6 ms·
I'm a little younger than Woz, and I am skeptical we'll have truly autonomous self-driving cars in my lifetime. Three thoughts: 1. Any of us who work in softw
by mindcrime 7y ago
I'm a little younger than Woz, and I am skeptical we'll have truly autonomous self-driving cars in my lifetime.
Three thoughts:
1. Any of us who work in software development know that "getting to 90% done is easy... it's the second 90% that gets you". And I believe that to the extent that we may seem to be 90% of the way to self-driving cars, it's definitely the "first 90%" not the second. The devil truly is in the details.
2. From what I've seen / heard, it seems that most of the testing done to date has been done in day-time, on limited access, smooth, flat, straight roads, OR urban surface streets where traffic speeds are relatively slow. I believe the leap from either of those environments to "any arbitrary twisty, curvy, back-country road, at night, when it's foggy and snowing", is quite substantial. And I don't consider a car truly autonomous unless it can handle those conditions at least as well as a human (to be fair, humans don't always handle those conditions well, so maybe this bar isn't as high as it seems).
3. I've developed software for 20 years... knowing how the sausage is made, seeing the compromises that are made in order to "hit the ship date", the bugs that are swept under the rug, the boundary conditions that are assumed away as "impossible", etc., I won't be trusting any self-driving car anytime soon.
- steelframe 7y ago> knowing how the sausage is made, seeing the compromises that are made in order to "hit the ship date", the bugs that are swept under the rug, the boundary conditions that are assumed away as "impossible", etc., I won't be trusting any self-driving car anytime soon. As a general member of the public who is present on the roads, you have no choice but to trust any Alpha- or Beta-level self-driving technology that certain companies thrust out on the roads today.
- pkulak 7y agoI think we're at least one CS breakthrough away, and how do you put a timeline on that? Kinda like how speech recognition was just almost there for decades until modern ML made it actually as good as a human being.
- ozten 7y ago> ML made it actually as good as a human being How ML made it usable in some cases, would be more accurate. I still can't ask Alexa to play specific albums or tracks most of the time. I don't want that level of accuracy driving cars on the road.
- shsjxjbsbs 7y agoGoogle seems to have no trouble playing music from Spotify for me. It can even manage it while I yell my song requests from the shower.
- rsj_hn 7y agoThe only thing I have ever wanted from phone assistants is to tell me whether a coffee shop was open or not, or what the closing time is. I still can't get this info, nor is this question understood. I still have to stop, launch a browser, navigate to the site, and dig around their website for opening hours, or in the worst case find a phone number and call to ask them.
- adriftincode 7y agoWhat phone assistants are you using? I’ve never had this problem.
- rsj_hn 7y agoSiri
- adriftincode 7y agoSame here, Siri solves this problem. Me: “Hey Siri, how late is x open?” Siri: One possibility is on x street, does that sound good? Me: Yes Siri: “X is open from y-z.”
- yumraj 7y agoI agree. In my various conversations on this topic around the bay area, people are generally overly optimistic, who believe it'll happen in next couple or so years, and people who are overly pessimistic. Possibly a gross generalization but generally the people who are overly pessimistic are the ones who are or have till recently been engineers, while the people who are overly optimistic are the ones further away from engineering - with the farther they are the more optimistic they are. Moreover, in addition to what you wrote there are a lot of other open questions, not necessarily in any order and definitely not a complete list: 1) Auto Insurance (cars below refers to fully autonomous cars): 1.1) What happens to auto insurance? Do I still need to buy it if I'm not driving it, or does it come bundled in the car price? 1.2) Does everyone pay the same auto insurance for the same car model/year. 1.3) Do cars with different autonomous models have different auto insurance? 1.4) What happens in the case of car accident between self-driving and non-self driving car? 1.5) What happens in the case of two self-driving cars' accident 1.6) What happens if a person is killed due to the Car's fault. Who is liable? The insurance company? The Car manufacturer? The self-driving module manufacturer? 2) Some Edge cases 2.1) What happens if on a 4-way stop 4 self-driving cars come to stop at the same time? Do they know how to handle that, as in which car is moving forward and which one is allowing other cars? 2.2) What happens in an emergency? Can I force my car to drive rash to the hospital or will it follow the speed limit to the T. 2.3) What happens if the Car runs into a situation which it is not trained for? 3) How are the cars tested? 3.1) As a consumer do we know that the cars are fully tested to handle ALL edge conditions? 3.1.1) What is the definition/definitive list of ALL edge conditions? 3.2) When will we know that the threshold has been passed, and the car is truly autonomous? 4) Security 4.1) Assuming the cars will need to be connected, how will the security be? 4.2) Can the cars be Pwned? I'm sure they can be.... so this is the rhetorical question 4.2.2) If the cars can be pwned, will the fully autonomous cars become the next WMD (Weapon of Mass Destruction) -- if you don't agree, close your eyes and imagine a fleet of hundreds of thousands or millions of fully autonomous cars under the control of a rogue entity hell bent on causing damage/killing people. 4.2.3) How do we protect against that?
- aeternum 7y ago1) Car insurance can work exactly like it currently does. The car owner's insurance is liable by default, however if the car itself is in some way at fault (performing out-of-spec), then the insurance company goes after the car company. This can already happen if something like brakes fail or accelerator gets stuck. 2 & 3) Yes there are some edge cases that you can't train for, but same with humans. What do humans do in an edge case like a torrential downpour? Simply pull over. Even if there are edge cases, consider that humans are pretty bad drivers on average, over 1.25 million deaths per year, and 50 million injuries in the US alone. Suppose that in a couple years, self driving cars are not perfect due to the edge cases, and still cause 250k deaths / year. Would you allow them at that point? Even with those stats we should consider only allowing self-driving cars and begin to outlaw human drivers.