4 ms·
> until the root cause is addressed: income inequality. There isn't any evidence for that root cause though. If someone has a comfortable, secure life with foo
by roenxi 7y ago
> until the root cause is addressed: income inequality.
There isn't any evidence for that root cause though. If someone has a comfortable, secure life with food and shelter they aren't going to be unhappy no matter how much someone else has.
Fixing "income inequality" completely misses the actual root cause. I don't know what the root cause is, but I have lived next to some people who were substantially wealthier than I was and I didn't feel anything negative. Some inequality is healthy and nobody knows how much is ideal.
- H8crilA 7y ago> someone has a comfortable, secure life with food and shelter That's the thing, they don't. If they did I'd agree with you that the problem isn't very bad. You just don't see it around you. If you don't believe me search the FRED database for rent inflation and median wages, for example. Human brain is desperate for explanations. Populism is getting a lot of votes at the moment - people will prefer something that at least attempts to explain their pain over something that denies that the pain exists. "Drain the swamp" by Donal Trump and "Tax the rich" by Democratic hopefuls like Elizabeth Warren.
- roenxi 7y agoBut you have identified a root cause that wouldn't cause the problems you are observing. If I changed things (eg, for sake of argument, a highly effective welfare program combined with non-transfer-payment spending cuts and a tax cut to the wealthy) inequality could increase and the problem could go away at the same time. So the root cause is somewhere in the direction of 'people can't comfortable, secure and resourced'. That isn't related to inequality - people can be safe, comfortable, resourced and unequal. Root cause has a specific meaning; I'm basically saying I've done root cause analysis professionally and you havn't actually picked a root cause. You've picked something closer to a guess at a solution.
- H8crilA 7y agoInequality is the problem because everything happens in a single market. Rich people push the real estate market high and suddenly no affordable housing exists. I actually think that the FED is largely responsible for this setup. Unintended consequences of QE and cheap money - everything is now expensive. Same as the seeds for 2008 were laid out in the post-dotcom ultralow interest rates.
- dragonwriter 7y agoCongress is responsible, because the reason the Fed had to push so heavily on blunt monetary policy levers is because Congress has been asleep at the switch on more targetable fiscal policy remedies to economic problems. Monetary policy alone is useful for smoothing some of the edges of business cycles, but it's not—and not intended to be—the alpha and omega of economic policy.
- H8crilA 7y agoConcurrence has been reached, sir. I am (mostly because I like interesting things) hoping to see the most stupid form of fiscal stimulus in the next deflationary recession - money handouts. It'd be interesting to see what happens if instead of buying $300B worth of bonds the FED with the help of the Treasury just airdrops $1000 into each citizen's bank account. Perhaps start with $100 and see how it goes. Anyhow, not sure if with this polarity the authorities could reach consensus on such drastic measures.
- clucas 7y ago> If someone has a comfortable, secure life with food and shelter they aren't going to be unhappy no matter how much someone else has. I believe there are studies showing that relative inequality is a factor in people's happiness. Here is literally the first link on the first search I did: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0276562417302123 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S027656241... Now, I'm sure you could make strong critiques of those sorts of studies, and I would probably agree with all our most of them. But ignoring the literature as you are is not likely to convince the people who actually need to be convinced. (And saying "well, I didn't experience it when I lived next to a rich person" is not going to go over well.)
- roenxi 7y agoWell, how equal are you to your neighbour? I don't even know, I couldn't answer that question if it were put to me. Might be 10x as wealthy as my neighbour, 100x, 1x, 1/2x. I seriously don't know and I'm pretty sure they don't either. People are notoriously bad at estimating wealth inequality. Something that they can't detect can't be the root cause of their unhappiness.
- clucas 7y agoMy neighbor parenthetical was in direct response your own claim that you lived next to someone way wealthier than you, and it didn't make you feel bad. And, just because people are bad at estimating something doesn't mean that they can't detect it, or that they won't make decisions (conscious or unconscious) based on their bad estimate. Frankly, with the moving of the goalposts and clearly specious reasoning, I'm having a very difficult time believing you're arguing in good faith.
- roenxi 7y ago> Frankly, with the moving of the goalposts and clearly specious reasoning, I'm having a very difficult time believing you're arguing in good faith. I don't have any specific advice. Trying harder often doesn't work for that sort of thing; maybe try meditation or some other activity to make you relaxed and reflective? > And, just because people are bad at estimating something doesn't mean that they can't detect it Not in the general case, but in this specific case it is pretty clear that they can't detect it. That is central to my point - inequality can't be the root cause because people can't detect it and there is no reason to be unhappy about inequality specifically even if they could. > My neighbor parenthetical was in direct response your own claim that you lived next to someone way wealthier than you, and it didn't make you feel bad. So which inequality is the problem? It is much easier to go to the actual problem - people struggling to make ends meet. That isn't an inequality problem.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIncome inequality includes the root cause, but more besides. It's not just that some people got really rich. It's that some other people got significantly poorer. If I were to take a shot at a root cause, I would say globalization. The business owners got lower costs, so they made more money. The factory workers got laid off, and eventually their unemployment benefits ran out. That created income inequality, all right, but the real problem is that a bunch of people lost jobs that supported middle-class lifestyles, and didn't find comparable replacement jobs. Increasing globalization may be a net win. But it happened too fast for people to adjust, and it destroyed a bunch of people.