software and computers? The morality of physical computers is quantum electronics, and the morality of software is information theory and mathematics itself. I'm humbled.
- maxerickson 7y agoMetaphysics considers the possibility of a universes with properties different than ours. If such things exist, then things in our universe behave as they are more than any ought.
- dekken_ 7y agoMetaphysics is more philosophy than physics
- maxerickson 7y agoYeah, I must be pretty confused to post a comment about metaphysics in reply to a comment discussing the morality of chemistry.
- defined 7y agoSadly, I did not enjoy _Lila_ nearly as much as ZATAOMM. It seemed to be less organized or something.
- tjridesbikes 7y agoAfter I read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, I went and bought myself a ‘71 Honda CB350, almost the exact bike Pirsig rode in his book. I found that fixing this motorcycle, taking it apart, fixing internal component, figuring out how everything ties together, and upgrading worn out or otherwise non-functional components, and putting it all back together, felt extraordinarily similar to my day job as a software engineer. There’s even the same “loop”: fix one thing, turn it on to test, then turn it off again and fix the next thing. The turnaround time is waaaaayy slower, and there’s a lot more opportunity to hurt yourself, but the skills as a programmer translate very well to motorcycle maintenance. Interesting to see that I’m not the only one who sees these similarities.
- jypepin 7y agoI've seen "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" recommended on book threads on HN multiple times, by multiple people, so I would agree that yes, a lot of other engineers see the similarities! The way the author explains how to go about to find the issue, fix it, etc. has made me much calmer about finding my own bugs and fixing them indeed.
- forinti 7y agoThere's a passage (page 123 in my edition) I really like about combining your mental model of something with the stimuli you get from your senses that I think has a lot to do with systems analysis and modelling. You have to build up your mental model (and often your client's too) and, at the same time, evolve your interface to reflect this model and permit your client to do what he wants to do effectively.
- dfraser992 7y agoI recommend you investigate plumbing. Yeah, seriously.... I have not done anything very complicated, but it takes much of the same mindset (or skillset), it is satisfying, and you will have a job for life (aka I have just hit 50 and sort-of age discrimination (or just can't deal with the nonsense anymore-ness - or everything is so familiar it is so tedious))
- 7y ago
- whalesalad 7y agoEveryone in our circle of nerds recommends this book and all three times I tried to read it I found it absolutely unbearable. It collects dust in a donation box that I haven’t mustered the strength to carry down to goodwill. Does anyone else share this sentiment? Did you ever crack the reason why so many love it? Obviously taste is subjective and we are not all supposed to like everything but I’ve always felt like the odd man out with this specific text.
- gen_greyface 7y agoSame here. This problem of feeling left out may not be there if the person who recommends it also provides the reason he recommends it for.
- lincolnq 7y agoI only liked it a little bit but was recommended by someone for whom it was their favorite book ever. I only really took away one thing from the book (some deeper level of understanding of what is meant by "quality", in the sense of craftsmanship). I value that understanding and am happy I read the book, but I don't use that wisdom very often in my life. Maybe you're reading it in a way which expects it to have a plot? I don't know, I think book recs are generally hard and people should only trust book recommendations from people who like books for the same reasons.
- wsinks 7y agoI took away the parable about the broken motorcycle flummoxed by a screw. As a kid, I didn't want to take things apart. It's breaking the rules, usually. But when something is already broken, then the rules change, and this book gave me language for that.
- Haul4ss 7y agoI slogged through it. I appreciate the sentiments expressed in the book, but it was not a breezy read. I found it to be dry and long-winded.
- cm2012 7y ago
- LostInTheWoods2 7y agoAt the end of day, the customer does not care if, for example, you implemented their project as giant if-then conditional; as long as it works. It is the craftsman in us that makes us write quality code; it is something we ultimately do for ourselves.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoAt the end of the day, it's a lot less likely to work if you write a giant if condition. So yes, the customer won't care why it works or doesn't - but quality code has impacts they can feel.
- indigochill 7y agoMy experience has also been it's a not-entirely-Zen experience extending giant if conditions even if they technically work fine for the current use case.
- ep103 7y agoI hate this sentiment so, so much. Let's take it out of the realm of software for a moment. Let's use the motorcycle metaphor, since this is a ZATAOMM thread. At the end of the day, the customer does not care if, for example, you fixed their bike sloppyily, quickly, or haphazardly; as long as it works. It is the craftsman in us that makes us care about the nature of our work. It is something we ultimately do for ourselves. Bullshit! It is true that no customer is going to care how we organize our tools in the mechanics garage. We should not be having long arguments about whether 2 storage cabinets or one make more sense for holding our screwdrivers. If at the end of the day, the radiator is replaced in the same way, and the coolant is cycling correctly, then both the slow and steady and the quick and haphazard mechanics did a good job, however they accomplished this fact. But the ENTIRE POINT of the book, is that these two mechanics WILL NOT accomplish the same job. Sure, they may both deliver the same result in 7 out of every 10 jobs they are given, but those last 3 matter! And are almost certainly going to be the hardest of the 10. More direct to your point, however, customers ABSOLUTELY DO care whether we replace the radiator with a cheap chinese knockoff that's likely to break in 1k miles, or the 5x more expensive overseas german version. And they ABSOLUTELY do care if the haphazard mechanic or the slow thoughtful tedious one does the job. They just don't all care equally. Some customers want the cheap chinese knockoff (the giant if-then conditional). If it doesn't work, they'll just throw away the bike and buy a new one. Other customers want the german and thoughtful mechanic, and will pay accordingly. Its about knowing who your client is and why.