4 ms·
It's too fragmented for that to really be a first class concern. "Christian" is a broad class that encompasses LDS, Jehovah's Witnesses, Presbyterian, Baptist,
by tyingq 7y ago
It's too fragmented for that to really be a first class concern. "Christian" is a broad class that encompasses LDS, Jehovah's Witnesses, Presbyterian, Baptist, Catholic, etc. We have no shortage of controversy and conflict to debate about.
On this particular topic, I'd be more interested in the Italian opinion.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoUm not sure about all of those being "technically" "Christian"
- tyingq 7y agoCurious why you think that. From my POV, they are all very "Christian".
- jki275 7y agoFrom the perspective of any Protestant or Catholic, LDS and Jehovah’s Witness are not Christian churches. In general, outside of their circles, those two are considered heretical cults. Protestants and Catholics generally disagree on many doctrinal things, but they agree on that.
- schoen 7y agoWhy Italian?
- ekianjo 7y agoThe Vatican probably?
- lsc 7y agoso, uh, I thought the kjv was... not recognized as valid by the catholic church? Like, the KJV was authorized by the church of England, a, uh, rather different body from the Vatican. I thought a lot of what made the KJV important was that it was early in that split. I mean, i suppose that the Vatican would probably still have a pretty interesting opinion on it.
- schoen 7y agoAnother commenter elsewhere in this thread just mentioned the Preface to the KJV, which includes some specific criticism of the Catholic Church (referred to as "our chief adversaries") for (at the time) disapproving of vernacular language editions of the Bible. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Bible_(King_James)/Preface#%C2%A710_The_unwillingness_of_our_chief_adversaries,_that_the_Scriptures_should_be_divulged_in_the_mother_tongue,_etc https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Bible_(King_James)/Preface#%C....
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoPretty sure the Muslims were always their chief adversaries.
- schoen 7y agoI misunderstood a detail here: this section admits that the Catholic Church sponsored an English translation (the Douay-Rheims Bible) but complains that this translation was itself made in response to pressure from Protestants, and that Catholics were expected to seek permission from church authorities in order to read it. So I probably shouldn't have said "disapproving of" but rather something like "grudgingly permitting" or "restricting access to".
- lsc 7y agoI actually had no idea that the catholic church permitted an english translation so early.
- emmelaich 7y agoIt's not that that the KJV is not "valid". It's that it's not recommended over the Catholic version. The Catholic version contains the "deuterocanonical" books of the Old Testament. https://bustedhalo.com/ministry-resources/why-doesnt-the-catholic-church-recognize-the-king-james-version-of-the-bible https://bustedhalo.com/ministry-resources/why-doesnt-the-cat... PS. [mentioned in the article] Apparently the original KJV did include the deuterocanonical books, but they were not considered canon. The Puritans and non-English protestants were the first to omit them entirely.
- tyingq 7y agoBecause they have the most influence on things "Christian" and the best historical material.
- doggydogs94 7y agoI can tell by your your response that you are not a Christian.
- tyingq 7y agoRoman Catholic raised, agnostic. Irish descent and dissolutioned might be more interested in the historical source than the destination.
- emmelaich 7y agoSimilar. Fascinating to me was that some Catholics consider the "Roman" a bit of slur. But to me it was a common, unremarkable description.
- tyingq 7y agoYour profile says "greybeard", "skeptic" and "computers" so probably VERY similar backgrounds. Skimming your comments now to confirm :) Edit: Early, but see Apollo/HP, SunOS/Solaris already. Small world. Any chance of early 1990s Linux, Kermit, Windows packet drivers, KA9Q, Unicos, Mosaic, AT&T 3B2, Pyramid OSX, Usenet, UUCP, C, Perl, TCL, etc?
- emmelaich 7y agoAll those and more. Except for the 3b2. Not much Tcl.
- tyingq 7y agoKarnac says you're 54ish and from the Northeast US or Ireland or maybe UK ;) I suspect not US, which makes the shared experience more interesting, as the world in general wasn't particularly very global at the time, yet we have a remarkably shared experience (I'm EU born, US bred). Yay early (late 80's / early 90's) Internet. This is one of those rare HN moments that I wish more would notice.