3 ms·
Except the whole thing about increasing rural white poverty is largely a myth caused by failure to properly analyze the data. Adjusted for cost of living, rural
by rayiner 7y ago
Except the whole thing about increasing rural white poverty is largely a myth caused by failure to properly analyze the data. Adjusted for cost of living, rural areas have lower poverty rates: https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2006/november/adjusting-for-living-costs-can-change-who-is-considered-poor https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2006/november/adjusting.... Employment suffered less during the Great Recession in rural areas than in urban areas. Many of the places tagged with the travails of white rural people, in the Midwest, have some of the highest incomes for rural people relative to urban people in the country.
- _iyig 7y agoYour link only examines data up to 2003, accounts only for poverty vs. other measures of economic opportunity, and does not account for the steeper decline in life expectancy among white Americans vs. other groups.
- rayiner 7y agoOther sources show the trend only getting better through the recession.
- bart_spoon 7y agoThen link them.
- roenxi 7y agoAdjusting for cost of living is a little bit risky though; because part of what that means is that they don't buy things they can't afford. It doesn't matter how low the cost of living goes; a rural hospital is not going to have the same resources as a city-centre hospital attached to a university with a strong medical research focus. And there are probably other confounding factors; eg, it may be much more difficult for a homeless individual to exist in a rural town than a city - the stats would show that as more homeless in the city, even though the ambient conditions are better. So sure the stats say that there is more poverty in the cities - but that might just be signalling that poverty is much more painful in rural areas. This means that people could be saying things that are technically wrong (hence the myth) but are very accurate to the lived experiences and pressures on someone in a rural area.
- rayiner 7y ago> Adjusting for cost of living is a little bit risky though; because part of what that means is that they don't buy things they can't afford. It doesn't matter how low the cost of living goes; a rural hospital is not going to have the same resources as a city-centre hospital attached to a university with a strong medical research focus. Only a small number of people need things that a rural hospital can not offer. Meanwhile, everyone needs things (food, housing, etc.) that are much more expensive in the city. Likewise, cheap housing can mean that it’s much easier to afford to live in a decent school district. And the same amount of government funding for say schools goes further in rural areas. In NAEP tests, rural schools perform comparably to suburban schools, and better than urban schools: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/figures/images/figure-tla-5b.png https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/figures/images/figure-tla-5...
- codingslave 7y agoCan I have some of what youre smoking?!