4 ms·
> my eye was on the babies, and I couldn’t help but notice that one of them was chubbier, calmer and more beautiful than the others. My baby alone ... was much
by gumby 7y ago
> my eye was on the babies, and I couldn’t help but notice that one of them was chubbier, calmer and more beautiful than the others. My baby alone ... was much better than any of the others. Why wasn’t anyone remarking on this?
I am fascinated by this phenomenon. I remember my kid being in a school play when he was young: everybody who wanted could be in it and they clearly added trivial non-speaking spots for kids who might not have passed an audition but still wanted to be on stage. He had one of those! Yet whenever he was on the stage he just dominated -- expanded to fill the whole field of view. At least for me. I really recognized this phenomenon years later when I watched another play which had two kids in its cast who were really good. Probably the first time I really noticed that there were even other kids on the stage.
As for new parents groups: they really are for mothers and aren't about the babies. So I understand what she felt ("It was around the time I abandoned my third or fourth new moms group that I began to consider the possibility that I might be the problem."). And I mean mothers: as a father I was clearly not welcome (this was back in the late 1990s). At the park I was definitely viewed with suspicion by the other mothers even though I was a regular, and none would really talk to me (that's OK, I had EE times and the NYRB). Back then I was the only father pushing a pram around downtown Palo Alto in the middle of the day, and certain segments of the population clearly treated me with scorn. After the 2000 crash I saw more fathers doing this and I hope this has changed to some extent.
Interestingly at a party this phenomenon didn't appear, which I feel was due to context: if I was carrying a baby I believe the presumption was this was a dad being cute and "helping out" and that the rest of the child rearing was done by the mother (in fact she did a lot but had no patience for the American baby rituals). I saw this play out in other countries when I had the baby (and later child).
I don't agree that the child controls the process, but rather the child is a big responsibility, and that controls the process. Frankly owning a home is a lot of responsibility too, but the home is not in control.
- osullivj 7y agoRe school play: the phenomenon also neatly explains why Gene Hackman's line as Royal in The Tenenbaum's - "just a bunch of kids in animal costumes" - is so funny.
- cjcenizal 7y agoReally appreciate your post! I'm a dad who also takes an active role in raising and nurturing his kids. I agree with your point at the end about responsibility, but another way of looking at the author's reframing of "parenting" as "childing" is that the parent is also on the receiving end of the experience. As a parent I've found I've learned a tremendous amount of patience, humility, perspective, perseverance, and self-awareness from the role, so I found a lot of truth in that idea.
- technothrasher 7y ago> At the park I was definitely viewed with suspicion by the other mothers even though I was a regular, and none would really talk to me Interesting. My experience as the only dad at the parks with my young child was that all the moms wanted to come tell me what a great thing it was that I was there, and how they were really proud of me for doing it. It felt very condescending and awkward.
- gumby 7y agoCould be a cultural shift — this was 1998-early 2000s
- technothrasher 7y agoCould be, I was doing it in '06-'09 time period. Also could be different part of the country, as I'm in MA.
- nostrademons 7y agoBaby goggles. Your own kid is clearly the most talented/intelligent/cute of the bunch. It's probably an adaptive response, because any kid whose parents thought other kids were more talented/intelligent/cute probably didn't survive long in our ancestral environment. Mom's groups are still for moms (I think this is because they often discuss mom-things where they don't want men around), but the park and downtown have become a shared spaces. I don't get strange looks for taking my kid to the playground, about half the parents there are dads (more on Sunday morning), sometimes moms or other dads will even talk to me. I do remember my dad (a househusband back in the 80s) complaining about how he'd get lots of strange glances taking my sister and me to the playground.
- souprock 7y ago"as a father I was clearly not welcome" I've experienced this. I tried to volunteer with the summer band camp my daughter was in. The volunteers were all mothers. I got lots of vaguely accusatory questions, and then got turned away. The implication was that I was some sort of threat. Things can go a different way too. I've heard of other fathers getting lots of unwelcome romantic attention from the mothers.