16 ms·
I understand your viewpoint, and to be honest I was on the fence about posting names, but I decided to for 2 important reasons: 1. First, the info is totally p
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I understand your viewpoint, and to be honest I was on the fence about posting names, but I decided to for 2 important reasons:
1. First, the info is totally public and easily viewable in any case.
2. I think there is a danger in just saying "It was an organizational decision." When everyone is "responsible", then no one is. And in addition, both of the people mentioned are senior execs at the company. Having to deal with public scrutiny is one reason they get paid more.
I do give GitLab a lot of credit for being transparent, and for (at least for now) backing off this decision. But I hope they are able to do a deeper root cause analysis of what went wrong. While obviously on a whole other order of magnitude, Boeing didn't fuck up because MCAS was a faulty piece of software, they fucked up because they let financial concerns take precedence over engineering ones.
EDIT: one other thing, since I brought up 2 folks who I think made poor decisions, I should have pointed out Lukas Eipert (@leipert), who was the engineer who originally brought up his strong objections. Even more telling, when Eipert was asked to re-review the code change, he explicitly asked to be taken off the review - his sentiment was clear.