4 ms·
I am really having trouble understanding this project... how would this be a good way to feed people? It has so much technology to produce so little food, and r
by cortesoft 7y ago
I am really having trouble understanding this project... how would this be a good way to feed people? It has so much technology to produce so little food, and requires consistent power and internet... can anyone explain why this would be a good idea?
- catalogia 7y agoThe premise of this project was that it would allow farmers to run parallel experiments to discover optimal growing conditions. The "food computers" were meant to inform large-scale production, not replace it. The problem is this sort of matter is of course already studied by agricultural departments around the world, with a lot more competency. There is already a ton of research into, e.g. the effects of soil pH on potato production. Media Lab's food computer seems like a case of NIH, and probably wouldn't have happened if MIT had an agricultural department.
- khawkins 7y ago"It's the white man's burden to take care of these uncultured peoples and give them the science to feed themselves."
- mc32 7y agoYour words are a bit incendiary but the gist is right. This guy thinks he’s redeeming himself and is a good man because he came up with a cockamamie idea that on first blush could seem altruistic, but, my word, you have to be worse than tone deaf to propose something as impractical as this as some kind of actual solution. Incredible! Usually people on LSD might conjure up something like this but come back to reality when it wears off.
- Laforet 7y agoMy impression is that it wasn't exactly pitched as a substitute for food aid, but more as a recreational project to provide moral support for the refugees, and perhaps some micronutrients on the side. Overall it's not too bad for a concept but the execution clearly prioritised asethetics over utility. It does tick all the boxes for an attractive startup though: - Disruptive tech - Charismatic (?) founder - Peer-reviewed research - Open source - Internet of things - Benefits the environment - Contributes to world peace - $insert_random_progressive_agenda_here As impractical as it is, nobody should be surprised by the fact that it got so much traction over the years. Even more far fetched projects such as roads paved with solar panels[0] and various kinds of atmospheric water harvesters[1] are still being actively funded and developed as we speak, despite overwhelming evidence that they are never going to be economically viable. [0]:https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Roadways https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_Roadways [1]:https://m.phys.org/news/2017-04-device-air-powered-sun.html https://m.phys.org/news/2017-04-device-air-powered-sun.html
- abeppu 7y agoAs a recreational project with "perhaps some micronutrients" as a side, gardening without the box would work too.
- catalogia 7y agoYeah, but how do you turn "perhaps refugees would enjoy gardening" into a TED talk?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jrochkind1 7y agoAnd how do you turn it into money to pay yourself and your lab nice salaries? Which is of course the point of the TED talk, it's marketing. For you, not for refugees. Refugees can garden without paying American academics six figure salaries to pretend to help them do it. Helping refugees sounds nice, but if it doesn't result in very comfortable salaries for non-refugee Americans, what's the point of that? Much preferable to pay American academics to pretend to help refugees -- get your priorities straight man!
- paulgerhardt 7y agoAs a recent twitter rant against the Media Lab food computers went[1] - massive indoor farming operations basically already work this way and have in fact ironed out most of the bugs. There just happens to not be so much cross-pollination between traditional A&M schools and the Media Lab. It should be noted that land grant schools were solely set up all over the country a hundred and fifty years ago to tackle exactly this domain of problems and not without some irony that MIT is one. [1] https://twitter.com/sarahtaber_bww/status/1171895657872941056?s=21 https://twitter.com/sarahtaber_bww/status/117189565787294105...
- DonHopkins 7y ago>There just happens to not be so much cross-pollination between traditional A&M schools and the Media Lab. MIT's Robotic Bees will solve that problem. https://futurism.com/mit-researchers-give-the-robot-bee-a-major-upgrade https://futurism.com/mit-researchers-give-the-robot-bee-a-ma...
- angry_octet 7y agoIf you mark such posts with <humor> it will be easier for users to down vote them.
- chillingeffect 7y agoI thought the same thing when I saw them start that at the ML a few years back... but in following this fracas, I've learned massive indoor growops are doing something related but different: They're optimizing growth cycles for efficient crops, as opposed to diversity. There's nothing wrong with that. It's just food computers are more about synthesizing a climate to grow pathologically diverse food. It's not a bad idea. Caleb Harper just did bad things.
- Lazare 7y agoIt's a great idea, if you do it right, and scale it up, which is what industry had been doing for decades. The problem with the MIT version is it was a toy, that also didn't work, and was developed by people who had no grasp of the problem space. If you look at a Hasbro Easy-Bake Oven, it would be easy to discount "ovens" as a good way of cooking food. They're too small, and the incandescent bulbs don't produce enough heat. How could anyone thing this was a good idea? It is...unfortunate...that the MIT name was attached to a group of people trying to pass off shoddy malfunctioning knockoffs of toys as new innovation.
- olalonde 7y agoSame, I just don't see a viable ROI. I'm not a farmer but it looks like their "food computer" could produce the calorie equivalent of one meal per month at most?